That's a long contract, but I believe he was signed through 2025 at Butler, so wasn't much choice.
I think this is about as good a hire as we could have made, outside of pipe dreams like Billy Donovan and Sean Miller.
I've said since the idea of replacing Matta became a legit topic that the idea that the next coach could replicate Matta's success was a risky idea. While it isn't the standard I personally will hold him to, I think Holtmann gives us the best chance of approaching those days as anybody that has been realistically discussed.
Comparing him to Matta directly, I think he's a superior in game coach and tactician. As far as recruiting, he's recruited quite well at Butler, but I'm not sure anybody will recruit here like Matta did from 2005-2010(ish). There were unique circumstances in place during that period that made tOSU far more attractive for blue-chippers than the current day. However, I believe Holtmann can get more out of his players than Matta did.
Patience will be key. But I think there's reason for more optimism this year than there was a week ago. I think Holtmann can maximize the potential of Guys like KBD, Kam Williams, CJ Jackson, the Wessons, Funderburke, and Potter. They might not be a tourney team this year, but they should be more watchable than we expected.
For the first time in years, I feel optimistic about the future of tOSU hoops. Everybody exhale. We got a good one.