• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

NCAA - slowly ruining football (rules changes - merged)

The first 2 I totally agree with. A 2 minute warning? Just an excuse to add more commercials toward the end of both halves. Does nothing to improve the game but it does lengthen the game and bring in more advertising dollars.
Basically a free time out for each. I don't see the point in a 2m warning if the clock stops after a 1st while they set the chains.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Basically a free time out for each. I don't see the point in a 2m warning if the clock stops after a 1st while they set the chains.

An absurd rule change as college football
continuously makes its superior product to the NFL, more like the NFL.

Taking away the clock stoppage after a first down was already dumb, because one of the best differentiators to the NFL was college football’s number of plays per game. But in taking out a significant amount of plays per game (which sucks for the better team bc it creates more parity when you reduce the amount of times a team has to perform over the course of a game…..something Ryan Day routinely bitched about in various ways throughout last season) they didn’t actually reduce game time in any actual meaningful way. Games remained same length of time, just more ad filled. Plays per game did reduce….which defeats the purpose. It’s less actual football with more advertising….which sucks. And when you add up all the actual gameplay, in terms of actual plays run (where ball is snapped to the end of a play where guy is tackled, forced OB, or scores), you get something like 7-8 mins of actual gameplay. All the other time is spent getting plays in and reading coverages, making alignments at LOS.

I don’t know….i hate how much college has evolved to be like the NFL…college has had a superior product forever but they’re always making tweaks to be more like NFL rather than continuing down own path.
 
Upvote 0
Speculation that the new NFL rule change on kickoffs will come to the will eventually come to college.


College football coaches already preparing for the arrival of NFL's new kickoff play

The NFL will begin a new kickoff play in 2024 that will drastically increase return rates. Will college football follow the NFL's lead, just as it has in the past? College coaches think so, and they're already preparing.

Rule changes in the NFL usually trickle through college football within a year or two, so when the NFL approved Tuesday a drastic overhaul of kickoff plays designed to increase return rates, college coaches took notice.

"Wow," Georgia Tech special teams coordinator Ricky Brumfield told 247Sports. "Well, it'll be in college next year."

Such a change to kickoff plays in college football likely wouldn't be in place until at least 2025 (no NCAA committees have officially discussed the NFL's proposal), but just like college football adopted and adapted the NFL's other kickoff rule changes over the last 15 years, implementation seems inevitable.

That's if the NFL sticks with the new rules, which move kicking and return teams downfield in a more confined space, after a one-year trial period this fall. The new kickoff play is the most dramatic change to the sport in recent memory. The fallout could shake coaching philosophies and lead to never-before-seen innovations in play design.

"I actually like it. I think it simplifies the phase, reduces big collisions and reduces the run load on guys by removing 60-yard sprints on touchbacks," UCF special teams coordinator Brian Blackmon said. "It also will open up more returns and put a premium on field position. It makes it more like a punt return play than a current kickoff return."

WHAT EXACTLY IS THE NFL's NEW KICKOFF PLAY?​

The new kickoff format adopted by the NFL is a variation of the kickoff rules originating in the XFL, which tightens the field and blocking zones, and eliminates fair catches. Kickers will continue to kick from the 35-yard line, but the other 10 players must line up at the opponent's 40-yard line. At least nine members of the return team will line up in the "setup zone" between their own 30- and 35-yard lines, and up to two returners will line up in the "landing zone" between the goal line and 20-yard line.

Here's a diagram to help you visualize the NFL's new kickoff play:



The kick coverage team and blockers on the receiving team can only move once the football has been fielded by a returner or touches the ground inside the landing zone. Touchbacks result in the ball being placed at the 30-yard line. Balls that hit the ground inside the 20-yard line and roll into the end zone without a return will be placed on the 20-yard line. If it fails to cross the 20-yard line, it is ruled out of bounds, and the offense gets it at its own 40-yard line.


.
.
.
continued
 
Upvote 0

A lot of it before Connor Stalions became the biggest spy since James Bond. The NCAA Football Rules Committee and secretary rules-editor Steve Shaw have already let it be known electronic communications will be a "top of mind" issue in 2024.

Technology rules approved in football

Automatic timeouts to occur in the last 2 minutes of the 2nd and 4th quarters​

Optional technology rules in football, effective for the 2024 season, were approved by the NCAA Playing Rules Oversight Panel on Thursday.

In games involving Football Bowl Subdivision teams, each school will have the option to use coach-to-player communications through the helmet to one player on the field. That player will be identified by having a green dot on the back midline of the player's helmet.

