You can nitpick all the way through the ten page letter, but I very specifically want to highlight the hypocrisy of the position that Harbaugh wasn’t the one who “committed an offensive action” and therefore can’t be punished (1B).
How about not preventing your subordinates from blatantly cheating is the “offensive action” you fucknuts. It’s really not that hard when the language is broad and gives broad discretion.
Moving back, 1A is a page and a half that says the conference usually prefers to defer to the NCAA on investigations. Pretty sure in completely unprecedented situations like this normal preferences (which aren’t hard rules) can be set aside.
Continue to do my best to read through this piece of garbage.
As has been clear the entire time, they’re not even trying to argue they’re innocent, they’re just desperately trying to stretch it out so they can play the games and maybe win a championship.
Edit: Section II’s title gives away that game immediately. “Disciplinary Action is Premature” in which the second sentence states “there is no reason to shortcut a full investigation in favor of summary punishment,” um, how about the reason is to punish blatant cheating in real time rather than let the cheating reap a potential trophy. As everyone has ALSO been saying, all this bullshit goes away if they lose a game and are no longer in title contention.
It also gives away the game when they use weasel language in section two. “We are aware of no justification the would permit the Conference to ignore these outstanding issues (editorializing: which is just “due process, vaguely defined as an opportunity for the University to respond, once again, please just let us waste everyone fucking time until we’ve gotten to play all our games) and impose an immediate sanction.”
They “aren’t aware,” which they again use here: “As far as we are aware, there is no current evidence suggesting that Michigan coaching staff knew about or participated in the alleged offensive conduct.”
Other than the dozens and dozens of pictures and videos of both coordinators speaking directly with Stalions on the sidelines before calling in their plays? It seems like the game they are trying to play is that the pre-scouting and recording are the rules violations, but using that illegally obtained data isn’t specifically against the rules… I’m no lawyer, but I hope that shit doesn’t actually fly, especially when the standard is something deemed to be an “offensive action.” Blatant cheating seems pretty offensive to me.
They couch all their bullshit arguments with “we aren’t aware” weasel language and then complain “given Michigan’s current inability to evaluate and respond to the evidence.”
So the end of page six seems to invalidate everything that came before it, to me, since they apparently haven’t even looked at any of the proof that would “make them aware” of what massive cheaters they are I.e. the “offensive actions.”
Edit: ha, these fuckers specifically complain they have no way to evaluate pictures and videos of Stalions on the sidelines described in the notice of allegations from the Big Ten because they weren’t provided in the email… you know, the ones that have been publicly available for two weeks?
And again, this DIRECTLY invalidates the previous “As far as we are aware, there is no current evidence suggesting that Michigan coaching staff knew about or participated in the alleged offensive conduct.”
Fuck. Off.