Kentucky coach indicted for reckless homicide in player's heat death

[Redhawk]

Kentucky coach indicted for reckless homicide in player's heat death

LOUISVILLE, Ky. (AP) -- A Kentucky high school football coach was charged Thursday with reckless homicide in the death of one of his players who collapsed at practice on a hot day.
A grand jury indicted David Jason Stinson in the death of Pleasure Ridge Park offensive lineman Max Gilpin. Stinson was directing practice on Aug. 20, when the heat index reached 94 degrees in Louisville where the school is located. The 15-year-old Gilpin collapsed and had trouble breathing.
When the sophomore reached Kosair Children's Hospital, he had a temperature of 107 degrees and died there three days later.
The reckless homicide charge means grand jurors didn't find that Stinson's actions were intentional or malicious, said Jefferson County Commonwealth's Attorney Dave Stengel. However, Stengel said, "a reasonable man should have realized something like this could have occurred."
Stinson's attorney, Alex Dathorne, told The Associated Press that the coach maintains his innocence and looks forward to "bringing out the whole story."
"We're certainly disappointed in the grand jury's decision to indict," Dathorne said.
Stengel said Stinson, who coached the whole 2008 season, will surrender Monday at his arraignment and likely will remain free pending trial.
Stengel said he reviewed the actions of five assistant coaches who were on the field that day and determined they committed no criminal act.
Lauren Roberts, a spokeswoman for the Jefferson County Public Schools, said she's aware of the indictment, but the school system had not been formally notified about the charge.
"We'll be making a determination about his status with the district," Roberts said.
Elden May, a Kentucky High School Athletic Association spokesman, declined comment.
Stinson asked to testify in front of the grand jurors but they declined to hear him, Stengel said. The grand jury heard only from a Louisville Metro Police detective.
Gilpin's parents, Glenna Michele Crockett and Jeffrey Dean Gilpin, sued Stinson and the five assistant coaches in state court accusing them of negligence and "reckless disregard."
Along with the lawsuit and criminal investigation, the school system has been conducting its own investigation, which was still pending Thursday.

 

[fourteenandoh]

94 is nothing. as long as he provided adequate water breaks i don't see how he was supposed to see that coming. if he withheld water breaks for a long time then that's a bit different.

 

[Jake]

the heat index reached 94 degrees in Louisville where the school is located. The 15-year-old Gilpin collapsed and had trouble breathing.
When the sophomore reached Kosair Children's Hospital, he had a temperature of 107 degrees and died there three days later.

The reckless homicide charge means grand jurors didn't find that Stinson's actions were intentional or malicious, said Jefferson County Commonwealth's Attorney Dave Stengel. However, Stengel said, "a reasonable man should have realized something like this could have occurred."

I'm sorry the kid died but why would a reasonable man realize something like this could have occurred? How often are 15 year olds dropping over with 107 degree fevers and dying 3 days later? Is this something that happens frequently? What is the statistical probability?

To reasonably expect that "could happen" is akin to expecting a "reasonable man" to cancel practice altogether, because a meteorite might land on the field. After all, that "could happen", too. It's extremely unlikely, but it could happen.

 

[scooter1369]

I did two a days in 114 degree heat indexes. Not everyone can handle those kind of temps. Sadly, you find out who can't by things like this happening.

 

[WoodyWorshiper]

I did two a days in 114 degree heat indexes. Not everyone can handle those kind of temps. Sadly, you find out who can't by things like this happening.

Excellent point. The reference behind the word "tragedy" is that it somehow could have been avoided, and that's why it's saved for Mythology, because who in the hell could see this coming.

I'm not a doctor or a weatherman, but to me, I'd guess 94 degree heat index to be somewhere about 85 degree temps with about 70% humidity, or somewhere in that range. Certainly not a reason to cancel a practice. For a single player to drop in these conditions would lead me to believe that there were other medical issues involved. This is horrible for this players family and loved ones, but to hold the Coach accountable, to me, is ludicrous.

