Madden 06 vs. NCAA 06

[ScarletBlood31]

Ok, if you were limited to only buying one of these games (regardless of console you have), which would you buy? Basically, which do you think is the better game and more worth the price tag.

 

[starBUCKS]

I am a way bigger college football fan than I am NFL, but Madden is a much better game than NCAA. The graphics are 10X better and the playability is more realistic.

 

[BuckeyeNation27]

NCAA. I'm a bigger college football fan also....plus I played madden last week and it sucked. I haven't played since Marshall Faulk was on the cover because the game right after that turned into an arcade 80 yard bomb fest.

 

[BrutusMaximus]

No comparison. I personally think 2006 is the worse madden ever.

 

[ToddziLLa]

NCAA hands down. This is actually the first year I haven't been at Best Buy the day Madden was released, and not missing it a bit...

 

[gotwoody]

i like madden better, its more realistic. i like ncaa but the thing is so many easy passes get dropped and it gets really annoying after awhile

 

[Penguin-BUCK]

Ncaa

i like madden better, its more realistic. i like ncaa but the thing is so many easy passes get dropped and it gets really annoying after awhile

I like both, but prefer the Universities playing more than the cities, so NCAA. I do get aggravated with all those easy dropped throws

 

[bucksjam22]

College Football is way Better!

This is the worst Madden ever while NCAA football gets better every year!:osu:

 

[SanAntonioBuck]

I like both, but prefer the Universities playing more than the cities, so NCAA. I do get aggravated with all those easy dropped throws

Plus, all the miracle 4th qtr. comebacks by the CPU.

 

[jwinslow]

NCAA. I'm a bigger college football fan also....plus I played madden last week and it sucked. I haven't played since Marshall Faulk was on the cover because the game right after that turned into an arcade 80 yard bomb fest.

um, you haven't been playing madden for a while, have you? It's been pretty hard to throw bombs for at least two years. In fact, you have to burn your opponent by 7 yards or have a burner vs. lber to complete a bomb.

NCAA is an arcade game with an unbelievably great dynasty. Madden's dynasty isn't that great, and the superstar thing blows (but so does the Race for the Heisman).

The gamebreaker thing seems cool at first, but is pretty gay after a while. You can rely on breaking a tackle 95% of the time. There are way too many dropped passes, and the defenses do not respond to your repeated playcalls like they do in madden.

I love NCAA more, but in terms of gameplay Madden is much better. The QB vision is very realistic, and a very good addition. You can't just run around with a mobile QB anymore and throw it wherever you want. Also, the defenses do a great job adjusting to playcalling, esp if you try to scramble a lot with your QB.

 

[MistriBuck]

i think for the first time ever NCAA has surpassed Madden............i've only played 5-6 games of Madden this year, but in the past from the moment i picked it up i had to admit it was a better game than NCAA in terms of graphics and realism............this year to me it seems to have gotten very acardish, and the physics are not nearly as smooth as NCAA.............i have one buddy who is a hardcore sports gamer like me, and he always completely stops playing NCAA the day Madden comes out, this year he sold his Madden