SUNDAY FOCUS | COLLEGE BASKETBALL
Sunday Focus | An age-old question
Will the college game get hurt by the NBA's new age restriction for entering the draft, with elite players leaving after just one season?
BY MICHELLE KAUFMAN
[email protected]
AP PHOTO
TIME TO KILL: Ohio State freshman center Greg Oden, a 7-1, 255-pound Indiana native, will have to wait at least a year before being eligible for the NBA.
Greg Oden -- the most dominant high school center since Shaquille O'Neal -- is a freshman at Ohio State. He takes classes, attends practice, eats dorm food and plans to suit up for the Buckeyes once his ailing wrist heals. Whether he unpacks his luggage remains to be seen.
He might be better off keeping his stuff in boxes.
Oden, a 7-1, 255-pound Indiana native, is a member of the first freshman class held back from the NBA Draft for a year under the league's new age rules. Players must be 19 and one year removed from high school to be eligible for the draft. Unlike 2004, when a record eight high schoolers were drafted in the first round, the Class of 2006 has to wait until summer 2007 to cash in.
Oden, Seattle prep star Spencer Hawes (University of Washington), and all-everything forward Kevin Durant (University of Texas) are among the NBA-bound youngsters biding their time in college this season because their only other choices are going to Europe, spending a year riding buses to NBDL games or getting rusty.
AN ELITE CLASS
Other top freshmen who would likely be in the NBA under the old rules are Paul Harris (Syracuse), Thaddeus Young (Georgia Tech) and Ty Lawson (North Carolina).
So, for five months anyway, college basketball can boast the most talented freshman class since 1995, when Kevin Garnett went directly to the Timberwolves and opened the floodgates. That last great college class featured Stephon Marbury, Vince Carter, Antawn Jamison, Paul Pierce, and Chauncey Billups.
After that, the elite high school players followed Garnett's route. Kwame Brown skipped college and was the No. 1 overall pick in 2001, LeBron James was No. 1 in 2003 and Dwight Howard was No. 1 in 2004. Most experts say Oden would have been the top pick this year had the new rule not been in effect.
Though fans might be excited to see the top prep players in college uniforms, albeit for just one season, many college basketball coaches are not convinced the rule is a good idea. If players are allowed to declare for the draft after their freshman year, why not just let them turn pro out of high school?
''It's like the kid has one foot in college and one foot out,'' University of Miami basketball coach Frank Haith said. ``He's not really committed to the team or academics, he's just there counting days until the draft, so how seriously is he going to take his college experience?
``The NBA wanted to do the right thing, but I'm not really in favor of the rule as it is because I think if a kid's good enough to go out from high school, he should go. It's not fair to those kids to hold them back and force them to go to college if they don't want to.''
That said, if a player such as Oden wanted to play for the Hurricanes for one season, Haith would take him.
''Heck, yes,'' Haith said. ``Absolutely I would. I won't lie. Look what Carmelo Anthony did for Syracuse. But I don't think that will be an issue for us here at Miami, at least not yet. And it would take a very special kid.''
Virginia Tech coach Seth Greenberg said he's not so sure he'd take a player for one season.
''If a kid comes in, plays amazing as a freshman and has a chance to go, he should go,'' Greenberg said by phone. ``But to recruit a guy knowing he's going to go after one year? I'm not inclined to take a guy like that. For my program, I need to recruit to build continuity. It would take an extraordinary situation.''
Duke coach Mike Krzyzewski and North Carolina coach Roy Williams also have expressed reservations about the new rule, even though both stand to gain one-year wonders.
Williams, who probably wouldn't have much-hyped freshmen Brandan Wright and Wayne Ellington were it not for the age rule, said he worries college basketball will become a ''bus stop'' for some NBA-bound freshmen. Krzyzewski would rather see players make the leap from high school, or make a college commitment of at least two years.
The NFL requires football players to be three years removed from high school graduation before they can enter the draft. Professional baseball drafts right out of high school, but if a player chooses to attend college, he must stay three years before he's eligible for the draft again.
''Frankly, I'd rather have it the way it was , or have it [a mandatory] two years in college,'' Krzyzewski told reporters recently. 'Nobody has to go through this thing of `I think I want to go to school' when they really don't.
``We have a 16-year-old girl [golfer Michelle Wie] winning money. [Basketball players] should be given the same opportunity. It's not going to hurt the college game. We're going to be OK no matter what.''
Greenberg agreed, and said the fuss is overblown because it affects so few athletes.
''This new rule affects a very few number of schools and kids,'' Greenberg said. ``The few programs that can recruit those kids are able to get the next-best guys, too, so it doesn't make a whole lot of difference. I don't see this having a long-term effect on college basketball.''
NBA WILL GAIN
The new rule was a gesture by the NBA to limit the number of teenagers in the league and help college basketball, but, in fact, it could be the NBA that benefits more.
Under the new system, the NBA gets a full year to watch 18-year-olds compete against a higher level of competition than they faced at the McDondald's All-American game. Someone who looked great against high school players might not look so great against college seniors, so NBA teams will be able to make more educated draft choices.
Maryland coach Gary Williams likes the rule, and would like to see it extended to two years -- or more.
''I think it's good for anybody to spend a year on a college campus,'' Williams said by phone. ``I'd rather see it be longer, but it's a step in the right direction. If a kid's a great player, I'd take him for a year. We had Steve Francis for a year, and he helped us a lot. Carmelo Anthony helped Syracuse win a championship. I see nothing wrong with that.''
Texas coach Rick Barnes agreed. He is eager to coach Durant, a 6-9 forward from Rockville, Md., who is so good, he could lead the Big 12 in scoring as a freshman. After that, he's likely to turn pro.
''I think what the rule did was take pressure off parents from having to make that difficult decision while the kid is in high school,'' Barnes said by phone. ``I tell the kids not to come into college with a timetable of one or two years, but to come in, develop physically and mentally, and when the opportunity presents itself and the time is right, then make the jump.
``If we have him only one year, and that kid is ready to go to the next level, we shouldn't hold him back. It's his right to go.''