• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

QB Kirk Herbstreit (Frosted Quips)

Did you call him a "fake Buckeye"? If you did then, yeah, you can join the beard boy, Hawaiian wannabe, and central Pennsylvania Syracuse fan.

"OMG, Herbie isn't an OSU cheerleader on national TV! He's 'fake Buckeye!'", as compared to someone who never attended Ohio State and thinks guys who did should be Buckeye cheerleaders on national TV. :roll1:

If that's you, then enjoy hanging with those guys. If it's not you, then hang with me. Your choice. No hard feelings either way (at least not on my end).
Ah my mistake....I spoke too soon. There it is. Like clockwork. Jake needed some attention, so we have this thread.
 
Upvote 0
If you never went to OSU and feel the need to call an OSU alum a "fake Buckeye" because you experienced butt hurt watching Game Day, then I am going to laugh my ass off at you. All day, every day.
Got my BSCS from Hawaii Pacific University and I'm about as fake a Hawaiian as can be. Just because you attended an institution doesn't make you a representative of said institution. So keep on yuckin'...
 
Upvote 0
"Jake said you can't be a real Buckeye if you didn't go to Ohio State!" :roll1:

Actually, "Jake" didn't say that at all. But if you're sitting on your couch, having never so much as attended Ohio State, telling the world which alums are "fake" Buckeyes, then I am laughing at you. What's that? You root for the football team? Congratulations, so do thousands of children across the midwest.

But please, do preach on about the "satanic soulless" football train, your awesome beard, or the greatness of Syracuse basketball. I'm all ears. Just don't tell me who is a "fake" Buckeye, because you haven't got a clue about it.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
If you never went to OSU and feel the need to call an OSU alum a "fake Buckeye" because you experienced butt hurt watching Game Day, then I am going to laugh my ass off at you. All day, every day. :slappy:

Whether or not you're part of that crowd is your decision, not mine.
What if we dislike him because:

He slandered Michael Brewster on national TV and never apologized? (With about a thousand apologies to McGloin during the same stretch for calling him a handoff QB?)

He has the emotional stability of a toddler up past their bedtime?

He routinely engages in petty spats with teenagers and cannot be the adult or the media professional ?

...the latest one was with an OSU recruit and he not only made the situation a lot worse (and a national story), but he blatantly lied about what the kid said?

He threw the osu fanbase under the bus to cover the actual reason he moved to Tennessee?

He offers up next to nothing in terms of substance during broadcasts ? The Kardashian reference is perfect.

Is that allowed, Jake? :roll1:

I don't call him that, but it stuck because it embodies exactly how he conducts himself. Rather than separating himself from immature children, he outpaces them.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
What if we dislike him because:

He slandered Michael Brewster on national TV and never apologized? (With about a thousand apologies to McGloin during the same stretch?)

He has the emotional stability of a toddler up past their bedtime?

He routinely engages in petty spats with teenagers and cannot be the adult or the media professional ?

...the latest one was with an OSU recruit and he not only made the situation a lot worse (and a national story), but he blatantly lied about what the kid said?

He threw the osu fanbase under the bus to cover the actual reason he moved to Tennessee?

He offers up next to nothing in terms of substance during broadcasts ? The Kardashian reference is perfect.

Is that allowed, Jake? :roll1:
Probably have more force coming from me, ex-michigan liver.
 
Upvote 0
What if we dislike him because:

He slandered Michael Brewster on national TV and never apologized? (With about a thousand apologies to McGloin during the same stretch?)

He has the emotional stability of a toddler up past their bedtime?

He routinely engages in petty spats with teenagers and cannot be the adult or the media professional ?

...the latest one was with an OSU recruit and he not only made the situation a lot worse (and a national story), but he blatantly lied about what the kid said?

He threw the osu fanbase under the bus to cover the actual reason he moved to Tennessee?

He offers up next to nothing in terms of substance during broadcasts ? The Kardashian reference is perfect.
 
Upvote 0
This is going to end up like the infamous chart that tells coaches when to go for two.

I was born in Ohio, grew up in western NY, lived long stretches in Atlanta, Jacksonville and Philadelphia. I'm not sure who I am qualified to insult. Going to have to check Jakes card.

Gosh, I sure hope it shows you are qualified to insult the Reds....
 
Upvote 0
Gosh, I sure hope it shows you are qualified to insult the Reds....

giphy.gif
 
Upvote 0
This is going to end up like the infamous chart that tells coaches when to go for two.

I was born in Ohio, grew up in western NY, lived long stretches in Atlanta, Jacksonville and Philadelphia. I'm not sure who I am qualified to insult. Going to have to check Jakes card.
I spent most of my childhood in PSU territory. I later moved to ND country (which was heavily MSU/UM also). Maybe I should have rooted for those abominations?

Also my first in-person experience was Kenyon Rambo dropping a wide open bomb in Spartan Stadium. I was raised by a Spartan dad who went to grad school there. Maybe that would be an approved fandom by blood? I mean it would've been easy to switch, my first OSU game was 99 with Rambo dropping a wide open bomb.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top