You should really give your voice of reason schtick a rest.
In terms of a professional poker player, Moneymaker is not a good a player. If you watched the tournament he won you would have seen he not only got extremely lucky, but had to naviagte through a much smaller field than any main event champ since. In fact, since the 03 main event, he has less than $300,00 in tournament winnings.
With great luck and a general knowledge of the game a player could win anything from a big pot against Phil Ivey to a tourament, but it doesn't make them better than the people who can consistently do it.