Biggest Concern: Does Ohio State have enough (or any) offensive line depth?
Josh Dooley via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here
Adam Cairns/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK
Will the Buckeyes’ lack of OL depth be the one thing that holds them back in 2024?
From now until preseason camp starts in August, Land-Grant Holy Land will be writing articles around a different theme every week. This week is all about our Biggest Concerns. You can catch up on all of the Theme Week content here and all of our Biggest Concerns here.
Ohio State’s offensive line play has been an issue for the past few seasons. I think few would argue with that opening statement. Even those wishing to make an argument were likely silenced by the team/OL’s
Cotton Bowl performance. What is up for debate is how and why the Buckeyes’ OL play fell off in the manner that it did. Is subpar recruiting to blame? Poor coaching? Are players simply not developing?
The answer is likely (obviously?) all of the above. Former OSU OL coach Greg Studrawa was not known for his recruiting prowess, and Justin Frye has not been an upgrade over his predecessor, at least in the recruiting department. As for coaching and development, well, someone smarter than myself could and would do a much better job of breaking that down and/or identifying where things have gone sideways. However, I would at least bring up the four-tackle lineup of 2021 and suggest that maybe that experiment was the jumping-off point for some of the Buckeyes’ recent issues. If nothing else, it is both comical and painful to look back on.
Now, it hasn’t been
all bad. Paris Johnson Jr., Dawand Jones, and Luke Wypler carried Ohio State’s 2022 OL unit and became coveted NFL prospects. That was two years ago, and only one football season has been played since then. But even in ’22, OSU’s rushing attack lacked efficiency and explosiveness. Things got worse in 2023, as OL communication and execution was severely lacking at times.
This is god awful
pic.twitter.com/jwWNkcqS9i
— Jordan Potts (@PottsAndPans23)
December 30, 2023
**I’m not glossing over or dismissing the influence of Ryan Day and/or his playcalling on the Buckeyes’ lackluster running game but we’ve already been there and done that, right? Ok, moving on.
Now, as Day’s team prepares for the 2024 season, they are left with no shortage of OL questions... At least in my opinion, which is why the big men up front are of great interest and/or concern.
What stands out or concerns me the most about Ohio State’s OL is not its presumed starting talent – although I do have questions – but rather the group’s very real (and thus very concerning) lack of proven depth. While OSU was surprisingly able to retain most of its 2023 roster, including 4/5 starting offensive linemen, the team did not
add much in the way of OL help. Seth McLaughlin transferred in from Alabama with tons of great experience, but if he wins the Buckeyes’ starting center job, he will have supplanted Carson Hinzman in doing so. Since the latter is/was a returning starter, his potential relegation to the bench would drop the number of returning starters from four to three.
Photo by David J. Griffin/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
It is also entirely possible that Hinzman retains the starting center job and bumps McLaughin to guard — or vice versa. If either of those scenarios play out, then Ohio State would actually boast five offensive linemen who have previously started
somewhere.
But as I stated earlier, starting talent is not necessarily what OSU fans should be most fearful of. That would and/or should be depth. Or the Buckeyes’ lack thereof.
Ohio State’s group of expected OL backups/depth pieces includes the likes of Zen Michalski, Austin Siereveld, Joshua Padilla, Toby Wilson, and one or both of Luke Montgomery and/or Tegra Tshabola. Now at any point while you were reading the preceding sentence was your mind flooded with positive, impactful memories of these players’ stellar on-field performance in Columbus? Or anywhere?
No offense to any of the players mentioned above, but they are completely untested and unproven at the college level. Most of them have never even played a meaningful snap for the Scarlet and Gray. And we’re talking about (a few) guys with multiple years in the program... Not a single meaningful snap.
Some of that can be chalked up to playing behind the likes of Paris Johnson Jr. and/or Donovan Jackson, both multi-year starters. Some of it can be chalked up to Day and his coaches not putting backups on the field until/unless the Buckeyes are up 50. But at the end of the day, it doesn’t really matter. A collective lack of experience is a collective lack of experience. More worrisome is the fact that these second and third-string offensive linemen haven’t
forced their way onto the field at any point. This is at least part of the reason that Day and Co. have chosen to look for outside help.
Photo by Ian Johnson/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
But a guy like Josh Simmons shouldn’t even be at Ohio State! Don’t get me wrong, I am very, very,
very happy that he is. This is by no means a shot at him or his talent. He was a stud down the stretch last season. That being said, it’s crazy that OSU felt compelled to go and get a right tackle from a 7-6
Mountain West team – with limited experience – to start at left tackle in Columbus... Three freaking months before the (2023) season began! I mean, what the heck are we talking about here!?
The Buckeyes should have depth on top of depth. I’m talking four stars behind five stars behind older five stars. But they don’t. I would argue that OL is the one position at which Ohio State has lagged behind (other CFB bluebloods such as Alabama, Georgia, and others) for several years now. Not necessarily in terms of development, but absolutely when it comes to recruiting. And unfortunately, I am not very confident in Frye’s ability to change the narrative.
However, if Frye is able to land David Sanders Jr., top-ranked OT and five-star in the 2025 class, then I might be willing to reconsider.
The On3 Industry's No. 1 ranked offensive tackle in five-star David Sanders Jr. is back at Ohio State this weekend. More here:
https://t.co/cG9nVRgn0a pic.twitter.com/GDCT5NaJ5G
— Steve Wiltfong (@SWiltfong_)
May 5, 2024
Recruiting issues aside, what happens if Simmons or Jackson gets dinged up and misses time on the left side? Throughout the spring, Josh Fryar, Luke Montgomery, Tegra Tshabola, and Hinzman all got reps with the first-team offense. But that was on the right side. How often is Michalski and/or Siereveld getting the same opportunity (on the left)?
Not saying that Ohio State’s coaches aren’t fully aware of the need to get all players reps, but is it possible that they are so focused on the right side that they’ve ignored at least developing depth on the left? Probably not. But it wasn’t until June of last year that they realized the team didn’t have a starting caliber left tackle for the then-upcoming season, so I'm just sayin’.
Take all of the above with a grain of salt, though, as I am an admitted pessimist. However, I also happen to believe that every other position group for OSU is chock full of talent
and depth, to the point where I have no other concerns. So all of my pessimistic energy is laser-focused on the Buckeyes’ OL. But I will gladly eat crow if and/or when the group goes out and dominates.
Go Bucks!
Continue reading...