I would counter that it's more about adjusting fan "interest" than anything else. For instance, what turns you off about kids getting paid? How does that change the sport? I ask because, hopefully, you understand that they have always been paid.
That's literally what I was going to say. It's ironic how now so many fans are sanctimonious and self righteous when kids are getting paid out in the open in a legal fashion. But those same fans had no problem with the McDonald's bags, Duffel bags, sketchy meetings, secret jobs for parents, etc...
I don't care much for pro sports because there isn't much of a personal connection to any of those teams; it's just business. With NIL and unlimited transferring, that special connection and school pride is going by the wayside and that's a massive part of what makes the game great, imo.
I also don't understand the complaints of thinking that college sports are NOW just businesses. They've always been about business! Why do you think the SEC puffs its chest out every year? Programs look for competitive advantages every year, with or without NIL. If they aren't out right paying players, they're over signing, giving BS satellite camps to target specific players, giving parents jobs, heck Bama literally destroyed the UAB football program because they saw them as a threat! Does that help with the special connection to a school? For those that want "purity" of CFB, and that special connection, like I've said before, go root for Tiffin or Wittenburg.
Every sport needs at least some semblance of structure and regulation anyway. College football and basketball have practically none. That's not a good recipe for long term fan interest.
My argument is, when has there ever been a semblance of structure and regulation in college sports? There have been scandals in college sports since its inception! If anything, what aTm is paying isn't anything compared to the amount that they earn off of these players. The $30mil aTm shelled out was peanuts since they probably sold a few more season ticket packages, more VIP event tickets, etc. So whether the kids stay or not, they're money will be made back easily.
Fans will root for winners. So fans will enjoy if their team is in the hunt. OSU fans will complain, but when we beat scUM and get into the CFP, most will root or remain silent about NIL. And if we win the CFP, I envision any of those fans complaining about NIL to be quiet or forget about their protests all together. Its easy to complain in the off season and when your team didn't get into the CFP hunt late last season. Success gives many amnesia