hold up. are you really claiming people were calling for the benching of Braxton Miller and Troy Smith?
Upvote
0
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
BuckeyeNation27;2349526; said:hold up. are you really claiming people were calling for the benching of Braxton Miller and Troy Smith?
Nope, Smith was put in when Zwick was getting killed as a drop-back, no-run threat at QB. Smith was not the better passer at that point in time, but he had the ability to escape and make plays that Zwick lacked.BuckeyeNation27;2349526; said:hold up. are you really claiming people were calling for the benching of Braxton Miller and Troy Smith?
BuckeyeNation27;2349526; said:hold up. are you really claiming people were calling for the benching of Braxton Miller and Troy Smith?
In three cases I can think of, problems in the offensive line/pass blocking package forced Ohio State coaches to bench Zwick, Boeckman and Bauserman before they felt their replacements were fully ready. That may well have been the case with Hoke at Michigan.
Some people try to win arguments by making good arguments. Some people try to win by exhausting the other person by saying as many stupid things as possible. I know which kind of arguer cinci is now.
Jaxbuck;2351586; said:
ooooooooook? let me know when I called you one in that post.Let me know when I call you names on this list.
cincibuck;2349524; said:No disagreement there, not unlike Bauserman, Miller, Boeckman, Pryor, Zwick, Smith. I thought Gardner gave them a much better offense, still a mobile QB and now a way to add ways to get the ball to their best big play back.
So the question becomes why wasn't Gardner ready, or was DR a potential problem maker if Benched? That happens, ask Coop about putting Jackson on the bench for Germaine. But, I wonder more about the strength of the coach than the skill of the player in those situations- It's not DR's fault if Hoke and Bourges can't do their job.
Nice to have some insight on that. Makes me appreciate the Oregon QB of a few years back- Miller?- who was so good at getting the right read - and like DR was prone to injury.
And that's where I probably have the biggest issue with many who posted on this thread. I know that my years as a track coach didn't present the same kinds of injuries, or injury problems as a high school football coach faces, but I wouldn't want to be the coach who put an injured athlete into a contest. I wouldn't want to be a coach who coerced an athlete back into a contest. DR took a lot of hits... and not unlike Braxton Miller, he was out of big games at key moments. But you- as a coach- do not decide when a player is fit for action. That's a call that begins with the player and goes through the trainer or doctor. Likewise, unless someone here has a special access to the Michigan sidelines, we don't know what happened in each instance that DR left a game. Did he want to go back in? Did the trainer/medical staff say no? In the case of the Ohio State game, did Hoke decide his chances were better if he put Gardner on the field w/o DR? We don't know and it's presumptuous to call DR a pussy as a result.
But teams still seek them out. In three cases I can think of, problems in the offensive line/pass blocking package forced Ohio State coaches to bench Zwick, Boeckman and Bauserman before they felt their replacements were fully ready. That may well have been the case with Hoke at Michigan.
And imagine what their offense could have been with Gardner at QB, DR moving between slot back and wide out and Toussaint as the RB. Again, that seems to say more about the strength of the coach than the players involved.
probably what he did...ask Mattison and have a couple of donuts as he took notesgerm;2364094; said:This was a really good post to read, actually Hoke commented on the Denard at QB vs Gardner. Let me see if I can find it, but I agree looking at what we know now it's easy to state what we would do. Put yourself in Hokes position, what would you do?