Absolutes are fun. I guess, using that logic, Bill Belichick shouldn't be successful in New England after his debacle at Cleveland, Gary Moeller shouldn't have won 3 consecutive Big Ten titles at Michigan after his shitshow at Illinois, and Doc Rivers had no business winning an NBA title after ruining the Magic and running the Celtics further into the ground.
It's funny what, you know, talented players can do for a coach's reputation. Just like I don't buy into the "Tressel can't get his team ready for the Big Game" crap, I don't buy the "Zook can't get his team ready to win consistently on the road" schtick. You guys ran into two hot-at-the-right-time SEC teams that were finally healthy. We followed up two emotional home wins over #21 and #5 by laying an egg at Iowa. Most rational Illinois fans were OK with that, not swirled into an angry mob marching on Jeremy Foley's house.
Again, I feel like you guys are viewing our orange and blue world through your scarlet glasses. We're overjoyed at 4-loss seasons. You would be distraught. We're giddy at the prospect of the Outback Bowl and would send 20,000 strong. Your seasons are disappointments if you don't make a BCS bowl. Whereas the Zook losses in the State of Mississippi were meltdown inducing in Gator-land, our loss at Iowa was more of a "well, that was bound to happen after getting ranked for the first time since 2001."
Is Zook a perfect coach? No. But then again, you never sat through seasons with Ron Turner and Lou Tepper. 15 years of 62-96 football (2.4 Big Ten wins per season and 3 bowls) will tend to change a man's perspective. And even though we got destroyed, my view from the end zone of the Rose Bowl was downright gorgeous.