Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
When is this going to become official? Damn NCAA
<H1 class=red>NCAA set to reveal OSU's fate
</H1>
Friday, March 10, 2006
Doug Lesmerises
Plain Dealer Reporter
Columbus- The NCAA will announce its final punishments for the Ohio State men's basketball team today, one hour before the Buckeyes play their first game of the Big Ten Tournament.
The timing brings the saga full circle, the investigation into transgressions committed under Jim O'Brien concluding as coach Thad Matta and this year's players work toward a No. 1 seed in the NCAA Tournament.
All along, Ohio State has expected that the Buckeyes will escape any postseason bans, the university having self-imposed an NCAA ban last season.
But even the remote possibility had lingered over this entire season, and the wondering will end today.
More likely, the school will be forced to erase the past, taking down championship banners, including one for the 1999 Final Four, and giving back money earned during that NCAA Tournament run. Athletic Director Gene Smith told WSYX-TV in Columbus that if the Buckeyes do have to pay back money, it would amount to about $800,000.
The NCAA's decision will be made public in an 11 a.m. conference call. An hour later, blocks away from NCAA headquarters, Ohio State will play Penn State at noon.
To reach this Plain Dealer reporter:
[email protected], 216-999-4748
NCAA announces penalties today
Friday, March 10, 2006
The NCAA will announce penalties this morning for infractions in the Ohio State men’s basketball program.
• Possible penalties include returning NCAA Tournament revenue, removing banners in Value City Arena, vacating games and records, a reduction in scholarships and probation. A postseason ban is unlikely.
• The NCAA will discuss the penalties during a teleconference for news media at 11 a.m.
Going, going, gone?
Removing banners like shot in heart, coach says
Friday, March 10, 2006
Rob Oller
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
JONATHAN QUILTER | DISPATCH The Ohio State men’s baskeball banners in the Scottenstein Center likely are soon to be minus several numbers after the NCAA releases its ruling today.
More than history will be affected if the NCAA penalizes Ohio State today by instructing the university to remove "1999" from men’s basketball banners in Value City Arena.
Woven through the fabric are the dreams of players from the 1999 Final Four team who worked hard to achieve their goals, former Ohio State assistant coach Dave Spiller said.
"You’re taking more than a banner down. For some of these kids, the hard work to get to that point . . . would be like taking a shotgun and shooting them in the heart," said Spiller, adding that the sense of accomplishment for players on the team that reached the NCAA Tournament semifinals in 1999 should not be treated as if that season never existed.
"They all worked for the dream of someday cutting down a net in the Final Four," said Spiller, who coached at OSU from 1997 to 2001 and now works as a recruiting coordinator at Ohio Sports Plus in Worthington. "That’s the purpose kids go to school and keep their grades up, so they can have that opportunity."
Former Buckeye Will Dudley, who played on the 1999 team, said it would be unfair to punish the entire team for the act of one or two individuals, but that removing banners and deleting records would not erase what happened that season.
"All that stuff we accomplished was on the court," said Dudley, a teacher and assistant boys basketball coach at Harvest Prep. "Even other coaches at other schools and teams we beat know that this stuff happens on the court, when the ball goes up in the air, that’s what decides those banners."
The Final Four banner likely would not be the only one to receive cosmetic surgery. The NCAA violations — that former coach Jim O’Brien gave cash to the mother of a recruit and that player Boban Savovic received improper benefits in the care of Kathleen Salyers of Gahanna — allegedly occurred during the four seasons (1998-99 to 2001-02) Savovic was on the team.
The Buckeyes won Big Ten regular-season titles in 2000 and 2002 and the Big Ten tournament title in 2002. The numbers on those banners likely would be removed, too.
Another condition of the punishment could be that OSU would vacate wins and losses during that stretch, which would put the team record at 0-0 each of those four seasons.
Instead of punishing former players by altering banners, Spiller suggested another course of action.
"Maybe make the school pay back some money and limit the amount of scholarships for a couple of years," he said.
Both of those scenarios could happen. Ohio State would likely have to repay earnings from its NCAA Tournament appearances. Athletics director Gene Smith last night confirmed estimates that the total would be about $800,000 in an interview with television station WSYX. The school also could face further loss of scholarships. The university-imposed penalties in 2004 included the loss of two scholarships this season.
An NCAA official, speaking on condition of anonymity, could not confirm whether OSU would lose more scholarships but explained that the penalty typically fits the crime.
