crazybuckfan40;1170965; said:The thing is in my opinion is that Jay Bruce is our best hitter, or will be...You don't lead him off because that takes away from his ability to knock in runs...You want a guy with a high OBP that isn't a great slugger, will work a walk, get on base and hopefully has a little speed to make something happen...
Hairston isn't a great option, but he is the best if we are going witht he lineup we are going with...His OBP is 338 which puts him 8th on the team...
Maybe not Votto in the two hole, but i don't wan't Dunn or Bruce there because they need to take advantage of slugging and also their OBP...that is why Dunn or Bruce is your 3 hole hitter...That was Griffey back in the day but his day has passed him by...I would put Phillips in the 2 hole against lefties, but against righties i would put him at 7...EE has struggled lately, but I put him in the 6 hole and keep him there...
I go with 4 lefties Votto, Dunn/Bruce, Griffey in the 2-5 spots...The Dunn, Votto, and Bruce look to be the top 3 OBP guys against righties, then you got Griff, EE, Phillips, catcher Pitcher...
IMO you gotta move Phillips from 2 to 7 as crazy as his splits are...You take advantage against lefties getting him as many at bats as possible and not against righties...You don't platoon him with someone else because he hits righties ok, and is a gold glove caliber second baseman...
There is no way you can lead off patterson, it is just laughable...hairston isn't a bad option when he is in there, because he isn't really an rbi guy you put down in the lineup..
I see what you're saying... to me it's kind of a chicken/egg problem. You need to get guys on base in order to have an opportunity to drive them in.
I definitely wouldn't mind doing what you propose. Really, I think there are a lot of valid possibilities for a lineup with the personnel the Reds have. I'm not sure Dusty has stumbled upon a single one of them yet though.
Upvote
0