• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

QB Tavien St. Clair (Official Thread)

And tOSU claims both of them, much like Joe Burrows....
OSU never claimed Joe's Heisman. All that was ever said was Joe himself says he'll always be a Buckeye and he gives OSU a lot of credit for making him a better player even though he was never the starter. He got his his degree at OSU after all.
 
Upvote 0

What many of us have been saying regarding TSC


Day has had the luck of not really having to play the backup or having been put in the position to play the QB who wasn't ready until now. I bet we would be in this same situation if Day was the coach and it was the QB who is understood the offense on paper better than someone like Braxton Miller or Terrelle Pryor that had the physical skills but might have not master the playbook.

Truly I'm not sure Day has done a good job adjusting his offense when necessary to the QB. The ironic part of this is Fahey is limiting the offense despite him most likely knowing the offense in his head and most likely being able to go through reads better than St Clair. Fahey's size, accuracy, and his lack of willingness to throw mid to deep is limiting the offense. Everytime he moves out of the pocket or they roll him out he is cutting his reads. That would be all fine if he was able to make completions and keep the offense moving. At critical times, his accuracy has killed drives despite him making the right read. Throwing high, throwing in the dirt, or throwing to a receiver before he makes his break have basically killed drive or led to interceptions.

Day and the staff could limit the offense and all the read with St Clair but he might actually be better at making those completions or making plays out of nothing with his feet. The other part is this offense is so focused on getting Jeremiah Smith the ball, that it's not really that necessary for St Clair to make more than 1 or 2 reads.

At least when the coaches are designing plays to limit the QBs reads, they are designing it to go to a certain player and they are making the decision to where to limit the field and reads. With Fahey if they are giving him the full offense, he is making those decisions to limit the offense on his own and on the fly.
 
Upvote 0
Day has had the luck of not really having to play the backup or having been put in the position to play the QB who wasn't ready until now. I bet we would be in this same situation if Day was the coach and it was the QB who is understood the offense on paper better than someone like Braxton Miller or Terrelle Pryor that had the physical skills but might have not master the playbook.

Truly I'm not sure Day has done a good job adjusting his offense when necessary to the QB. The ironic part of this is Fahey is limiting the offense despite him most likely knowing the offense in his head and most likely being able to go through reads better than St Clair. Fahey's size, accuracy, and his lack of willingness to throw mid to deep is limiting the offense. Everytime he moves out of the pocket or they roll him out he is cutting his reads. That would be all fine if he was able to make completions and keep the offense moving. At critical times, his accuracy has killed drives despite him making the right read. Throwing high, throwing in the dirt, or throwing to a receiver before he makes his break have basically killed drive or led to interceptions.

Day and the staff could limit the offense and all the read with St Clair but he might actually be better at making those completions or making plays out of nothing with his feet. The other part is this offense is so focused on getting Jeremiah Smith the ball, that it's not really that necessary for St Clair to make more than 1 or 2 reads.

At least when the coaches are designing plays to limit the QBs reads, they are designing it to go to a certain player and they are making the decision to where to limit the field and reads. With Fahey if they are giving him the full offense, he is making those decisions to limit the offense on his own and on the fly.

To me it's not so much adapt the offense to the talent on hand but, you have a very clear system created- why doesn't the talent on hand fit it?

Day built this NFL level passing game offense. He had a couple of home run QB's and Hartline cranking out the WR talent at a level no one has ever seen. Ok great- now you have Smith who is so generational No ONe on earth is going to do anything but GHTGDB.

Then you lose the latest QB who needs to have the physical and mental acumen to deliver the downfield juice.

Why then do you have an undersized, under talented true freshman and a dual threat guy (near as we can tell) as your two back ups?

You want a pocket passing monster? Ok. People can debate that but it is certainly a defensible strategy. What is not defensible is needing a hammer to do your business but your back up plan is two screwdrivers.
 
Upvote 0
It is funny 15 years ago everyone made fun of Gus Malzahn dumbing the playbook down for Cam Newtown (I mean, c’mon it had to be in crayon I’m sure). Yet all he did was dominate like few ever have, get a Heisman and win an NC.

Now, TSC isn’t a generational talent like Cam. But take 4 years later with our own Cardale. Again, I’ll be kind and say the playbook had to be extremely limited. But those coaches found what he could do (throwing BOMBS and putting his head down to truck people when his read was covered).

I just posted in the Fahey thread that I like the kid and see a future serviceable role. I do wonder if OSU could/should have figured out the higher upside talent and done whatever it takes - at the college level - to just win for this team. Not worry about teaching these kids some complex, NFL system. Just roll out the talent, run TSC, use his strong arm and give this team a chance to live another day.

Who knows, that could have blown up spectacularly as well. But this “safe” path definitely did already.
 
Upvote 0
To me it's not so much adapt the offense to the talent on hand but, you have a very clear system created- why doesn't the talent on hand fit it?

Day built this NFL level passing game offense. He had a couple of home run QB's and Hartline cranking out the WR talent at a level no one has ever seen. Ok great- now you have Smith who is so generational No ONe on earth is going to do anything but GHTGDB.

Then you lose the latest QB who needs to have the physical and mental acumen to deliver the downfield juice.

Why then do you have an undersized, under talented true freshman and a dual threat guy (near as we can tell) as your two back ups?

You want a pocket passing monster? Ok. People can debate that but it is certainly a defensible strategy. What is not defensible is needing a hammer to do your business but your back up plan is two screwdrivers.

I completely agree with this. It seems like Day wanted the dual threat QB that could grow more into a pocket passer. While I understood having Sayin even though he was undersized, recruiting Fahey made zero sense especially since Sayin seem to limit the offense with his size and arm strength. Going that route again didn't make any sense.

I think what we are seeing is that the big dual threat QB takes too long to develop to Day's standard to be playable in time. Like Keinholz transferred before he was ready for Ohio State. TSC probably transfers too. Then the small QBs who are ready to step in have a limited ceiling.

Its pretty clear that Day is recruiting the wrong QBs that balance out being ready enough to play when needed and don't need years of development but also have a high enough ceiling to take advantage of how the rest of this team is built. Even with Sayin we weren't taking full advantage of the WR talent we have.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top