DDN
12/15
Tressel: Hawk lost Butkus by one vote
OSU players upset with snub
By
Doug Harris
Dayton Daily News
COLUMBUS | Ohio State's A.J. Hawk brought home one trophy from his national awards tour last week, but that wasn't enough to suit his teammates.
<!--endtext-->
<!-- inset --><!--begintext-->The senior from Centerville was beaten out for the Butkus Award as the top collegiate linebacker by Penn State junior Paul Posluszny despite having glossier credentials.
OSU coach Jim Tressel said Wednesday he was told Hawk lost by one vote. And although Butkus Award chairman Chip Landon wouldn't disclose the tally, he said the process was agonizing for the 27-member selection committee.
"It was a very, very close vote," Landon said. "And there were several voters who asked for a little more time because they were just having trouble deciding."
Penn State's 17-10 win over OSU on Oct. 8 apparently swayed some voters, although the Buckeyes have the Big Ten's top-rated defense. Posluszny had 14 tackles in the game and 111 for the season, two more than Hawk.
But the Buckeyes' star had more tackles for losses (13-11) and sacks (7.5-3.0) while being picked by the coaches and media as the conference defensive player of the year.
He also finished sixth in the Heisman Trophy balloting — the best showing by a defensive player — and Hawk and Southern Cal's Reggie Bush (the Heisman winner) were the only unanimous selections on the Associated Press All-American team.
The Butkus committee is made up of media members from across the nation, and Landon is confident the group did its homework.
"It was a cumulative vote of some very knowledgeable people," he said. "I feel very confident about that."
But Hawk's cohorts were dumbfounded.
"I don't understand how you give it to a guy who's had one (good) year," OSU middle linebacker Anthony Schlegel said. "(Posluszny) hasn't done what A.J. has done over his career here. To say he's a better linebacker than A.J. Hawk, I completely disagree."
Hawk also was nosed out by Posluszny for the Bednarik Award (top defensive player) and by Alabama's DeMeco Ryans for the Lott Trophy (defensive player who excels on and off the field).
"I'm not too sure how you can be Big Ten player of the year, a unanimous first-team All-American, and not win the Butkus or Lott or Bednarik," OSU outside linebacker Bobby Carpenter said. "He should have won them all, in my opinion."
Contact Doug Harris at 225-2125.