• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

OC Arthur Smith (Official Thread)

Stereotype much?

And no, I did not grow up a "rich kid". Didn't live in the "rich" part of town (that would have been Rolling Hills where I went to school). But I did grow up thinking you shouldn't judge people based on their net worth.

Here's a novel concept - How about we see what he does as our OC before reaching any conclusions?
Mischaracterize much?

That's a novel concept, and one that I explicitly mentioned in the post you quoted, lol.
 
Upvote 0


After coaching in the NFL for the last 15 years, Smith views the chance to coach in college as an exciting new challenge and an opportunity for him to grow as a coach.

“That’s really the thing you pride yourself on. We're always talking to players about growing, having that growth mindset, getting out of your comfort zone, and for me, it was a good challenge with where I'm at in my career,” Smith said.

The expectations for Smith will be just as high as they were for Patricia and Kelly. As Ohio State’s offense looks to bounce back from a rough end to the 2025 season, in which the Buckeyes scored just 24 combined points in losses to Indiana and Miami, Smith is being brought in for the job of building Ohio State’s offense back to a national championship level. But he’s excited about Julian Sayin, Jeremiah Smith and the rest of the talent he’s inheriting and embracing the championship expectations in Columbus.

“You don't go to Ohio State if you don't welcome those expectations, and it's the same thing in the NFL,” Smith said. “The expectation is to win every Sunday, and you love that challenge as a competitor, and it's kind of what gets you going as a coach.”
 
Upvote 0
Rich kids like Arthur are often not the sharpest bulb in the shed because they never had to work for anything. No pressure at school to get A's, no reason to do the work it takes to grow as a person. Mike Brown, e.g. Hopefully he'll turn out to be much more effective than Tim Beck, at least.

Mischaracterize much?

That's a novel concept, and one that I explicitly mentioned in the post you quoted, lol.
Mischaracterize? Those sentences are a perfect example of stereotyping. He came from a rich family so he's probably not real bright and he's probably unmotivated because he never had to work for what he got. You hope he's not as dumb and lazy as most rich kids. That's mischaracterizing?

Please point out the portion of your post that is not stereotyping and I have mischaracterized.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Mischaracterize? Those sentences are a perfect example of stereotyping. He came from a rich family so he's probably not real bright and he's probably unmotivated because he never had to work for what he got. You hope he's not as dumb and lazy as most rich kids. That's mischaracterizing?

Please point out the portion of your post that is not stereotyping and I have mischaracterized.
I did not say, "He's probably not real bright," or anything about "most rich kids."
 
Upvote 0
I did not say, "He's probably not real bright," or anything about "most rich kids."
Excuse me for paraphrasing what you said. So let's look at exactly what you said.

Rich kids like Arthur are often not the sharpest bulb in the shed.

Rich kids like Arthur
- A very reasonable interpretation of those words would indicate that Arthur is a typical rich kid, i.e., like most rich kids. So if I say, "the majority of rich kids" instead of "most rich kids" it has a different meaning?

are often not the sharpest bulb in the shed - This one is a little more difficult. I understand not the sharpest tool in the shed. I understand not the brightest bulb in the box. Both indicate someone who is not real bright. Maybe the writer of said post is not the brightest tool in the shed? Either way, it is meant to group a certain group of people as not very bright.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Rich kids like Arthur are often not the sharpest bulb in the shed because they never had to work for anything. No pressure at school to get A's, no reason to do the work it takes to grow as a person. Mike Brown, e.g. Hopefully he'll turn out to be much more effective than Tim Beck, at least.

Career history
  • North Carolina (2006) Graduate assistant
  • Washington Redskins (2007–2008) Defensive quality control coach
  • Ole Miss (2010) Defensive intern/administrative assistant
  • Tennessee Titans (2011) Defensive quality control coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2012) Offensive quality control coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2013) Assistant offensive line coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2014–2015) Assistant tight ends coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2016–2018) Tight ends coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2019–2020) Offensive coordinator
  • Atlanta Falcons (2021–2023) Head coach
  • Pittsburgh Steelers (2024–2025) Offensive coordinator
  • Ohio State (2026–present) Offensive coordinator
OK, besides this position:
Smith began his NFL coaching career in 2007, when he became the defensive quality control coach for the Washington Redskins. His father, FedEx founder Frederick W. Smith, was a minority owner of the team. Smith would stay at that position through 2008.
Just curious, what other positions do you think he got because he was a dumb rich kid and/or through nepotism?
 
Upvote 0
Career history
  • North Carolina (2006) Graduate assistant
  • Washington Redskins (2007–2008) Defensive quality control coach
  • Ole Miss (2010) Defensive intern/administrative assistant
  • Tennessee Titans (2011) Defensive quality control coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2012) Offensive quality control coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2013) Assistant offensive line coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2014–2015) Assistant tight ends coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2016–2018) Tight ends coach
  • Tennessee Titans (2019–2020) Offensive coordinator
  • Atlanta Falcons (2021–2023) Head coach
  • Pittsburgh Steelers (2024–2025) Offensive coordinator
  • Ohio State (2026–present) Offensive coordinator
OK, besides this position:

Just curious, what other positions do you think he got because he was a dumb rich kid and/or through nepotism?
oof. that reads like a certain "kid" of Harbaugh who we all know isn't really his.
 
Upvote 0

Ohio State football player got very honest about Ryan Day‘s NFL addition to the Buckeyes’ coaching staff

Ryan Day made a big decision to bring Arthur Smith to Columbus, and players are speaking out on how things are going with the new hire.

IMG_7906-1536x1024.jpeg


Ryan Day runs the Ohio State Buckeyes football program like it’s the NFL in many ways and when you look at the coaching staff you’ll get the same feeling. After a successful year with Matt Patricia as the defensive coordinator last season, Day added an NFL offensive mind to the staff this offseason.

When Brian Hartline left for Columbus, the belief was that Day might go to the NFL to bring in a coordinator. That’s what the Buckeyes did with former Pittsburgh Steelers OC Arthur Smith, and the move has been well accepted across the board to this point.

Key Ohio State offensive player gets real about Buckeyes OC Arthur Smith

“He’s a great coach, and just being able to listen to him and how he runs his offense and knowing that he’s been at every single level,” Roberts stated. “He’s such a smart guy that he comes over in our [drills] and teaches us and helps with our footwork and some of our routes just because he’s been through the game for so long.

“But listening to his offense and being in it for a couple of weeks now, I really enjoy it. I love it. I love his offense, and I know it’ll help me for the next level.”

Bringing in a veteran play caller allows Day to be in the CEO role, which he hasn’t been in since the 2024 national championship season. Ohio State should be able to blend together some of Smith’s run and passing concepts with the spread passing game Day has typically had. Bringing those two together should bring an explosive offense led by Julian Sayin and Jeremiah Smith.

Roberts’ comments show Smith has already come in and taken command of the players. When you have NFL head coaching experience and make the switch to the college level, players will naturally gravitate toward the coach. We’re talking about a team full of players at Ohio State who have aspirations of playing in the NFL.

Someone like Roberts has a chance to be the team’s top tight end with Max Klare and Will Kacmarek off to the NFL. Roberts played in 13 games as a true freshman and caught four passes for 30 yards. Ohio State went out and added Hunter Welcing and Mason Williams in the transfer portal, but Roberts is the most experienced player who returned.

Smith’s arrival has players excited to play for him, and while we don’t have a whole lot to go off of yet, the early signs are encouraging around Day’s key hire.

Just sayin': Click on the link to see video of entire interview.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top