View from Pluto
PERALTA PLAYING FOR KEEPS Lack of concentration, limited range put player on the spot at shortstop
By Terry Pluto
<!-- begin body-content -->• The Indians must demand that Jhonny Peralta play a better shortstop -- or tell him he won't be the shortstop in 2007.
Supposedly, Peralta wants to remain at short. In that case, he needs to begin playing like it. What we've seen this season is a guy who can't handle the position for a team that wants to win.
• Here's the breakdown of Peralta's 13 errors: April (3), May (3), June (5) and July (2). His 13 errors are second in the American League, fifth in all of baseball. The Detroit Tigers' Carlos Guillen leads the AL with 17 errors.
• It's not just errors. Peralta's range is below average. He seems to have trouble getting his balance after moving a long way for a ground ball, then setting to throw. He actually grew 1 ½ inches and gained about 10 pounds. He's now 6-foot-3, 205 pounds. His body fat is supposedly lower than a year ago. That might be true, but he's still slower in the field than last year.
• The problem for the Indians is that not one infielder is above average. Only second baseman Ronnie Belliard would be considered average on defense, and that's because of his strong arm on the double play. Someone has to catch the ball. The Indians can't return next season with Peralta performing at short as he has so far.
• I think they seriously should consider Peralta at second base. Belliard is a free agent, wants a long-term deal and he might get one from somebody. The Indians like Belliard on a one-year contract with a team option for a second year -- it's a way to try to help him keep in some semblance of condition.
• Peralta does have a strong arm and he can play a deep second base, much like Belliard. They would have to work on his pivot, but it seems he can learn it. At short, he entered the weekend with 13 errors in 91 games. A year ago, he made 19 errors in 141 games. The good news was that after a nervous start replacing Omar Vizquel (nine errors in his first 46 games), he had only 10 errors in his last 95 games.
• Peralta turned 24 on May 28. He signed a five-year, $14 million contract. Did it make him too comfortable? Perhaps. Manager Eric Wedge has talked about Peralta ``needing to focus.'' The Indians have discussed his ``pre-pitch preparation.'' It sounds like they don't think he's always paying attention.
• Peralta knows the Indians have no immediate alternative to take his job. He should be told that they'll find one for next year. Reader Kevin Bresnahan wondered if David Eckstein could be a possibility, but the St. Louis Cardinals' shortstop is under contract through 2007. But the Indians can shop this winter for a glove to handle short. For example, 30-year-old Alex Cora (.315) is a free agent, and he's solid at short, as he showed with the Tribe briefly in 2005.
• The Indians are using newly acquired Asdrubal Cabrera at shortstop in Buffalo. He's the youngest player in all of Class AAA at 20 and has made only six errors in 75 games this season. His range is considered well above average. One scout told me, ``He's a guy who seems to never get the ball on the wrong bounce. Shortstop comes natural to him. You just don't see 20-year-olds play short like he does.''
• Cabrera hasn't hit much this season, only .232 with little power and few walks. But if nothing else, the Indians can say that at some point in 2007, they'll consider putting the kid between Peralta at second and Andy Marte at third because he can settle down the infield.
• Before trading Cabrera to the Indians for Eduardo Perez, The Seattle Mariners skipped Cabrera from Class A to Class AAA because of his glove. He should be in Class AA this season. But the Indians are keeping him in Buffalo just in case an emergency hits and they need a shortstop. He did bat .300 with two Class A teams in 2005.
• It's amazing the Mariners traded Cabrera for the 36-year-old Perez, who is seldom used and went into the weekend 2-of-10. They have 24-year-old Yuniesky Betancourt (.294, 5 HR, 33 RBI, 12 errors) at short, so they believed there was no room for Cabrera. But this could be their Brandon Phillips-to-the-Cincinnati Reds deal in a few years.
• The Indians believe Peralta can return to his form of 2005, when they said he was an average defensive shortstop with a strong bat for the position. Best guess is Peralta will hit, regardless of where he plays. Peralta's batting average by month: April (.229), May (.270), June (.245), July (.306). Overall, he was hitting .258, with 10 HR and 43 RBI heading into this weekend's Minnesota Twins series.
• Some fans have complained about Peralta's contract. They seem to believe it will make it hard for the Indians to deal him. Just the opposite. Teams will know that he is signed for five years and that can help them control their payroll. They also will look at his 2005 season (.292, 35 doubles, 24 HR, 78 RBI) along with him being the Class AAA International League Most Valuable Player in 2004 and believe he just had an off season. He does have trade value, although that's not in the Tribe's plans.
TALKIN' TRIBE
Braves and Brewers pursued Wickman
• Because Bob Wickman had the right to veto any deal and because he preferred to remain a closer, the Indians ended up with only two real suitors for him: the Milwaukee Brewers and the Atlanta Braves. The New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, Chicago White Sox and Detroit Tigers all have established closers. There were other teams with which Wickman preferred not to play. The list ended up as the Brewers and Braves.
• Because they are trying desperately to get back into the playoff race, the Braves wanted to make a deal now. They also had an interest in a few other closers. The Brewers didn't have much in the farm system that was available and of interest. The Indians really likecatcher Max Ramirez, acquired in the Wickman trade, despite him being in Class A. They think he has a chance to become a special player.
• The deal also was appealing to the Indians' management because: 1) They wanted to see Fausto Carmona close for two months, and 2) Wickman is 37, a free agent and has $2 million left on his deal. They wanted someone to take the contract to put the money into the winter free-agent budget.
• Eric Wedge's complaint that the Indians miss the leadership of Kevin Millwood and Scott Elarton sounds hollow. Neither of these guys catches a ground ball, which is the team's biggest problem. Elarton is 4-9 with a 5.34 ERA and on the disabled list with the Kansas city Royals. I'd rather have the Indians looking at Jeremy Sowers, Jeremy Guthrie or even Jason Davis as a fifth starter than Elarton.
• Yes, they do miss Millwood, who is 10-5 with a 4.61 ERA for the Texas Rangers. At home in that tough pitcher's park, he's 3-4 with a 6.59 ERA. On the road, he's 7-1 with a 2.96 ERA. Millwood was 9-11 with a 2.86 ERA for the Tribe last year. He's a good pitcher, but not even the free-spending Yankees and Red Sox would match the five-year, $60 million deal the Rangers gave him. The concern is his elbow, which has ached in the past.
• Yes, the Indians would have won a few more games with Millwood, but his presence would not address the real problem with the team: sloppy defense. Paul Byrd replaced Millwood in the rotation, and he's 7-6 with a 4.28 ERA. Only twice in his past 15 starts has he allowed more than four runs.
• This is the first time Wedge seems to be in a major struggle to reach his players. In his first three seasons, there were problems, but the Indians progressed from 68 to 80 to 93 wins with him in the dugout. This year they might lose 90. They rarely play solid baseball for more than a few days, and for all his talk about ``playing the game the right way,'' they seldom do it.
• Wedge pushed to keep Ramon Vazquez over Brandon Phillips. He wanted the right chemistry in the clubhouse. Fans know Phillips is an emerging star with the Reds. Worse, Vazquez can't even be a backup infielder with the Tribe. He doesn't hit (.182) and seems shaky in the field.
• With the Indians out of the playoff race and veterans being traded, it will be crucial that Wedge finds a way to have his team play smarter, cleaner baseball. Last year, when they lost, it usually was because they couldn't hit. Yes, they had trouble getting down sacrifice bunts, but they weren't the defensive and fundamental flops that they are this season -- with all the key starting players back except Coco Crisp in left field.