• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Rate a Position....Part 3..WR

Jump to latest Follow Reply
Sort by date Sort by votes
Best: Calvin Johnson
Overrated: Jordan Shipley, has never been healthy but is already winning games for us
Underrated: Jarrett Hicks, or Sweed, or someone from a confrence/team that I never get to watch....which would be a good reason he is underrated
 
Upvote 0
NOTREDAMECHIEF said:
Easy TW's offense....
But make no mistake he was easily ND's best receiver.
Click to expand...

I'm still not impressed. ND's "best reciever" with an offensive team that couldn't do much isn't very impressive to me. I know, I know, TW's offensive scheme wasn't the best and that attributed to alot of it but I still dont see why people are calling him anything other than above average/good. Throw in the knee injury and I'll pass until he shows me something.

You would know more about him though, so I'll be watching.
 
Upvote 0
Best: I will go with 2:
Dwayne Jarrett, USC
He has everything you could want in a reciever - size, hands, speed, sharpe routes, good reads.

Sidney Rice, South Carolina
Hes still a little raw IMO, but thats only because hes a underclassmen (soph). However, he can put up big numbers for any QB that throws to him. He missed the opener to injury (broken finger) but flourished in his season as the teams main target. He went on to have five 100-yard games in his final six highlighted by a 12-catch, 191-yard, one touchdown performance in the Independence Bowl. I question his durability though after 3 straight seasons of injurys (knee in 2004, finger in 2005, thumb in 2006).

Overrated: Jessica Samarjkljasfdj Notre Dame
Yes, he put up good numbers, but against a stellar Defense like OSU, he did nothing spectacular. Take Brady Quinn's accurate arm away and hes just another receiver on a media-loved squad. He doesnt have anything in particular going for him, not excellent speed, only decent hands, no open field presence.

Underrated: Dorien Bryant, Purdue
Bryant was the most heralded recruit (and some could say the most talented) in the Joe Tiller era of great wideouts. Hes not the most dominant reciever in America (or Big Ten for that matter), but he didnt get the credit he deserves for the season he had. He had a less than mediocre QB tossing him the rock, yet there still wasn't a more dominant receiver over a three game stretch when he caught 40 passes for 421 yards and 3 TD's against Notre Dame, Iowa and Northwestern. Once Painter took over, his production slid, but thats not to say he isnt reliable as the top target on his team.

 
Upvote 0
OSUBuckeye4Life said:
I never understood the love affair with this kid. As the number 1 two years ago he didn't put up very impressive numbers. Now, given the fact he's coming off of a knee injury along with those numbers I'm just not sold.
Click to expand...
This would be because Rheema is faster, stronger, and a better route runner.
The most favored route run by JS and Quinn last season was a straight out or simple variant of the same. Rheema goes over the middle.
The real issue is whether McKnight will return in full health. If he does then I expect NDChief will be spot on about more pass attempts going deep into McKnight's path.

OK -that said -

Best - Jarrett - USC
Over-rated - well I could go with ND's budding baseball star, but really I think Breaston is far more over-rated, as a wide receiver. Put him on special teams, and he is not over-rated.
Under-rated - the kid from G.Tech gets my vote.
 
Upvote 0
AirForceBuck said:
Best: I will go with 2:
Dwayne Jarrett, USC
He has everything you could want in a reciever - size, hands, speed, sharpe routes, good reads.

Sidney Rice, South Carolina
Hes still a little raw IMO, but thats only because hes a underclassmen (soph). However, he can put up big numbers for any QB that throws to him. He missed the opener to injury (broken finger) but flourished in his season as the teams main target. He went on to have five 100-yard games in his final six highlighted by a 12-catch, 191-yard, one touchdown performance in the Independence Bowl. I question his durability though after 3 straight seasons of injurys (knee in 2004, finger in 2005, thumb in 2006).

Overrated: Jessica Samarjkljasfdj Notre Dame
Yes, he put up good numbers, but against a stellar Defense like OSU, he did nothing spectacular. Take Brady Quinn's accurate arm away and hes just another receiver on a media-loved squad. He doesnt have anything in particular going for him, not excellent speed, only decent hands, no open field presence.

Underrated: Dorien Bryant, Purdue
Bryant was the most heralded recruit (and some could say the most talented) in the Joe Tiller era of great wideouts. Hes not the most dominant reciever in America (or Big Ten for that matter), but he didnt get the credit he deserves for the season he had. He had a less than mediocre QB tossing him the rock, yet there still wasn't a more dominant receiver over a three game stretch when he caught 40 passes for 421 yards and 3 TD's against Notre Dame, Iowa and Northwestern. Once Painter took over, his production slid, but thats not to say he isnt reliable as the top target on his team.

Click to expand...

Decent hands!! Do you have a clue?
 
Upvote 0
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top