Peace.

 

[BUCKYLE]

Um, I'm not sure about you guys, but when I was in HS, our trainer would bring out some fuckin' contraption, spin that fucker over his head, and if it reached whatever number, we didn't wear pads. It's pretty fucking easy to avoid shit like this as far as I know.

 

[stxbuck]

94 is nothing. as long as he provided adequate water breaks i don't see how he was supposed to see that coming. if he withheld water breaks for a long time then that's a bit different.

This pretty much sums it up. The team I work with has certainly practiced plenty in 94 degree heat.

 

[jimotis4heisman]

94 is nothing. as long as he provided adequate water breaks i don't see how he was supposed to see that coming. if he withheld water breaks for a long time then that's a bit different.

bear bryant says water is for losers...

 

[BuckNutty]

Um, I'm not sure about you guys, but when I was in HS, our trainer would bring out some fuckin' contraption, spin that fucker over his head, and if it reached whatever number, we didn't wear pads. It's pretty fucking easy to avoid shit like this as far as I know.

 

[DaytonBuck]

PRP is hood

 

[Redhawk]

Louisville high school football David Jason Stinson coach facing charges - More Sports - SI.com

LOUISVILLE, Ky. (AP) -- Football players know them as "gassers" -- sprints up and down the field to build stamina. Sophomore Max Gilpin and his Pleasure Ridge Park teammates spent the tail end of a three-hour practice on a sweltering August day in Louisville running the drill that is a coaching staple across the country, hoping to impress enough to earn varsity playing time that fall.

They sprinted 12 times in what felt like 94-degree heat, sometimes with helmets and pads, as the coaches pushed them to go harder and harder. It was a drill like those on many high school football fields, until Gilpin, a 6-foot-2, 220-pound offensive lineman, collapsed to the turf just 15 minutes after a teammate went down.

Three days later, the 15-year-old Gilpin was dead from heat stroke, with authorities saying his body temperature was 107 degrees when he reached the hospital. Five months later, his first-year head coach David Jason Stinson is facing a reckless homicide charge, with a prosecutor saying the coach should have realized a player could get heat stroke in such broiling weather. Harold Jarrard, whose grandson played on the offensive line, was there Aug. 20 and said coaches were shouting at the players, encouraging them to pick it up as practice wound down.

"It was just a normal day of practice," he said. "They always run gassers at the end. It's a daily activity. Nothing was different that day. I never heard anything out of the ordinary. "You hear them being threatened every day, stuff like 'If you don't straighten up, you're out of here.' It was just regular," he said.

Interviews with witnesses and a review of filings in a civil lawsuit brought by Gilpin's parents against the coaching staff, including depositions, Stinson's handwritten notes and weather logs filed with the school, shed some light on what happened that day. For Brian Bale, who was watching his daughter play soccer on an adjacent field during most of football practice, the way coaches were yelling at players was "appalling," he said in an e-mail to the school district two days later. Bale declined an interview request from The Associated Press on Friday.

But he wrote in the e-mail: "Those coaches thought that they were training young teenagers for the Navy SEALS team instead of a football team. I never once in the time I was there saw anyone offered a water break. I did, however, hear the coach say numerous times that all he needed was one person to say that they quit the team and all of the suffering and running and heat would be over."
That's exactly what Kim Englert's son, David, did -- quit that day.

David Englert said "Coach Stinson made the team run sprints until someone quit," Gilpin's mother, Michele Crockett, said in court filings. Heat exposure deaths happen occasionally in football from the sandlot to the pros, the most famous example being Minnesota Vikings offensive lineman Korey Stringer in 2001. Lawsuits have been filed in many of those cases, but it doesn't appear that a coach has ever been criminally charged.

Commonwealth's Attorney Dave Stengel declined to say why he chose this case for a grand jury. Stinson, a technical teacher at the school who has been reassigned pending the outcome of the case, is scheduled to be arraigned on Monday. His attorney, Alex Dathorne, did not return calls from The Associated Press on Friday.

