Not certain of your point, 'Gene Smith won't share donor info with the collectives'. l to my knowledge, feel free to correct me, tOSU is independent from the NIL collectives. Now, not to say that 'someone' on tOSU staff doesn't give input to the guys holding the bag, but the donors go to the collectives, and either may or may not, say "I want this to go to the best running back" or whatever. If the donors give without a plan, etc, then the money goes into a pot that whomever controls the collective, doles out to the players. If one recollects the Florida QB commit, he left Florida because their collective reneged on their $1.3 million pledge. School didn't fight it, but gave him his release. Guess this kid coulda sued for 'specific performance', but from what I read, the contract contained a clause that stated 'we can withdraw the offer at any time'. Who in the heck would have signed garbage like that is beyond me....anyway, there is clearly a separation between a university and 'it's' collectives. Also read that the Texas collectives have told the coach, 'you need to recruit this kid', we'll take care of him. Don't know who said it first, but yeah, agree that the NIL stuff will be the downfall of college football. Would like to see an expose on the Texas A&M NIL stuff.......what with all their decommits from their vaunted #1 recruiting class. Go Bucks! PS, may be going against the tide here, but do believe that tOSU is doing the 'right' thing here. PS, looking at the bigger picture, with playoff expansion, believe the Buckeyes will be in the 12 (?) team playoff yearly.