Charlie Weis might be the worst head coach in major college football. Romeo Crennel might be the worst head coach in the NFL. Maybe the only genius in New England was Bill Belichick ... and the cameraman who was stealing signs all those years.
I know that talent plays a large part in both equations, but neither coach appears capable of getting his team ready to play. Prehaps Weis and Crennel are just two more guys who were great assistants, but lousy head coaches. Some guys just can't take a step up in responsibility, no matter what credentials they bring to the job.
Speaking of talent.... If the cupboard is bare in South Bend, it is largely Weis's fault at this point. In his first two seasons at the helm, Weis rode an excellent quarterback (Brady Quinn, a Willingham recruit), a very good wide receiver (Jeff Samardzija, again a Willingham recruit), a decent running back (Darius Walker, yet another Willingham recruit), and a cupcake schedule to a combined 19-6 record. But, even with one of the most talented signal callers in Irish history, Weis's teams lost every big game, usually in spectacular fashion. Now Weis is without his best players - the quarterback, running back, and receiver whom Willingham recruited and developed - and the situation is a disaster. This season, Ohio State has played eight true freshman, two of whom are budding stars (Brandon Saine and Cameron Heyward); where is the young talent for Notre Dame? Weis already has three recruiting classes under his overly-large belt, but his young players simply aren't developing.
And finally, is Weis losing his team? When the Browns traded their starting quarterback (Charlie Frye) after just one game this season, they were the laughing stock of the NFL. Now, Notre Dame's opening day starter (Demetrius Jones) has transferred to Northern Illinois after week two, an almost unheard of move. Will the other rats (or lemmings, if you will) also jump the sinking ship? Look for some more transfers before too long, and maybe a few de-commitments from the 2008 recruits.
Charlie Weis has the reputation of being an overbearing, pompous ass who publically brags about his own accomplishments and berates and belittles his players. I wonder if they believe in karma under the Golden Dome?