• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Nico Iamaleava (QB Tennessee, bad poker player, transfer to UCLA)

I wouldn't argue with you at all. It's the in-between of models.

The old thing is dead/dying and the new thing isn't ready yet. Businesses, products, technologies, organizations, governments etc etc etc one model is on the way out and one is on the way in. That spot in the middle is chaotic.

That is what we are in right now with college football. Old model is broke, new model isn't built yet. I'm kind of taken back by all the pearl clutching to be honest. There is nothing new to mankind happening here. All the money flying around tells us the sport is in no danger of being killed/ruined/broken or whatever other hyperbole people want to throw out there.

It isn't any better or worse than it was before. It's just different.
This

Especially the last sentence

When this happens to “Businesses, products, technologies…” , in other words when it happens to markets, the chaos in between definitely includes objectively bad stuff. The examples are numerous. The markets for land when new western states were made eligible for settlement and the concomitant speculation bubbles, the market for silver in the 1890s and the bubble that created, the new markets for telephony, electricity, and the automobile that all had their bubbles pop at once…. Shit happens and it gets everywhere. In every case, those who adapted to what the new world would look like first did the best, while those who tried to profit from chaos were a sordid mix of villains and victims, sometimes all wrapped up in the same person.

It’s worse when it’s governments. Especially the former Soviet Union. It crashed with nothing in place to handle capitalism. They did not have a system of laws to handle property rights, so there were none. Most of the KGB became the Russian mafia, and they were the only organization there was for awhile. People became billionaires by hiring workers for starvation wages to tear up railroads to sell the tracks as scrap steel, others did the same in tearing up utility infrastructure to sell for scrap. Russia was destroyed and a handful of people became ridiculously wealthy because you had anarchy. Russian soldiers could be seen in Moscow, begging… in uniform… because the government couldn’t pay them. You can’t blame the transition on any form of government because there was none.

All of this to say that, yeah, this is messy. But the standards of value by which we judge this to be a bad thing are purely subjective. When these transitions happen in real life, the result has been hell on earth. This is, at worst, incommodious for those of us who liked things the way they were.

The only truly important thing in college football right now is the utter destruction of the DPIA. The rest is inconsequential
 
Upvote 0
incommodious

tenor.gif
 
Upvote 0
Devils advocate. Kid showed toughness against an OSU defense that was pissed off from the Game and ready to put some hits on anyone with the ball.
of course he also threatened to not play in the CFP iunless he got more money. Makes him a “me first” asshole, but consider the coaches who got more money for getting in the CFP. Sauce for the goose should be sauce for the gander.
just the same,glad to see OSU has no interest in him.
 
Upvote 0
I would imagine that NIl deals have some kind of clawback if one party doesn’t deliver. Who knows? I do t think anyone has ever seen one of those contracts to be honest.

As far as “where does it end?” I guess you have to define what you mean. Kids getting paid? It isn’t going to end.

Lack of organization and structure? I can only see it ending when athletes are employees, unionize and collectively bargain like all the other pro sports leagues do (that I am aware of).

To do that, the universities have to change something in their structure to be an employer of the athletes. That’s the part that’s going to be the biggest challenge imo.
While I think this is a reasonable viewpoint I would argue they went from "paying players is illegal" to "NIL" pretty darned quick, so I can happen if they want it to.

But I must reiterate: where does it end? Holding out of playoffs for more money can quickly morph into holding out for regular season games and then after a good game or two, holding out after a great play! It's not sustainable. Will it have to crash first before they do something? Probably.
 
Upvote 0
While I think this is a reasonable viewpoint I would argue they went from "paying players is illegal" to "NIL" pretty darned quick, so I can happen if they want it to.

But I must reiterate: where does it end? Holding out of playoffs for more money can quickly morph into holding out for regular season games and then after a good game or two, holding out after a great play! It's not sustainable. Will it have to crash first before they do something? Probably.

It’s hard to imagine that… but, by the same token, 10 years ago it would have been very hard to imagine where we are today. Anything is possible.

I hope that the pilots of this thing can pull back on the stick before it runs into the ground.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top