The defense isn't going to get better for more than a year or two at a time until OSU finally finds and keeps a guy for more than a few seasons and then can consistently recruit to improve the talent and depth that it needs for that guy's philosophy. While I'm not happy with Knowles right now, I think he could be that guy. There were big improvements this year over what was basically a clown car flying down the highway, on fire, at 90 mph. We knew the offense would still have to carry the team regardless of what he did.
That being said, the boneheaded and hyper aggressive calls need to stop. If you don't have the personnel to have your DBs on islands, or can't rely on your blitzes getting home, then you have to be a bit more conservative. Most of all, Day and co. need to start winning big recruiting battles to pull in better safety talent if you're going to play 5 all the time. They've had good results so far, but desperately need players like Downs.
I definitely hope Ransom comes back. Haven't seen enough of Styles but I'm impressed that he's played as much as he has as an early enrollee. Stokes looks dangerous in coverage, but prone to terrible angles. The Martinez experiment is pretty much over. The biggest issue I have with his scheme is that it relies on having great safeties that are both really good in coverage and run support, and it's hard enough to just have 2 of those guys. At what point do you just find physical CBs and play them at nickel and call it a day?
This!
What many are forgetting in the first year Knowles, is that most of the season the defense made marked improvements, ESPECIALLY in the 2nd half. And that was an issue during Coombs' tenure. What many are also forgetting, is that Knowles' defenses make large improvements, year to year(https://okstate.com/sports/football/roster/coaches/jim-knowles/1570
).The Oklahoma State defense has shown significant improvement each year during his first three seasons as coordinator. In 2018, the Cowboys allowed an average of 32.5 points and 452.5 yards per game, but in 2019, those numbers improved to 26.8 points per game and 412.3 yards per game. Then in 2020, those numbers improved again to 23.5 points per game and 379.0 yards per game.
The defense this year, was worlds better than the last 2 seasons, and Knowles said at the start of the season, he's only opened a portion of the playbook as not to overwhelm the team. But the offense was saying all year how much the defense was disguising looks to cause confusion. Now we live in a recency bias world, so many will only remember the last 2-3gms of the year, and not see how improved the defense looked.
But like you said, being too aggressive at times, at bad moments caused an L as opposed to a W. I too wonder if it would be better to have an actual CB playing in the slot instead of a S. Because like you said as well
S are usually best at coverage OR run support, the elite(i.e. Ed Reed, Troy Polamalu, Malcolm Jenkins, Mike Doss, Sean Taylor, etc) can do both and they're in short supply. There are more CBs who can do both, though they usually do 1 of the traits better, a CB can be a great cover CB and decent in run support(and vice versa). IMO, starting Burke, Hancock and Johnson; and rotating the 3 S, would be better than starting the 3 S and rotating the CBs.great safeties that are both really good in coverage and run support, and it's hard enough to just have 2 of those guys
Upvote
0