TrueDat JWINS, but I notice that you live in the Columbus Metro area. How many ND fans have ever been within 100 miles of South Bend?
Quite a bit actually, having spent 18 years of my life less than 45 minutes from South Bend i have a pretty good idea.
There are two types of fans in Indiana
1. Notre Dame Football / IU Basketball Fans
2. Purdue Fans who despise both ND and IU. (ironic how Purdue struggles to beat both schools in their respective strengths)
Ohio State fans such as myself, were few and far between in my area.
http://www.theozone.net/football/2005/Notredame/buckeyewatch.htm
Their connection to the program has more to do with where they go to church than where they live. It is about being Catholic, not about football.
Entirely wrong, this is such a blatant stereotype, and demonstrates such arrogance that it warrants bringing OSU fans into this discussion. My highschool was flooded with green "Return to Glory Shirts" in 2002 when Ty had the Irish at 8-0 (for the record a public highschool 2,000 students). I myself a Catholic would even say that Catholicism wasnt even the predominant form of Christianity in my city, yet the major college affiliation was Notre Dame. Catholicism doesnt bind you the team, nor does it deter you from wearing blue and gold.
What many of you probably dont realize is that many of the news stations in South Bend are also broadcast in Chicago, and the entirety of Northern Indiana. The Indianapolis stations from what ive seen/heard do a great deal of ND coverage also. Notre Dame football is a statewide obsession as is Ohio State football, maybe not to the same extent, nor as loyal (many ND fans wouldnt go outside before charlie), but it does naturally draw a regional fan base. While i do agree that ND's popularity is helped by its ties to religion, especially on a national scale, its very easy to forget just how popular they are otherwise.
Furthermore its hard if not impossible, to speculate what type of religious demographic the subway alumni consist of. Ive met my fair share of ND fans id rather discuss table tennis with than football, ive also know some i could talk for days with. Its rather presumptuous for Buckeye nation to assume Catholicism is what gives ND fans, they have a great program, and storied tradition, to ignore this is what manifests the beliefs in other fan bases that OSU fans are arrogant.