CBB Summer Buzz: Ohio State
The Buckeyes will have to learn to live without Evan Turner
By Matt Meyers
ESPN The Magazine
Archive
Insider knows you're hot for hoops during the summer, so we're bringing you a closer look at a few of the big-profile schools before most freshmen have even moved into their dorms. We continue today with Ohio State.
Ohio State Buckeyes
29-8 (NCAA tournament -- Sweet 16)
This Buckeyes team is in an odd position. On the one hand, it returns four starters, and who wouldn't want that? On the other hand, the one guy it lost, Evan Turner, will be the hardest to replace. Turner was the No. 2 pick in the NBA draft, and he did practically everything for the Buckeyes last season. And when he went down for a month with a spine fracture in January, it was obvious that he was the team's linchpin. "If you watched us play without Evan, we were a different team," assistant coach Brandon Miller says. "And not that successful." With Turner out, Ohio State was a mere .500 team (3-3).
Experts' Take
Jay Bilas
Ohio State has recruited as well as anyone in the country under Thad Matta, and this year's class is no exception. The Buckeyes have every position stocked except the point. There is no way to replace Evan Turner, but Ohio State doesn't need to do that. All the Buckeyes need to do is find someone who will get the ball up the court safely, initiate the offense and get the ball to Ohio State's best scorers.
But there is no easy answer at the point. David Lighty could fill that role, but that is not his strongest suit and could take him away from doing other things. The best option may wind up being 6-foot-1 freshman PG Aaron Craft, a very smart and savvy winner who seldom makes mistakes. Craft is not a creator, but he can run a team and hit open shots.
Newcomers Jared Sullinger and Deshaun Thomas are difference-makers up front. Sullinger can be an All-American in his first season because of his productivity on the glass and his penchant for winning. As he improves his low-post game, he has the chance to be special right away and yet another first-year player who leaves Ohio State for the NBA. Thomas is the one who could surprise at the highest level. He is an outstanding scorer on the block and can step away and score. With a tandem of Thomas and Sullinger inside, Lighty and William Buford on the wings and Jon Diebler to stretch the floor, Ohio State will have a top-10 team if the point is played competently.
Joe Lunardi
Something about Ohio State makes me think of Utah in the post-Keith Van Horn era. The Utes were supposed to take a big-time dip after Van Horn was drafted No. 2 overall in 1997 by the Philadelphia 76ers. Instead, they rallied around a veteran core and marched all the way to the 1998 national championship game. You probably can see where this is going.
The present-day Buckeyes lose Evan Turner, another No. 2 overall pick of the 76ers, but return a veteran presence in wings David Lighty and William Buford. For good measure, OSU has several impact frosh led by hometown star Jared Sullinger. If the 6-8 power forward can provide even half of Turner's production, the Buckeyes should be just as dangerous as they were a year ago.
If OSU can get adequate play at the point, a Utah-like run through the 2011 NCAA tournament is not a reach.
Doug Gottlieb
The most difficult part of replacing Evan Turner is the intangible quality of being able to make others better. Frankly, no one remaining from last season's OSU roster does that. But the Buckeyes will be able to return a big-time scorer in David Lighty, a lights-out shooter in Jon Diebler and several other solid, ancillary parts from last year's Sweet 16 team.
Aaron Craft, who originally was headed to play for Tennessee last summer, should start right away, despite some athletic limitations. Craft's reputation is that of a solid shooter, passer and ball handler who might not be able to get into the defense as well as some of the more highly rated point guards in the country, but with the Buckeyes' surrounding cast, that may not be an issue.
Jared Sullinger is a terrific low-post scorer and rebounder who frankly plays like a 10-year NBA vet with his poise at the block and volume of scoring moves. The big question is whether Sullinger, who plays below the rim, will be as effective against bigger, stronger competition in the Big Ten. (He should.)
The depth of the returning starters and the signing class makes Ohio State, on paper, capable of competing for Big Ten and national crowns. But the young players and veterans have to mesh, and much like last season without Turner, Ohio State may not be good enough at the point to win big, despite all its weaponry.