This is on the "Ask CFN" portion...
http://www.collegefootballnews.com/2005/Ask_CFN/Ask_CFN.htm
http://www.collegefootballnews.com/2005/Ask_CFN/Ask_CFN.htm
I am an extremely biased Ohio State fan and perhaps blind to the facts. I know it's not the Heisman, only the Butkus (and therefore unworthy of any great debate), but how in the world does AJ Hawk not win that award? Please make a convincing argument for Posluszny as the best LB in the country this year statistically and otherwise. – MH
A: Posluszny had a fantastic year and does deserve the recognition, but I’m with you. I thought Hawk was the better all-around player and the much bigger playmaker, but Penn State is the hot team right now, and that means the voters of the awards, who normally go off hype and one game of viewing, went with the feel good story. I actually thought Iowa’s Chad Greenway even had a better year than Posluszny. Ask most SEC fans, and they’d say Patrick Willis of Ole Miss was the best linebacker they saw this year.
OK, so why was Posluszny better than Hawk … uh, um, he made more tackles. He was the leader of one of the nation’s best defenses, and he restored the tradition to Linebacker U. Ohio State's defense finished ahead of Penn State's in almost every category, including run defense, and Hawk was far better in pass coverage and at getting into the backfield. Don't get me wrong; Posluszny is fantastic. I just thought others were better.
Upvote
0