I subscribed to ESPN.com the first month they offered the service, and helped beta a lot of their offerings, including fantasy football.
While the MoC/Tom Friend fiasco was the final straw in terms of my 'divorce' with ESPN, I had 'fallen out of love' with most everything about them online and on the small screen well before. I won't go into all the reasons, and I allow that some of them extend to the greater media as well -- but never did I imagine one of the 'core' Buckeye sites ever being directly affiliated with them. In retrospect, I realize why that's sort of naive. Business is, after all, business.
And that's what this is, of course, a business decision. A pay site finds it difficult to go from the massive cross-pollination that occurs in a network full of affiliates representing most I-A teams, to the relative isolation of independence. At the end of the day, there has to be bang for the buck, and the bet here is that getting access to ESPN offerings will lubricate wallets the way getting access to 'extra' Steve Helwagen and Dave Biddle didn't.
Don't misunderstand, I have no lingering issues with either of these guys. Biddle's a good guy and a solid writer, and with that hair, Steve is one of the few people I know who is virtually assured to never suffer blunt force trauma to the head. I joke -- but I think it goes without saying that Bucknuts has always had a terrific team of contributors, and this was true even when I was divorced from that community myself. I consider my relationship with Mr.B amicable, even friendly, and when I think of Kirk, I remember fondly destroying him in the first Bucknuts fantasy league (not to mention his hysterical contributions to our old picture association threads on the forums). So none of this is a "bash Bucknuts deal" at all, this scenario would be the same in my eyes were we talking about BSB or, ah, SGN/BII, instead of Bucknuts.
This move will probably help their bottom line, and will certainly give them new reason to crow about being "THE" this and "best/most authoritative" that.
I offer them congrats, while simultaneously feeling a bit (personally) like there's a bit of a oily taint that's just entered our cozy little virtual Buckeye neighborhood. Maybe that's unfair to ESPN, it's just my initial reaction.
BUT, when people bitch to me about BP, I almost always say something along the lines of "we're one flavor, it may not be for you, and there are plenty of alternatives -- find one where you'll be happier." This holds true here as well. Good for BuckNuts, I know this scenario is what they feel is ideal for them, and I'm sure there are plenty of fans who will find the marriage one that suits their interests. So in that light, it is indeed a win-win for everyone who will make use of it. For those who won't/don't, there are still plenty of viable alternatives.