Bernini;1376468; said:
Should anyone be surprised by this? Up until the last season or two, Wisconsin was rubbish during the preseason out of conference slate.
...and Wisconsin has been rubbish during the NCAA tournament. When was the last season in which they've not underachieved in the NCAA tournament when you take into account their seed?
2008: Seeded #3, lost in Sweet 16 -- Underachieved
2007: Seeded #2, lost in round of 32 -- Underachieved
2006: Seeded #9, lost in first round -- Wash
2005: Seeded #6, lost in Elite Eight -- Overachieved (but were the benficiary of upsets, beating only #11, #14, and #10 seeds)
2004: Seeded #6, lost in round of 32 -- Wash
2003: Seeded #5, lost in Sweet 16 -- Wash (but were the beneficiary of only having to beat a #13 seed in the round of 32)
2002: Seeded #8, lost in round of 32 -- Wash
2001: Seeded #6, lost in first round -- Underachieved
2000: Seeded #8, lost in Final Four -- Overachieved
1999: Seeded #5, lost in first round -- Underachieved
1997: Seeded #7, lost in first round -- Underachieved
So in the last ten or so years, they've underachieved in the NCAA tournament over 45% of the time.