• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

The Ohio State University Marching Band (TBDBITL)

Yep, I have a feeling that part of this was one of those "I'm making a statement" moves by Drake, along with a lot of paranoia/nervousness resulting in over-reaction on the part of the rest of the administration. Given the report released by Waters' attorney and the accounts from several former band members the last few days, it certainly seems more like a "statement" decision than a thought out, necessary decision.

I'll be interested to see how this shakes out.

Well, my experience with things "shaking out" over the long term for Presidents who take the "I'm making a statement" route out of the gate and keep doing it, is they don't shake out well. In the end, efforts to control the "culture" at Ohio State end up being rather counterproductive when it comes time to tally up the fundraising take. (Note to Penn State, these are the things trustees should be worrying about). Dear Dr. Drake, you're not in California anymore. Also, if you're thinking to yourself, "Being President of this University isn't a popularity contest," you've been grossly misinformed about the job description.
 
Upvote 0
Well, my experience with things "shaking out" over the long term for Presidents who take the "I'm making a statement" route out of the gate and keep doing it, is they don't shake out well. In the end, efforts to control the "culture" at Ohio State end up being rather counterproductive when it comes time to tally up the fundraising take. (Note to Penn State, these are the things trustees should be worrying about). Dear Dr. Drake, you're not in California anymore. Also, if you're thinking to yourself, "Being President of this University isn't a popularity contest," you've been grossly misinformed about the job description.
I think the board of regents need to start looking for a replacement for the OSU president. OMG what a mess.
 
Upvote 0
I think the board of regents need to start looking for a replacement for the OSU president. OMG what a mess.

Meh, Kirwan for example, got the message on his own, he realized he couldn't remake Ohio State in his image and went into a snit. As for the "powers that be" -- these are the same clowns that ran Gee out on a rail* for making jokes... I wouldn't count on them to do much of anything other than overreact to... well, just about anything.

*that might be overstating it, but, yeah.
 
Upvote 0
Dear Dr. Drake, you're not in California anymore. Also, if you're thinking to yourself, "Being President of this University isn't a popularity contest," you've been grossly misinformed about the job description.

AKAK pretty much hit the nail on the head with his last two posts. Long term, I don't see the school thriving as it has under Gee if Drake is left at the helm... And continues to act like this. Will not win over many $$$.
 
Upvote 0
Upvote 0
I'm wondering how tF some douche from UC fucking Irvine was allowed to become the president of TOSU...

Aside: regarding Milgram, it's pretty intriguing to me that many 'teachers' continued to push the button. What does that say about them? Empathy can be a very strong emotion. Surely some of them were pushing the button against their will, right? Perhaps the assbackwardness of the whole thing makes a valid point? W/e off to read more about it...
 
Upvote 0
Disagree. What was going on in the band, particularly in light of Waters nonchalant attitude towards it and/or active participation in it was every bit as actionable under federal (and civil) law as what you're talking about. As to your latter paragraph, soldiers might not find any problem with a so-called "code red," but that doesn't relieve their officers of legal responsibility for its occurrence.

I'm about the least PC person you'll ever meet and personally don't find anything offensive about what went on. That being said, the university found itself in a precarious legal position because of Water's inaction and had to act decisively. That I understand and support. Here's The Dispatch article on some of the legalities.

If it was illegal, they would be charged. Cite the law he was breaking.
To play stupid and pretend it's not happening, that would be negligence. To be present in order to ensure nothing does happen is responsible. Marching around in your underwear isn't illegal. Jumping into a glorified pond isn't illegal. The Dispatch article relies utterly and entirely on the claim of a "hostile environment", which I find laughable and material to move this all into the pussification thread.
I also don't accept the claim that Waters was lackadaisical in dealing with transgressions. The report itself outlines him taking actions on several items, and the letters by members since have corroborated that he had actually done a lot to scale back what he inherited.

I doubt any such thing as "code red" exists. The Marine Corps is not like A Few Good Men, much more like Full Metal Jacket. There's perhaps a legal argument to be made there too, but it's not anywhere near as clear cut. And in any case, that's not what I was speaking of. The kind of things we did revolved more around skirting orders around liberty restrictions for nonrates, or technicalities dealing with ignorant staff ncos who don't take hazmat and haz waste regulations seriously.
The most egregious thing I ever witnessed was a SNCO changing the fault lights on a Radar's control panel to be all green for an FAA flight inspection required to begin operations.
 
Upvote 0
So he investigates, turns it over, gets the kid expelled, and is still fired because he didn't empathize?

Didn't realize he worked in a call center.

Yea pretty much how I read it as well...
They decided not to prosecute the rapist because "she just wanted to get on with her life"... but then 8 months after the rapist is expelled, the mom files a complaint getting Waters fired ?
There's some twisted logic in there. The mom is basically holding Waters responsible, even though he did the right thing. And the worst thing she can say is that he wasn't vocally empathetic enough? I hate to be cynical, but anytime you have 225 people and the kind of turnover rate experienced in a University organization... there are going to be sexual predators. Prosecute the sexual predators, not the staff -- unless you can actually provide an argument on how they enabled the predator ala Paterno.

This had nothing to do with Title IX and everything to do with her mom going vigilante on the wrong guy. Waters didn't rape her daughter.
 
Upvote 0
This has Holbrook 2.0 written all over it...

Not prepared to make that leap, and some will argue it isn't necessarily bad since she did put an end to a lot of the more embarrassing ish that occurred every home game with a kick at 3:30 or later. Of course, she also spoiled the fun for all the responsible adults that can handle their booze, but it probably needed to occur anyway before something really bad went down. If the prior environment had existed into 2010 when Miami came to visit there would have been wild brawls everywhere given the way the Miami fans behaved the moment they stepped off the jetways at CMH.

What really grinds my gears is that after twenty years of Gee, Kirwan, Holbrook, Gee (again), and now Drake, plus Geiger and Gene, it's become plainly apparent the next person OSU hires should have CRISIS MANAGEMENT in big fucking letters at the top of their resume. Bold, underlined, italicized, 48-pt font.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top