Don’t bet on Millwood, Elarton
Friday, December 9, 2005 <TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD>
By ANDY CALL
REPOSITORY SPORTS WRITER
At least three of the pitchers who helped the Indians compile the best ERA in the American League last year probably won’t be back in 2006.
General Manager Mark Shapiro said Thursday it is unlikely that veteran right-handed starters Kevin Millwood and Scott Elarton, both free agents, will return to the Indians. Right-handed setup man Bobby Howry has signed with the Cubs.
“From Day 1, I’ve never felt like we could do everything we needed to do,” Shapiro said. “There is not a lot of quality on the free-agent market, and we do have a lot of competition for the guys who can impact us.”
The Indians signed right-handed starter Paul Byrd on Monday and brought back closer Bob Wickman on Wednesday after being spurned by San Diego closer Trevor Hoffman.
Millwood, who led the American League in ERA last summer (2.86), is seeking a five-year contract.
“I’ve kept the possibility of us signing Kevin open,” Shapiro said. “At this point, the likelihood is very remote to almost impossible.”
Elarton has been a solid No. 5 starter for two seasons (11-9, 4.61 ERA in 2005), but that success means another team will either offer Elarton a multi-year contract or more money than the Indians are willing to spend.
“It’s the exact same situation we faced with Omar Vizquel,” Shapiro said. “We like the guy. But there are limited dollars, good minor-league alternatives and needs in other areas of our major-league club.”
Elarton’s spot could be opened to a spring-training competition among young starters Jason Davis, Fausto Carmona and Jeremy Sowers.
Shapiro said he would prefer to have a veteran to replace Howry, although young relief pitchers like Fernando Cabrera have shown promise.
“I would feel more comfortable with one more veteran reliever, but we could put a very good bullpen together with the bodies we have,” Shapiro said.
The Indians might pursue a hitter, particularly one to play right field or first base. Manager Eric Wedge said this week the team has some interest in former All-Star shortstop Nomar Garciaparra to play right field. Recent media reports seem to indicate, however, that another team will offer Garciaparra either more money or the chance to play a more familiar position.
“It gets back to the age-old value equation for us,” Shapiro said. “We’ll go where we find the greatest value and where our money can make the biggest impact.”
The Indians plan to increase last year’s $42 million payroll to about $55 million for 2006.
n
The Indians did not lose any players in Thursday’s Rule 5 draft, nor did they take any from other organizations. Shapiro said the team had anticipated some top minor-leaguers would be chosen by other clubs.
“I’m ecstatic we were able to hold on to a guy like Ryan Mulhern,” Shapiro said of the Class AA Akron left fielder, who slugged an organization-high 32 home runs last season and drove in 94 runs. “It could be that the major-league rosters are just a little more clogged this year.” Mulhern and Sowers were named the organization’s player and pitcher of the year Thursday. Reach Repository sports writer Andy Call at (330) 580-8346 or e-mail
[email protected].
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>