Dryden said:
Really? Is this something you've maintained privately? I'd be interested to know the numbers for the top programs in All-Americans (1st team, 2nd team, total, etc.).
Figures. I'm currently working on All-Americans Dryden, but that is a tought and time involved project. And yes, it's something I maintain privately. I do have all other position awards and CFHOF entries for all D-1 schools. When I'm done (with AAs) I'll let you know. The problems is that there are so many different All American lists AP, UP(I), Walter Camp, SI, Billybobs Newspaper, etc., etc, etc. So what do you list? I'm attempting to find information on as many different ones as possible, but it will be a long process. It is time consuming because there are multiple winners and multiple teams for each year ... much more data input than a single Heisman winner for each year. It become even more intricate when to attempt to quantify Consensus All-Americans. That would be folks who won All-American status on a majority of All-American lists.
I think an easy place for you to start is at the NCAA web site. They have a listing of Consensus All-Americans up through 2000 (I believe) in PDF format. If you have problems finding it, let me know and I'll find the link for you. IIRC Yale leads the list in total All-Americans followed by Notre Dame, Michigan, Ohio State, etc.
EDIT: Here's the link:
http://www.ncaafootball.net/doc_lib/award_winners_2001.pdf
Here's the Consensus All-American Leaders by Team
Team.........................No.....Players
Yale ..........................100.....69
Notre Dame .................93.....77
Harvard.......................89.....59
Michigan .....................68.....56
Ohio St. .....................65.....50
Princeton......................65.....49
Southern California .......61.....54
Oklahoma....................57.....47
Nebraska.....................52.....43
Pittsburgh .....................48.....41
Pennsylvania ................46.....32
Texas ..........................40.....35
Alabama .....................38.....37
Army ...........................37.....28
Tennessee ....................34.....25
Penn St. ......................33.....31
UCLA ..........................32.....28
Minnesota....................32.....27
Florida St. ...................31.....25
Miami (Fla.) .................30.....27
Colorado .....................27.....23
Stanford.......................26.....21
Auburn ........................24.....22
California ....................24.....22
Michigan St. ...............24.....21
Navy...........................23.....20
Georgia.......................23.....19
Illinois..........................23.....18
Florida.........................22.....21