The communication from the coach to the player will be turned off with 15 seconds remaining on the play clock or when the ball is snapped, whichever comes first.

For all three divisions, teams have the option of using tablets to view in-game video only. The video can include the broadcast feed and camera angles from the coach's sideline and coach's end zone.

Teams can have up to 18 active tablets for use in the coaching booth, sideline and locker room. Tablets cannot be connected to other devices to project larger additional images and cannot include analytics, data or data access capability or other communication access. All team personnel will be allowed to view the tablets during the game.

The Football Rules Committee, which met the last week of February, had a thorough discussion regarding wearable technologies.

The committee invites non-FBS conferences that are interested in using wearable technologies to submit an experimental proposal to the committee. Any proposals must be made to the committee by June 15.

Two-minute timeout​

The panel approved adding an automatic timeout when two minutes remain in the second and fourth quarters.

This rules change synchronizes all timing rules, such as 10-second runoffs and stopping the clock when a first down is gained in bounds, which coincides with the two-minute timeout.

First-down timing rules​

After a year of review, Division III committee members decided to adopt the timing rules where the game clock would continue to run when a first down is gained in bounds. The game clock will stop when a first down is gained during the last two minutes of either half. Division I and II schools used this timing rule last season.

Other rules changes​

  • Allowing conferences the option of using a collaborative replay review system. This will be formally added to the rules book; it had been an experimental rule.
  • Penalizing horse-collar tackles that occur within the tackle box as a 15-yard personal foul. Previously, a horse-collar tackle within the tackle box was not a foul.
Additionally, head coaches can conduct interviews with broadcast partners after the first and third quarters. This was allowed on an experimental basis last season and will be added as a permanent rule.

Optional technology rules in football, effective for the 2024 season, were approved by the NCAA Playing Rules Oversight Panel on Thursday. In games involving Football Bowl Subdivision teams, each school will have the option to use coach-to-player communications through the helmet to one player on the field. That player will be identified by having a green dot on the back midline of the player's helmet.

Just sayin': Sign stealing may be a thing of the past now.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

A lot of it before Connor Stalions became the biggest spy since James Bond. The NCAA Football Rules Committee and secretary rules-editor Steve Shaw have already let it be known electronic communications will be a "top of mind" issue in 2024.

Technology rules approved in football

Automatic timeouts to occur in the last 2 minutes of the 2nd and 4th quarters​

Optional technology rules in football, effective for the 2024 season, were approved by the NCAA Playing Rules Oversight Panel on Thursday.

In games involving Football Bowl Subdivision teams, each school will have the option to use coach-to-player communications through the helmet to one player on the field. That player will be identified by having a green dot on the back midline of the player's helmet.

The communication from the coach to the player will be turned off with 15 seconds remaining on the play clock or when the ball is snapped, whichever comes first.

For all three divisions, teams have the option of using tablets to view in-game video only. The video can include the broadcast feed and camera angles from the coach's sideline and coach's end zone.

Teams can have up to 18 active tablets for use in the coaching booth, sideline and locker room. Tablets cannot be connected to other devices to project larger additional images and cannot include analytics, data or data access capability or other communication access. All team personnel will be allowed to view the tablets during the game.

The Football Rules Committee, which met the last week of February, had a thorough discussion regarding wearable technologies.

The committee invites non-FBS conferences that are interested in using wearable technologies to submit an experimental proposal to the committee. Any proposals must be made to the committee by June 15.

Two-minute timeout​

The panel approved adding an automatic timeout when two minutes remain in the second and fourth quarters.

This rules change synchronizes all timing rules, such as 10-second runoffs and stopping the clock when a first down is gained in bounds, which coincides with the two-minute timeout.

First-down timing rules​

After a year of review, Division III committee members decided to adopt the timing rules where the game clock would continue to run when a first down is gained in bounds. The game clock will stop when a first down is gained during the last two minutes of either half. Division I and II schools used this timing rule last season.

Other rules changes​

  • Allowing conferences the option of using a collaborative replay review system. This will be formally added to the rules book; it had been an experimental rule.
  • Penalizing horse-collar tackles that occur within the tackle box as a 15-yard personal foul. Previously, a horse-collar tackle within the tackle box was not a foul.
Additionally, head coaches can conduct interviews with broadcast partners after the first and third quarters. This was allowed on an experimental basis last season and will be added as a permanent rule.



Just sayin': Sign stealing may be a thing of the past now.
Still likely a thing cause they will occasionally use hand signs to adjust the play or go fast but easier to negate when you think someone has them. Just huddle up and use comms
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top