B1G (Official Thread)

[ORD_Buckeye]

JJ being the QB1 on an NC winning team deserves a spot on the top 12, imo.

He fucking cheated. He deserves to be thrown out of a fucking helicopter.

 

[ScriptOhio]

This list is idiotic imo. McCarthy shouldn't even be on this list, and the fact that the B1G single season passing yards and passing TDs record holder doesn't even make the list(Dwayne Haskins) shows how much of a joke it is. I feel like whomever made the list just wanted to throw players in there and not just populate the list with OSU QBs. Because tbh, every starting QB in the 2000s should be on this list. And honestly 4 of the top 5 QBs should be OSU QBs if we're being completely honest(Stroud, Fields, Smith and Miller).
If I could redo the list:
1) Justin Fields 2) Troy Smith 3) CJ Stroud 4) Fernando Mendoza 5) JT Barrett 6) Will Howard 7) Braxton Miller 8) Russell Wilson 9) JJ McCarthy 10) Taulia Tagovailoa 11) Chad Henne 12) Trace McSorley

1) Fernando Mendoza
2) Troy Smith
3) Justin Fields
4) CJ Stroud
5 Russell Wilson
6) Braxton Miller
7) Drew Brees (played in 2000)
8) Dwayne Haskins
9) Will Howard
10) J.T. Barrett

 

[pnuts34]

1) Fernando Mendoza
2) Troy Smith
3) Justin Fields
4) CJ Stroud
5 Russell Wilson
6) Braxton Miller
7) Drew Brees (played in 2000)
8) Dwayne Haskins
9) Will Howard
10) J.T. Barrett

I didn't want to include Brees, he was more of a late 90's QB IMO

 

[Zurp]

Brad Banks played at Iowa in 2001-2002 and was a beast. Won the Davey O'Brien award in 2002 and had a decent career in the Canadian league.
If you recall, even though the Bucks won the Natty that year, they shared the B1G title because Iowa and OSU were both undefeated and didn't play each other. I always wished we could have seen that game played.

I remember him now. Thank you. Yes, I remember sharing the Big Ten title with Iowa. I'd forgotten that Brad Banks was the name of their quarterback that year.

 

[Zurp]

7) Drew Brees (played in 2000)

Good call on Brees. I'd forgotten he played in the 2000s.

 

[RhodeIslandBuck]

I remember him now. Thank you. Yes, I remember sharing the Big Ten title with Iowa. I'd forgotten that Brad Banks was the name of their quarterback that year.

He was legit, kind of a Troy Smith Lite

 

[muffler dragon]

 

[AuTX Buckeye]

Damnit just came to post this. I about pissed myself at some of them. Plus he doesn’t wash scum. He calls them cheaters. Full stop