I agree that last years games major flaw was the big advantage of the offenses in the passing game. I though that the advantage needed to be remedied but not flipped. Basically, the DB's have such high AI in this game, that it becomes unrealistic to the other extreme. Truthfully, I think the game should be SLIGHTLY skewed towards the offense because of the fact that most people don't play regulation quarters. The only way stats can be comparable to that of a whole regulation game is to give the offense a small advantage.
I agree that putting up 500 yards a game is really extreme, and I can live with the rushing changes that makes me work for my yards...But the passing is just no fun because of the fact that it's so hard to find an open receiver. Most of my completions are, like I said, pure luck. I wanted a little more of a passing challenge this year (smaller windows, tighter coverage, elimination of "money" plays), but EA made the DB's rocketmen!
I'm afraid this is going to eliminate a lot of the "casual" gamers...us diehards are going to stick through it and learn ways to use it...but it wasn't a good marketing decision, IMO.