So this has become the official "Will the Buckeyes score 30+?" thread huh.
OK
First, let me add a quick 'thank you' to the Big 10 fans wishing us well. I work with some great Big 10 fans, and we all cheer for each other in Bowl season. Specifically to the Wiscy guys, well done against your half of the SEC championship game. Here's hoping we take care of our half.
Now let's get back to what this thread is really about (now).
In what follows, games against Div. IAA opponents have been factored out for every Div. IA team in the country. This may sound like a lot of work, but if you are a spreadsheet uberdork it's incredibly easy.
Method I:
Ohio State has averaged 36.33 points per game. Florida has held teams to 56.45% of their average score. If we assume that Florida will hold Ohio State as far below their average score as they've done with everyone else, then we can surmise that Ohio State will score 20.51 points.
So this method suggests OSU will score about 21 points.
Method II:
Florida gives up 14.5833 points per game to Div. IA opponents. Ohio State scores 164.06% as many points as their opponents typically give up. If we assume that Ohio State will exceed Florida's average scoring defense by the same amount as they've done with everyone else, then we can surmise that Ohio State will score 23.93 points.
So this method suggests OSU will score about 24 points.
There are two things that neither of these methods takes into consideration. One is schedule strength and the other is untapped potential.
It is not just schedule strength that matters, but the strength of each team's opponents' schedules. Determining how many points a team scores over and above their opponents' averages requires that you compare the team not to their opponents, but to their opponents' opponents.
Although Florida faced a tougher schedule, albeit by a smaller margin than the experts suggest, it was actually Ohio State that was compared to a higher standard by this analysis, as OSU's opponent's faced a collectively tougher schedule than Florida's.
I won't bore you with the analysis for two reasons. The first is that the calculations are too complex for anyone but me to care. The second is because simple logic should tell you that the difference is very small. After 12 games each against Div. IA competition, comparing each team to their opponents' opponents means that the number of unique data points is nearly 100 for each team. The data collectively suggest that the numbers should be skewed 0.8% in OSU's favor, which I think we can agree is meaningless.
It is especially meaningless in light of the other factor in play, which is untapped potential. How many points did OSU leave on the field by playing back-ups when they had a big lead? How many points did Florida's defense allow when they were playing back-ups at the end of blow-outs? These numbers could be quantified with enough work, but there is no point in doing so because untapped potential can be found in so many other places.
For example, Ohio State attempted 10 passes on first down in the opening half of the game in Austin. We attempted one whole pass on first down in the second half. This was a common refrain throughout the season. How many points would Ohio State have scored if they had continued to pass on first down throughout each game? I suppose there might be ways of trying to quantify this, but the numbers would be clouded by still more factors than can possibly be accounted for.
The best way to examine untapped potential is to look at what happened when Ohio State had to score. When they were pressed. This type of analysis predicted an even lower score against Michigan, yet OSU scored 42 because they had to. If they had needed another td on their final drive, they would have scored that too. Or did you not notice that they ran straight into the teeth of a defense that knew they were going to run and got a first down anyway?
So the final upshot is this: OSU has it in them to score a heck of a lot more than 21-24 points. They left a ton of potential on the field this year, far more than Florida's defense can claim to have eschewed.
The question is not, "Will Ohio State score more than 30?"
The question is, "Will they need to?"
But then, this is the last game of the season. There is nothing left to save bullets for. The Buckeyes may well score the points even if they don't need them.
BTW: The above methods predict 11-14 points for Florida.