DREW SHARP: Clarett's legacy will be footnote
His shortcomings make NFL's case
March 5, 2005
BY DREW SHARP
FREE PRESS COLUMNIST
ESPN interrupted the 974th airing of the biopic "3" Friday afternoon with breaking news. Maurice Clarett had finally finished his 40-yard sprint at the NFL scouting combine -- six days after he started.
His actual time was inconclusive at first because scouts have long since forgotten how to read a sundial.
Needless to say, Clarett shouldn't worry about staying near the phone on the first day of the draft, April 23.
Paybacks are nasty, aren't they?
The NFL legal beagles got a hearty laugh at Clarett's expense in Indianapolis. In five seconds, he did more to validate the league's argument for age restrictions than the NFL did in five months of courtroom wrangling.
Clarett fought the lonely battle as college football's reincarnation of Curt Flood. He was confident that even if a league-orchestrated vendetta damaged his draft prospects, his impassioned fight against the system would open the doors for those who followed him.
But instead of a legacy, Clarett merits only a footnote.
Age restrictions have only gained traction in the year-and-a-half since Clarett sued the NFL, objecting to the league's rule against drafting players until they were three years past high school graduation.
The NFL won, and now there's speculation that the NBA probably will win, too, when it attempts to restrict its draft to players 20 or older. Not too long ago, the NBA players association categorically rejected the notion, but reports coming out of the All-Star weekend indicate that the union might surrender on the age issue if it wins more revenue concessions from the owners.
The NFL probably doesn't have to sweat another legal challenge, although there would be some interesting candidates.
Don't you think Oklahoma's fabulous running back Adrian Peterson might be ready to test the waters should he win the Heisman Trophy as a sophomore next season?
But a scout told me recently that Clarett's difficulties since he left Ohio State only strengthened the NFL's argument that players need more maturity and experience before entering the league.
There's no sympathy for Clarett. His failure to run 40 yards in less than 4.7 seconds dropped him to the sixth round at best -- and that's only if a team feels particularly charitable.
It has been one misstep after another since his unceremonious departure from Ohio State. He showed up at last year's combine with a middle-aged paunch, which NFL people considered an indictment of his discipline.
Clarett dedicated himself to better defining his physique. But he realized a month ago that the added bulk sapped his quickness. Desperate with time running out, he went through a crash diet to get his weight below 220 when he got to Indianapolis, thinking it would restore some speed.
Instead, he came across as ill-prepared.
Clarett strengthened the NFL's flimsy rationale that it is simply interested in the well-being of those young men who misguidedly think they're ready for the physical and mental rigors of football's highest level.
The NFL and NBA should have the latitude to bargain for specific entry rules for their rookies, but nobody buys the position that they're primarily interested in doing what's best for 18- and 19-year-olds.
The NFL wants to maintain a developmental system (a.k.a. NCAA football) that comes at absolutely no cost to the league. Clarett looks like someone who definitely needed the additional structure that another two years of college football would have provided.
He becomes the star of the newest "Don't Let This Happen to You" instructional video.
The NBA might get a 20-year-old age limit, but that doesn't mean the 7-footers who want to bolt for the draft just weeks after the senior prom will go to college for a couple of years.
The NBA will have to subsidize a legitimate minor league system to accommodate players who don't want the charade of being a student.
But who thought a year ago that an age restraint was even possible in basketball?
Some think that the most important point in this mess isn't that Clarett's failed, but that he got the opportunity to fail. And that will inspire others to challenge the NFL in the future.
But if they take an honest look at where Clarett's road has taken him since he last touched a football more than two years ago, they will realize the prudent course is patience.
Contact DREW SHARP at 313-223-4055 or
[email protected].