• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Big 10 a weak conference??

I'll take LSU, Auburn over anyone in the ACC. Georgia and Alabama are a push with Miami/VT.

what makes the ACC so great?

FSU? Highly overrated. VaTech? good, but not great. Miami? Lost to the overrated FSU squad, and a number of others.

GTech, BC, NC State & Virginia are all pretty average.
 
Upvote 0
I'll let the bowl games tell me who the best conference is.
bowl games are not a very good indicator of relative conference strength...

look at the Big Ten, i'll just use a couple games to illustrate my point:

1: the Citrus Bowl, is normally the Big Ten #2 and the SEC #2... however, if the Big Ten gets two BCS bids, then you have the Big Ten #3 v the SEC #2... then the Big Ten #4 gets the SEC #3 in the Outback Bowl... this equates to an instant advantage for the SEC...

in other, more obscure bowl games, the disparity is ever worse.

2: the Sun Bowl matches up the Pac Ten #3 against the Big Ten #5... if the Big Ten gets two BCS bids, then we get the Big Ten #6(!) against the Pac Ten #3... considering that only THREE teams in the Pac are even Bowl eligible as of right now, a hypothetical loss by Northwestern to UCLA in the Sun Bowl would be a pretty bad indicator of the Big Ten's strength relative to the Pac's strength... which is why i always fiond it amusing when Pac fans trumpet about ASU beating Purdue or whoever in the Sun Bowl last year... considering the disparity of the conference rankings of each team, it is clearly indicative that the Big Ten is more powerful than the pac, based on the 3-3 record over the last 6 games... remember that in 3 of those matchups, the Big Ten #6 was matched up against the Pac Ten #3...

unless you look quite a bit deeper than the surface, all the Bowl Games serve is to further muddy the waters...

in recent history, i can recall only one season in which one conference was clearly far and away the best after the Bowl games were played, and that was 1998, in which the Big Ten went 6-0... it doesn't matter what the matchups are, when a conference goes 6-0, including two BCS berths, that conference is a bad motherfucker... which is the reason that i'm still pissed that we didn't get a shot at Tennecheat... alas, if only that shanked punt did not bounce off Nate Clements' back... damn it... :pissed:
 
Upvote 0
i don't know if this has been mentioned, but the level of quarterbacking and coaching in the big ten is very very good.

troy and michael robinson are having career years. henne is your prototypical NFL-type player. tate, stanton, and basanez can all ball. cupito and stocco aren't great, but can be very effective when the running game is there. and purdue's got their new QB, who should improve under the tutelage of tiller.

the acc has a lot of talent, but has poor QBs and coaching. the SEC is ordinarily very good, but this is a huge down year for them, given how bad florida and tennessee are. LSU is overrated, and alabama is just woeful on offense right now. the only teams i like are auburn and georgia (i love watching shockley, he's such an accurate passer).

the big xii obviously sucks.

the pac-10 is an interesting conference. i think it's underrated as a whole. in other conferences, you usually have a few teams that are very good, every year. this gives the illusion that the conference is strong (like how people viewed the big xii when OU, tex, neb, colorado, and k-state were all top 10, even though all those teams would usually lose their bowl games). the pac-10, other than usc, is just ridiculously inconsistent. you don't know what the hell to make of these teams. teams are great one year, terrible the next. teams are great for parts of the season, terrible during other parts. teams are great for one game, terrible for the rest. teams are great for every game but one, and horrible in that other one. teams play great during parts of one game, and then horrible in the other part.

it's just totally impossible to figure that conference out. so for the rest of the country, the easy thing to do is just say, "bah, they don't play defense out there, they suck", when actually, the truth is far more complicated. a team can be predicted to finish 10th in the preseason and they'll finish 2nd. and vice-versa. wacky, wacky conference.

wisconsin is the most overrated team in the big ten, iowa is the most underrated (losing to michigan in OT, and they were dominating northwestern before onside kick did them in). hopefully iowa gets one of the florida bowls against an SEC team; wisconsin won't represent if they get into the outback or citrus. and who knows which michigan team will show up in their bowl game. if they have to play auburn in the citrus they are going to get rolled. whoever we send to the alamo bowl will win; the sun bowl will be very interesting. we should also win the music city. iowa will win their bowl game, unless they somehow end up playing auburn (that would be a very good game)

georgia will beat LSU.

another thing about bowl records. no conf has a harder bowl schedule than the big ten; no conf has an easier schedule than the acc. the acc is matched up almost exclusively against the big east and other minor conferences. it's a total joke. they will probably post the best record, but it's a fraud.

here's what the big ten's bowl schedule could look like:

#1 vs ACC Champion
#2 vs Notre Dame
#3 vs SEC #2 (even though Auburn is probably the best team in the SEC)
#4 vs SEC #3
#5 vs Big XII #4
#6 vs Pac-10 #3
#7 vs SEC #6

if we are to assume that the 5 major conferences are equal, you'd have to assume that the big ten would have a losing record. if they go 4-3 or 5-2, there should be no doubt as to which conference is the best this year.

now take a look at the acc's bowl schedule. it's embarrasing.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top