I'm not even being "selfish" in wanting him to come back, because I just don't think he makes us that much better either way.
i don't disagree with the rest of the post, but i do disagree with this. the only factor impeding thompson from being a star last year was limited playing time due to foul trouble. on a per-possession basis, he was outstanding. consider:
1. only one major conference player (swanigan) had a better total rebounding percentage. that's nationally. among all conferences, thompson was 5th in total rebounding percentage.
2. thompson was 8th nationally in defensive rebounding percentage.
3. in the big ten, thompson was 2nd in defensive rebounding percentage. no other osu player was in the top 20.
4. in the big ten, thompson was 2nd in offensive rebounding percentage. no other osu player was in the top 20.
5. in the big ten, thompson was 3rd in block percentage. no other osu player was in the top 20.
6. in the big ten, thompson was 2nd in true shooting percentage (2, 3 & ft shooting efficency). at 16th, tate was the only other osu player in the top 20.
7. in the big ten, thompson was 6th in defensive rating (points allowed per possession). no other osu player was in the top 20.
8. in the big ten, thompson was 6th in offensive rating (points scored per possession). no other osu player was in the top 20.
9. in the big ten, thompson was 4th in win shares (multi-statistical representation of player's influence leading to wins). no other osu player was in the top 20.
10. in the big ten, thompson was in the top 20 in both offensive and defensive win shares. no other osu player was in the top 20 in
either.
when on the court, thompson was the most proficient and most impactful player for ohio state. upon looking at per-possession (tempo-free) stats, he jumps off the page, especially compared to his teammates. heck... disregard the stats. the eye test difference between how the team played with thompson on the court and how the team played with potter was massive.
in my opinion, losing thompson has a substantial impact on the team. i'm optimistic that we'd be a tournament team with him. without him? well, kaleb better be matta's version of nick ward for us to have a shot.