It's an interesting debate - I don't know enough about the recruiting rankings, but it sure seems that Iowa and Penn State get phenomenal classes.
It also seems like Iowa chokes and PSU thrives on the big stage. PSU sure seems to peak at the right time and seem to be more aggressive in general.
I'm shooting from the hip here, but I think we've outrecruited every team except PSU (including Iowa) over the last 10 years overall. PSU gets about anyone they want at this point, though we've had some victories over them here and there. Not every year, but more times than not.
Problem is that we've had so many guys not pan out that were highly ranked, which is odd for wrestling. Just going from memory on recent guys, we have Singletary, Hoffman (maybe jury is out there, he did AA but he was ranked #1 coming out), the Decaturs, Heinselmann, R Jordan, and Kinner all underperform, by a lot. All were top recruits. Kharchla has been injured and still has time, so I'll withhold judgment. Ethan Smith was over-performing, then probably fell back to where he was ranked. Romero was the #1 guy in the country coming out and has had some moments, but not quite to where he was ranked. Sasso should be a champion at this point with his talent.
When Ryan had the team at their prime, guys stood up in the clutch. Stieber, Courts, the 197 guy that refused offense (can't recall his name, kudos to who reminds me), and many more that came up in the NCAAs and got aggressive. We're just not getting that right now, but it was admittedly a rebuilding year. But the rebuild better be done and ready to go with the class we have coming in.