• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

SimPLLLLLLLe Jim "6-13" Harbaugh (B1G Suspenders McKhakiPants, Cheater Cheater Booger Eater)

All joking aside I think recruiting has a lot to do with this.

  • Day has an offensive guru reputation, the testimony of Haskins passing stats and 62 points in The Game going for him.
  • Jimmy has a new, unproven OC trying to modernize the offense after 4 years of it being demonstrably outdated.
  • He just had to take the leftovers from a first year coach in Day for his 2021 QB.

Methinks the "QB whisperer" thing is dead to recruits and Harbaugh is scrambling in his gimicky, superficial, stupid ass way to look like he's got a competent offensive system that the top shelf recruits (outside of fullbacks) are going to want to play in. Like almost anything that involves interacting socially with other human beings, he will fail at it.
 
Upvote 0
Methinks the "QB whisperer" thing is dead to recruits and Harbaugh is scrambling in his gimicky, superficial, stupid ass way to look like he's got a competent offensive system that the top shelf recruits (outside of fullbacks) are going to want to play in. Like almost anything that involves interacting socially with other human beings, he will fail at it.
A comparison of Ohio State and Michigan offensive skill position recruits for the Class of 2020:

Ohio State RecruitPosition247 RatingMichigan RecruitPosition247 Rating
Julian FlemingWR.9978A.J. HenningWR.9604
Bijan RobinsonRB.9899Blake CorumRB.9229
Mookie CooperWR.9643J.D. JohnsonQB.8929
Gee Scott Jr.WR.9641Roman WilsonWR.8927
Jack MillerQB.9630Nick PattersonTE.8738
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR.9564Matthew HibnerTE.8485
Joe RoyerTE.8802Gaige GarciaRB.8104
The average Ohio State skill position recruit has a rating of .9595, while the average Michigan skill position recruit has a rating of.8859. It looks like recruits believe in Ryan Day and aren't buying into the QB Whisperer's nonsense.
 
Upvote 0
A comparison of Ohio State and Michigan offensive skill position recruits for the Class of 2020:

Ohio State RecruitPosition247 RatingMichigan RecruitPosition247 Rating
Julian FlemingWR.9978A.J. HenningWR.9604
Bijan RobinsonRB.9899Blake CorumRB.9229
Mookie CooperWR.9643J.D. JohnsonQB.8929
Gee Scott Jr.WR.9641Roman WilsonWR.8927
Jack MillerQB.9630Nick PattersonTE.8738
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR.9564Matthew HibnerTE.8485
Joe RoyerTE.8802Gaige GarciaRB.8104
The average Ohio State skill position recruit has a rating of .9595, while the average Michigan skill position recruit has a rating of.8859. It looks like recruits believe in Ryan Day and aren't buying into the QB Whisperer's nonsense.

Yeah, but once Jimmy gets a hold of them and develops them they would be at least an average rating of .8858.
 
Upvote 0
A comparison of Ohio State and Michigan offensive skill position recruits for the Class of 2020:

Ohio State RecruitPosition247 RatingMichigan RecruitPosition247 Rating
Julian FlemingWR.9978A.J. HenningWR.9604
Bijan RobinsonRB.9899Blake CorumRB.9229
Mookie CooperWR.9643J.D. JohnsonQB.8929
Gee Scott Jr.WR.9641Roman WilsonWR.8927
Jack MillerQB.9630Nick PattersonTE.8738
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR.9564Matthew HibnerTE.8485
Joe RoyerTE.8802Gaige GarciaRB.8104
The average Ohio State skill position recruit has a rating of .9595, while the average Michigan skill position recruit has a rating of.8859. It looks like recruits believe in Ryan Day and aren't buying into the QB Whisperer's nonsense.

Grouping by position, we can see a little better the disparity across each position. The only position where they come even remotely close is at WR, which is the only skill position at which they have a commit rated higher than a Buckeye commit, and even that is because their top WR is still below three of our four WRs. Well, the may be close at TE, too...sorta:

Ohio State RecruitPosition247 RatingMichigan RecruitPosition247 Rating
Jack MillerQB.9630J.D. JohnsonQB.8929
Julian FlemingWR.9978A.J. HenningWR.9604
Mookie CooperWR.9643Roman WilsonWR.8927
Gee Scott Jr.WR.9641------
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR.9564------
Bijan RobinsonRB.9899Blake CorumRB.9229
------Gaige GarciaRB.8104
Joe RoyerTE.8802Nick PattersonTE.8738
------Matthew HibnerTE.8485
 
