My 2 cents on those sliders...
tackling for both - increase about 10
QB accuracy for the CPU - lower about 10
RB ability for CPU - reduce to about 75 or 80
Maybe I just suck, but I have ran into many times with similar sliders where the CPU RB becomes unstoppable and times where the CPU QB goes on streaks that approach all time records. The CPU QB issues never seem to be accuracy. More like stupidity. There are also times here CPU RB's cannot be tackled.
Again, maybe I just suck, but I played some exhibition games with Illinois vs. Western Michigan with similar sliders (a little different, I will tweak my default to these tonight). Western's QB and RB are pretty good. Their QB at one point was 20 for 23 against me. The only reason I stopped him was sacking him. Their RB also had multiple huge runs where he broke 3 tackles and then simply outran everyone.
I still was able to outscore them for the most part (I did quit one where I was down 14 and felt it was just ridiculous what the AI was getting away with).
Anyway, just my 2 cents and I don't expect those changes to be made if not agreed upon. If I end up sucking, I end up sucking.
BTW...jwins, did you play your game with All American and all 50's like the dynasty was setup last night? I checked the dynasty sliders last night before running some exhibitions so I could match the sliders and it showed all 50's. The first page was changed from default (ice the kicker was off), but everything else was default. This was after your game. Can we see the slider changes? I will have to check tonight. Just wondering.