MililaniBuckeye;602637; said:If anyone had any doubts whether Laurinaitis knocked the ball loose from Pittman before Pittman was down:
After seeing the TV replay, I think Brent's comments helped give Mack Brown more criticism for his decision to challenge than was deserved.
Brent said 'they review everything'. The officials in the booth look at every play, but they only are doing an official 'review' if they notify the officials on the field and stop play. There are times that the booth doesn't get a good enough look soon enough and a team will lose out on a play that should be overturned. In the stadium, you don't get the TV replays on the scoreboard if the play is controversial. A coach has to rely on what he sees live, what his players and coaches tell him, and what somebody upstairs that is looking at TV replays tells him. That play was so crucial that I thought Mack was correct in calling timeout and using his only challenge. But perhaps he doesn't have a good system in place of having someone see the TV replays and communicate with him. Mack did correctly wait until tOSU started to line up before calling the timeout and requesting the challenge. A coach never wants to call the timeout until it looks like the booth isn't going to do it on their own and the next play is about to start, ending the ability to change the previous play.
They made a big deal about him using his only challenge and losing a timeout. But Texas ended up not needing more first half timeouts, after it was 14-7 they got the ball back on their own 20 with less than 20 seconds left, and weren't going to try moving it.
And he never really needed the challenge later. He could have challenged Pittman's TD, but it would have been upheld.
I think that what should have occurred is that the booth should have done an official review on both of those plays. The first one was obviously critical to the game, so make sure it's correct. By doing a review and taking 30 seconds to see it twice and then say, OK keep playing, no harm would have been done. And with Pittman's TD, delaying the extra point a little bit to get a better look at the replays wouldn't have affected the flow of the game at all. Neither of those plays would have been overturned, but they both should have been reviewed without the coach asking for the process.
I think this is a problem of giving the coaches the power to issue a challenge. The guys in the booth will sometimes hesitate to institute an 'official review' because the coach has the ability to request one.
Upvote
0