Jarrard said Gilpin's death weighed heavily on Stinson throughout the season as the Panthers finished with a 4-4 record. The coach brought Gilpin's jersey to each game in tribute, though he made no changes to his team's practice routine, according to his notes. "He's a real gentleman, he's got kids of his own," Jarrard said. "He lost a boy that day, too."

Stinson is no stranger to hot August football training camps. The former high school and college offensive lineman played briefly with the NFL's New York Giants. At the 1,900-student Pleasure Ridge Park, he spent three years as the offensive line coach before taking over the team in January 2008.

Stinson's weather log showed a heat index of 94 degrees as practice started at 2:30 p.m. The index is a measure of how hot it feels based on temperature and humidity. A small group watched the workout, including Gilpin's father, Jeff Gilpin, who sat next to Jarrard for most of the final two hours of the session, according to Jarrard and court documents.

Practice began with players congregating in the locker room before moving on to weights and film review. They took the field at 3:45 p.m. The team went through a variety of stretches and drills for about an hour before being given three water breaks in a 30-minute period, the log shows.

Then at 5:30 p.m. came the gassers.
About a half-hour later, the first player collapsed, and Stinson sent him to a nearby tree for shade and treated him with water and ice packs, according to the coach's notes. Gilpin collapsed 15 minutes later, at about 6:10 p.m., as the rest of the team headed for the shade tree for an end-of-practice meeting. Assistant coach Steve Deacon called 911 when Gilpin stopped responding to ice packs and water. In the call, made at 6:17 p.m., Deacon describes Gilpin as pale, with a "big rapid pulse."

"Yes ... he's breathing ... yeah ... he's going ... kinda going in and out on us though," Deacon said. Christina Spiva, the mother of another Pleasure Ridge Park student, called Gilpin's mother a few minutes later. "You need to get here quick. He's been down here for a while and I don't think they are moving fast enough," Spiva said. Crockett arrived at the school at 6:27 p.m. and found her son limp, with bloodshot eyes staring straight ahead, an ice pack behind his neck and a hose spilling water over the pack. Two people were pumping his legs to "keep Max's circulation going," Crockett said. Crockett did not return calls to The Associated Press and a phone number found for Jeff Gilpin was not his.

Paramedics arrived about the same time and made an unsuccessful attempt at putting a tube down Max Gilpin's throat before rushing him to the hospital, where he remained for three days before he died of septic shock, multiple organ failure and heat stroke. His teammate who collapsed was released several days later.

Gilpin was one of six heat-related deaths in high school and college athletics in 2008, said Dr. Frederick Mueller with the National Center for Catastrophic Injury Research at the University of North Carolina.

More than 120 athletes have died under similar circumstances since 1931.

 

[sepia5]

David Englert said "Coach Stinson made the team run sprints until someone quit," Gilpin's mother, Michele Crockett, said in court filings.

That will be what the prosecution hangs its hat on, IMO--that he pushed the kids at the end of the practice until they couldn't go anymore, and without water. We all know this goes on every summer in every corner of the country (not that it necessarily should), and I think the result of the criminal trial will be all about the composition of the jury. It's a lot easier to prove recklessness than other criminal states of mind.

 

[BigWoof31]

Um, I'm not sure about you guys, but when I was in HS, our trainer would bring out some [censored]in' contraption, spin that [censored]er over his head, and if it reached whatever number, we didn't wear pads. It's pretty [censored]ing easy to avoid [censored] like this as far as I know.

Yup, same thing down here in the south. We always staggered our two-a-days in the summer. The morning practice kicked off at 7:00am and was full pads. That we we could get a good 3 hours in while it was cool and dew was on the grass.

After practice, shower up, lunch was provided by the booster club, watch some film, stretch and start again at 3:00pm in "shells." Just helmets and shoulder pads.

 

[scooter1369]

I seem to recall our coach had a similar contraption. If he walked outside and his hair caught fire, we didn't practice.