Cleveland PD
Clash of the titans
Fans ready to see OSU, Notre Dame
Sunday, January 01, 2006Grant Segall
Plain Dealer Reporter
It's more than a game.
It's a clash of legends. States. Outlooks.
When the Buckeyes and the Fighting Irish collide, it's Hopalong and Woody versus the Gipper and the Four Horsemen. "Hang on Sloopy" versus "Cheer, Cheer." Ohio versus Indiana. Public versus private. Secular versus sacred.
Never mind Wednesday's official collegiate championship, pitting some Sun Belt upstarts. For millions of fans worldwide, Monday's Fiesta Bowl is The Game, pitting Ohio State University against Notre Dame in a rare pairing of the Midwest's perennial pigskin powerhouses. (Take that, Michigan!)
"This is the matchup of the year," says sportscaster Bob Golic, who starred with the Irish and the Browns.
Lurking in Buckeye Country are a surprising number of Domers, who root for a school with a golden dome in South Bend, Ind.
"You're going to be tripping over them now that they've had a good year," sneers Jim Caldwell, who leads the local Ohio State alumni.
Many locals trip over Domers at the office, the mall -- or the breakfast room. Caldwell's father, Cy, starred at Notre Dame.
Former U.S. Rep. Ron Mottl of Parma once pitched all 15 innings and scored the winning run for the Irish in a baseball game against the Buckeyes. Then he sent two kids to South Bend and a third to Columbus.
Mottl downplays the domestic divide. "In our family, there can't be a loser because we love both teams."
But during this season of peace and goodwill, most fans admit to roasting more than chestnuts.
"There's a lot of ripping back and forth," says State Rep. Tim DeGeeter of Parma, a South Bend native who worships Notre Dame, despite a rejection that exiled him to John Carroll University and Ohio.
Amid the Yuletide red and green, the Buckeyes' scarlet and gray and the Irish's blue and gold are dueling in rival sweatshirts, banners, e-mails and more.
Buckeye wits are circulating a miraculously edited photo of the pope waving an Ohio State flag. Notre Dame wags say he's giving the foe last rites.
Fans have more than bragging rights at stake Monday.
"I'm besieged with wagers, which I don't think I or my estate will ever be able to pay off should we lose," says Pat McCartan, who runs Notre Dame's board of trustees when not running Cleveland's mammoth Jones Day law firm.
Losers may have to wear the winning team's colors, sing its fight song or even get a tattoo of its mascot.
The two schools have global legions of alumni and unaffiliated fans.
Many Ohioans root for the state school. Many fans in the other 49 states love the team's old-style "three yards and a cloud of dust" attack, updated lately by a couple of roadrunners.
Notre Dame inspires countless Catholics, Irish-Americans and devotees of that South Bend invention, the forward pass.
On Game Day, many locals will watch in person, having nabbed tickets through alumni lotteries or bought them second-hand for lofty sums. Many others will drink in the game at local homes or bars.
The game will cap a long holiday weekend for many fans, but not all. Joe Vitale will have to bolt from the broadcast in midgame to take care of business.
"I'm getting sworn in, probably still in my jersey and face paint," says the Olmsted Falls councilman.
Rival alumni clubs happen to gather for gamecasts in the same building: Domers at the Blind Pig, 1228 West Sixth St., Cleveland., and the Young Buckeyes at the Dive Bar, 1214 West Sixth. The public can join either crowd Monday for $20, which will cover a game-long supply of beer and nachos.
Fans can also hear alumni from the Buckeye marching band accompany the broadcast at the Fox & Hound, 8735 Day Drive, Parma. The fans will pay just for what they eat or drink.
The broadcast will be a fund-raiser for former State Rep. Bryan Flannery. The Strongsville Democrat is running for governor, and his running mate is Frank Stams, a former Brown who played with Flannery on a championship team at Notre Dame. For $30 per person or $50 per couple, fans can eat, drink and watch the game at Akron's Tangier restaurant with these Irish pols.
Strangely, the two teams have met only four times. Notre Dame won in 1935 and 1936. The Buckeyes evened things up in 1995 and 1996.
Mottl once passed a Statehouse resolution urging the teams to play more often. That's a rare point of agreement.
"I would love to see this rivalry develop a little more," says Golic.
For now, Monday's game will break the tie. Says DeGeeter, "Someone's going to be very happy on Jan. 3."
To reach this Plain Dealer reporter:
[email protected], 216-999-4187