Upvote 0
Grouping by position, we can see a little better the disparity across each position. The only position where they come even remotely close is at WR, which is the only skill position at which they have a commit rated higher than a Buckeye commit, and even that is because their top WR is still below three of our four WRs. Well, the may be close at TE, too...sorta:

Ohio State RecruitPosition247 RatingMichigan RecruitPosition247 Rating
Jack MillerQB.9630J.D. JohnsonQB.8929
Julian FlemingWR.9978A.J. HenningWR.9604
Mookie CooperWR.9643Roman WilsonWR.8927
Gee Scott Jr.WR.9641------
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR.9564------
Bijan RobinsonRB.9899Blake CorumRB.9229
------Gaige GarciaRB.8104
Joe RoyerTE.8802Nick PattersonTE.8738
------Matthew HibnerTE.8485

You're looking at TE all wrong... you have to put our TEs up against McCafrey and Milton.
 
Upvote 0
A comparison of Ohio State and Michigan offensive skill position recruits for the Class of 2020:

Ohio State RecruitPosition247 RatingMichigan RecruitPosition247 Rating
Julian FlemingWR.9978A.J. HenningWR.9604
Bijan RobinsonRB.9899Blake CorumRB.9229
Mookie CooperWR.9643J.D. JohnsonQB.8929
Gee Scott Jr.WR.9641Roman WilsonWR.8927
Jack MillerQB.9630Nick PattersonTE.8738
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR.9564Matthew HibnerTE.8485
Joe RoyerTE.8802Gaige GarciaRB.8104
The average Ohio State skill position recruit has a rating of .9595, while the average Michigan skill position recruit has a rating of.8859. It looks like recruits believe in Ryan Day and aren't buying into the QB Whisperer's nonsense.

Grouping by position, we can see a little better the disparity across each position. The only position where they come even remotely close is at WR, which is the only skill position at which they have a commit rated higher than a Buckeye commit, and even that is because their top WR is still below three of our four WRs. Well, the may be close at TE, too...sorta:

Ohio State RecruitPosition247 RatingMichigan RecruitPosition247 Rating
Jack MillerQB.9630J.D. JohnsonQB.8929
Julian FlemingWR.9978A.J. HenningWR.9604
Mookie CooperWR.9643Roman WilsonWR.8927
Gee Scott Jr.WR.9641------
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR.9564------
Bijan RobinsonRB.9899Blake CorumRB.9229
------Gaige GarciaRB.8104
Joe RoyerTE.8802Nick PattersonTE.8738
------Matthew HibnerTE.8485

There was an oversight that makes it even more lopsided. Jaylan Knighton, APB. 0.9482
 
Upvote 0
I think what you're trying to say, or rather what Hairball is trying to say is that again, this year, Michigan plans to play with Peters out.
I can remember when Michigan didn't have Peters. It was in 2015 they started to talk about what it would be like to have Peters. Imagine being the winning-est program in football history and going over 100 years without Peters.

Imagine the excitement that they might actually get Peters. The absolute Joy in April of 2015 when they realized they were in fact getting Peters. Then the anticipation of what it would be like to play with Peters. Followed by the impatience - when will Peters come?

Somehow they thought that having Peters would make a difference on the field. It didn't turn out that way. It is one thing to have Peters. But to have Peters perform is something else again. I can recall in particular two years ago when we beat them. What was their excuse? Injured Peters.

As I watched John O'Korn fritter away that game the camera panned to the sidelines where you could tell that all the coaches were thinking about - was Peters.

Then Michigan discovered this kid named Shea Patterson. Well, they said, if we have Patterson we don't care if we have Peters or not.

But the result on the field was the same. We never did get the chance to beat Michigan's Peters - and I am OK with that. I am happy that we have kicked their butt so often over the past 16 years (particularly when we beat their Butt from 2013 to 2016).

And what is the message from this story? Just ask any Michigan cheerleader...

"Michigan men perform the same whether they have Peters or not."

Now Illinois will get a chance to play with Michigan's Peters. Let's see if they can demonstrate that it isn't important that you have Peters, but that you know how to use the Peters you have.


Tune in next week when we discuss Michigan DL Ron Johnson and LB Peter Bush and how the Wolverines might utilize these two in combination.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top