Since 1930:
<TABLE width="90%"><TBODY><TR align=middle><TD>1 </TD><TD align=left>
Ohio State</TD><TD>0.73850 </TD><TD>549 </TD><TD>186 </TD><TD>26 </TD><TD>761 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>2 </TD><TD align=left>
Michigan</TD><TD>0.72633 </TD><TD>550 </TD><TD>201 </TD><TD>20 </TD><TD>771 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>3 </TD><TD align=left>
Oklahoma</TD><TD>0.72559 </TD><TD>573 </TD><TD>208 </TD><TD>28 </TD><TD>809 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>4 </TD><TD align=left>
Alabama</TD><TD>0.72494 </TD><TD>580 </TD><TD>212 </TD><TD>26 </TD><TD>818 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>5 </TD><TD align=left>
Tennessee</TD><TD>0.72236 </TD><TD>573 </TD><TD>211 </TD><TD>30 </TD><TD>814 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>6 </TD><TD align=left>
Notre Dame</TD><TD>0.71947 </TD><TD>554 </TD><TD>209 </TD><TD>23 </TD><TD>786 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>7 </TD><TD align=left>
Penn State</TD><TD>0.70710 </TD><TD>539 </TD><TD>218 </TD><TD>18 </TD><TD>775 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>8 </TD><TD align=left>
Nebraska</TD><TD>0.69815 </TD><TD>557 </TD><TD>236 </TD><TD>17 </TD><TD>810 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>9 </TD><TD align=left>
Texas</TD><TD>0.69226 </TD><TD>554 </TD><TD>241 </TD><TD>19 </TD><TD>814 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>10 </TD><TD align=left>
Southern Cal</TD><TD>0.67927 </TD><TD>538 </TD><TD>244 </TD><TD>38 </TD><TD>820 </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
Since 1869:
<TABLE width="90%"><TBODY><TR align=middle><TD>1 </TD><TD align=left>
Notre Dame</TD><TD>0.74612 </TD><TD>796 </TD><TD>257 </TD><TD>42 </TD><TD>1095 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>2 </TD><TD align=left>
Michigan</TD><TD>0.74584 </TD><TD>833 </TD><TD>272 </TD><TD>36 </TD><TD>1141 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>3 </TD><TD align=left>
Alabama</TD><TD>0.71252 </TD><TD>758 </TD><TD>293 </TD><TD>43 </TD><TD>1094 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>4 </TD><TD align=left>
Texas</TD><TD>0.71154 </TD><TD>779 </TD><TD>306 </TD><TD>33 </TD><TD>1118 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>5 </TD><TD align=left>
Nebraska</TD><TD>0.70939 </TD><TD>788 </TD><TD>311 </TD><TD>40 </TD><TD>1139 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>6 </TD><TD align=left>
Oklahoma</TD><TD>0.70903 </TD><TD>735 </TD><TD>286 </TD><TD>53 </TD><TD>1074 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>7 </TD><TD align=left>
Ohio State</TD><TD>0.70898 </TD><TD>756 </TD><TD>295 </TD><TD>52 </TD><TD>1103 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>8 </TD><TD align=left>
Tennessee</TD><TD>0.69630 </TD><TD>744 </TD><TD>309 </TD><TD>55 </TD><TD>1108 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>9 </TD><TD align=left>
Southern Cal</TD><TD>0.69311 </TD><TD>707 </TD><TD>298 </TD><TD>54 </TD><TD>1059 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>10 </TD><TD align=left>
Penn State</TD><TD>0.68822 </TD><TD>756 </TD><TD>331 </TD><TD>42 </TD><TD>1129 </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
But you said
Hell, The Buckeyes only passed them on the all time list because of the 90's. Buckeyes.
Lets's exclude the 1990's
1930-1989
<TABLE width="90%"><TBODY><TR align=middle><TD>1 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Alabama">
Alabama</TD><TD>0.75232 </TD><TD>473 </TD><TD>147 </TD><TD>26 </TD><TD>646 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>2 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Oklahoma">
Oklahoma</TD><TD>0.74297 </TD><TD>463 </TD><TD>152 </TD><TD>25 </TD><TD>640 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>3 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Notre_Dame">
Notre Dame</TD><TD>0.73177 </TD><TD>441 </TD><TD>155 </TD><TD>21 </TD><TD>617 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>4 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Ohio_State">
Ohio State</TD><TD>0.73169 </TD><TD>418 </TD><TD>146 </TD><TD>23 </TD><TD>587 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>5 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Michigan">
Michigan</TD><TD>0.71536 </TD><TD>420 </TD><TD>162 </TD><TD>17 </TD><TD>599 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>6 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Penn_State">
Penn State</TD><TD>0.71026 </TD><TD>420 </TD><TD>166 </TD><TD>18 </TD><TD>604 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>7 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Tennessee">
Tennessee</TD><TD>0.70469 </TD><TD>437 </TD><TD>175 </TD><TD>28 </TD><TD>640 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>8 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Southern_Cal">
Southern Cal</TD><TD>0.69800 </TD><TD>436 </TD><TD>179 </TD><TD>34 </TD><TD>649 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>9 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Texas">
Texas</TD><TD>0.69129 </TD><TD>436 </TD><TD>190 </TD><TD>17 </TD><TD>643 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>10 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Nebraska">
Nebraska</TD><TD>0.66193 </TD><TD>411 </TD><TD>206 </TD><TD>16 </TD><TD>633 </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
1869-1989
<TABLE width="90%"><TBODY><TR align=middle><TD>1 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Notre_Dame">
Notre Dame</TD><TD>0.75918 </TD><TD>683 </TD><TD>203 </TD><TD>40 </TD><TD>926 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>2 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Michigan">
Michigan</TD><TD>0.74252 </TD><TD>703 </TD><TD>233 </TD><TD>33 </TD><TD>969 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>3 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Alabama">
Alabama</TD><TD>0.72939 </TD><TD>651 </TD><TD>228 </TD><TD>43 </TD><TD>922 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>4 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Oklahoma">
Oklahoma</TD><TD>0.71823 </TD><TD>625 </TD><TD>230 </TD><TD>50 </TD><TD>905 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>5 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Texas">
Texas</TD><TD>0.71436 </TD><TD>661 </TD><TD>255 </TD><TD>31 </TD><TD>947 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>6 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Southern_Cal">
Southern Cal</TD><TD>0.70946 </TD><TD>605 </TD><TD>233 </TD><TD>50 </TD><TD>888 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>7 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Ohio_State">
Ohio State</TD><TD>0.69914 </TD><TD>625 </TD><TD>255 </TD><TD>49 </TD><TD>929 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>8 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Nebraska">
Nebraska</TD><TD>0.68763 </TD><TD>642 </TD><TD>281 </TD><TD>39 </TD><TD>962 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>9 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Penn_State">
Penn State</TD><TD>0.68685 </TD><TD>637 </TD><TD>279 </TD><TD>42 </TD><TD>958 </TD></TR><TR align=middle><TD>10 </TD><TD align=left><A href="http://football.stassen.com/cgi-bin/records/fetch-team.pl?team=Tennessee">
Tennessee</TD><TD>0.67934 </TD><TD>608 </TD><TD>273 </TD><TD>53 </TD><TD>934 </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
Hey! look, you're right.. Of course, the game was vastly different way back in the aughts and such (which is why I posted the 1930 cutoff - game hasn't changed a whole lot since then..)