"In cases where there is academic fraud, no, there would probably not be a loss of scholarships," the official said. "If you have a player who was ineligible, then maybe."
None of the NCAA allegations against Ohio State includes the participation of an ineligible player, but the organization does tend to penalize schools beyond just removing banners, erasing records and vacating wins and losses. It is doubtful Ohio State will face a postseason ban — the school already banned itself from postseason play in 2005 — but the trend is for the NCAA to be harder on a school than it was on itself.
Spiller hopes that’s not the case.
"You have to respect the NCAA, but hopefully the NCAA understands that what (the 1999 team) accomplished, those kids want to sit down with their own kids someday and see those records," he said.
[email protected]
COMMENTARY
NCAA can erase records, but can’t erase memories
Friday, March 10, 2006
BOB HUNTER
ED REINKE | ASSOCIATED PRESS Coach Jim O’Brien holds the net after the Buckeyes won the NCAA South Regional championship on March 20, 1999.
So that 1999 Final Four never happened?
Really? Man, I’d swear Ohio State played Connecticut in the semifinals that year. If I were going to dream something up, couldn’t I do better than thousands of Buckeyes fans whooping it up in Tropicana Field?
The likelihood that the NCAA will have Ohio State wipe its 1999 basketball accomplishments from the rafters and the record books for rules violations has disoriented me a little. It still seems like that incredible Saturday in Knoxville, Tenn., the one when the Buckeyes beat St. John’s to qualify for the Final Four, is as real as the Purdue game Sunday. I can still picture Scoonie Penn sprinting around the floor like a lunatic when the game ended. I can still picture George Reese riding piggyback on Shamar Herron’s shoulders and Ken Johnson setting what must have been a tournament record for postgame tears.
It never happened? That’s weird.
I don’t know what to think of the NCAA possibly rewriting history because of coach Jim O’Brien’s $6,000 gift to a recruit’s needy parent and player Boban Savovic’s doting nanny.
Maybe I’ve read and watched too much science fiction. It just occurred to me that this is like a movie in which some poor sap discovers he never existed. He looks in an album and he’s no longer in the family photo at Niagara Falls. He runs to the fireplace to see if the high-school graduation photos of him and his three sisters are still hanging there, and finds his spot occupied by the family dog. He tries to find some trace of himself somewhere "they" didn’t think of — his high-school yearbook, the phone book, the address label on a magazine. But he’s gone. History. Kaput.
But when I checked my Ohio State media guide yesterday a few hours after we learned that the NCAA had notified the school of its punishment, there was the picture of the 1999 Buckeyes with "NCAA Final Four" under it. The Buckeyes’ names were still in my media guide from the 1999 tournament.
There’s still an Ohio State logo on a 1999 Final Four pin that lies with other memorabilia, a few pennies and some lint at the bottom of one of my desk drawers.
So it turns out that the NCAA is relying on all of us to just forget about it, or at least pretend that it didn’t happen. A few honest souls might do that, but it seems like a pretty inefficient system to me.
A lot has been said about how it was unfair that last year’s team wasn’t permitted to go to the NCAA Tournament because of infractions committed while some of the players were in junior high school. This memory-purging business isn’t exactly fair to the rule-abiding members of the 1999 team, either.
But then, punishing the right person in these situations is never easy. Rules were broken. Somebody has to pay. O’Brien? He has been fired. Athletics director Andy Geiger? Retired. Savovic? Now, we’re talking; he’s the one player who allegedly received improper benefits. So if anybody can find him, they should confiscate his Final Four hat and T-shirt just as quickly as possible.
Truthfully, given the lengths this situation was allowed to go, this is probably the best possible outcome for Ohio State. It would have been even more unfair to tell this year’s team that it couldn’t play in a postseason tournament, especially after it won an undisputed Big Ten title and might be in line for a No. 2 seed in the NCAA Tournament. And, if the penalties were allowed to carry over to next year, that would have sabotaged a recruiting class that had nothing to do with coaches who weren’t here at the time.
Besides, Michael Redd, Jason Singleton, Neshaun Coleman, Jon Sanderson and the rest know they made it there, and they sure aren’t going to voluntarily part with their memories just because the NCAA says they didn’t exist.
If I’m not mistaken, their joy was in the journey, not in some stupid banner.
That’s something the rule book monitors can never take away.
Bob Hunter is a sports columnist for The Dispatch
.
[email protected]