Titans dislike new kickoff rule
Written by John Glennon
THE TENNESSEAN
Mar. 27, 2011
Titans safety Donnie Nickey, left, doesn't like the new NFL rule moving kickoffs 5 yards to the 35, saying it will hurt the game. / George Walker IV / The Tennessean / File
When the NFL put its new kickoff proposal on the tee earlier this week, only six of the league's 32 owners voted against it.
But in the days since, it's been hard to find any players in favor of the change, which will move kickoffs from the 30-yard line to the 35.
Return men including Titans Pro Bowler Marc Mariani expressed their disappointment, but other players are concerned that the many who make much of their football living on special teams will become less important and that the game itself will be less exciting.
Twenty-three kickoffs were returned for TDs in 2010, just two shy of the record set in 2007.
"I just don't understand it," said Titans safety Donnie Nickey, who led the team in special-teams tackles two seasons ago. "There's a lot of big plays on kick returns, big momentum swings. I love kickoffs. When we score on kickoffs, that's a great play and that can really swing a game."
Mariani might not have been drafted if the new rule had already been in effect. But last year the Titans needed to plug a gaping hole in their return game.
Mariani proved a perfect solution, piling up the second-most kickoff return yardage in the league and finishing first with 42 kickoff returns of 20-plus yards.
He isn't likely to get nearly as many chances to return kicks this season, with the number of touchbacks guaranteed to jump. Touchback percentages have already increased from 9.1 percent of all kicks in 2005 to 16.4 percent, according to ESPN stats.
"The 35? That (stinks)! No more returns for us," Mariani posted on his Twitter account. "I think there will be way more touchbacks and less opportunities to return ? (crummy)."
Then there are the niche players such as Nickey, who's the longest-tenured Titan primarily because of his play on special teams. The two-time special-teams captain will be an unrestricted free agent when the new collective bargaining agreement goes into effect, and he is concerned about what opportunities will await him if teams don't consider kickoff coverage as much of a priority.
"Pretty much every kicker in the NFL can hit touchbacks all day long from the 35," Nickey said. "So it's going to reduce the opportunities for returns and reduce the opportunities for tackles and making a living."
Owners say they made the move for safety reasons, figuring it would reduce speed and impact. Nickey said he's seen no evidence that injuries were piling up at an unacceptable rate on kickoffs.
"It didn't seem that way. I haven't seen any numbers on it," he said. "It doesn't seem like a ton of players got hurt on kickoffs, no more than (any other part of the game)."