No, Herbie is the best type of Buckeye fan. A Objective one. He doesn't love the school so blindly that he refuses to believe anyone involved int he program can do no wrong. He see's it for what it is. He loves the program he loves the school not the people who make up the program.
Herbie's issue with Pryor was he thought he was a primadona. Always whining, talking about injuries, critizing, not leading the team, and being high maintance. Which really he's been dead on. Just because he critizes the program and often times players or coaches doesn't make him any less a buckeye fan. The guy is the definition of a buckeye. Wants whats best for the school and the program.