BP Awards-How I Voted

[NJ-Buckeye]

He recorded an extra .25 yards per punt more than Plackemeier but has 30 less attempts. In fact, Baugher only had about 65% of his own teams punts.

Baugher may very well deserve a look based on those stats, but anyone that has seen Ryan punt this year knows it doesn't get much better.

He got destroyed by Ngata in the Oregon game...while running a punt .. destroyed his knee.. but I'm tellin the Browns we need him...

 

[OilerBuck]

He got destroyed by Ngata in the Oregon game...while running a punt .. destroyed his knee.. but I'm tellin the Browns we need him...

While you're at it, talk to the rest of the all-american team . We look pretty bad in a LOT of areas.

On another note...

Looking at some of these polls, it seems homerism is still alive and well on BuckeyePlanet. No offense to our players, but we don't have a top 6 guy nationally at every position...no matter what Spielman tells you . I'm not bashing it, it's a natural byproduct of following a team. I just found it humorous.

 

[Fungo Squiggly]

While you're at it, talk to the rest of the all-american team . We look pretty bad in a LOT of areas.

On another note...

Looking at some of these polls, it seems homerism is still alive and well on BuckeyePlanet. No offense to our players, but we don't have a top 6 guy nationally at every position...no matter what Spielman tells you . I'm not bashing it, I it's a natural byproduct of following a team. I just found it humorous.

Are you saying I shouldn't have had James Laurinitis at 3rd for The Spielman Award??? :tongue2:

 

[daddyphatsacs]

Still better than Dale Jarrett or Jeff Jarrett.

Or Wade Garrett

 

[BuckeyeNation27]

what was the point of having everybody PM their choices again?

 

[jimotis4heisman]

what was the point of having everybody PM their choices again?

i went public with my choices... if you dont want to it wasnt required.

 

[LordJeffBuck]

56 ballots received so far, with a few more on the way - good response.

 

[bucknut11]

what was the point of having everybody PM their choices again?

Discussion.

 

[BuckeyeNation27]

Discussion.

no making them public was for discussion. and the same discussion would have been had after the results were posted.

 

[jwinslow]

not sure about everyone else, but had this thread not existed I would have forgotten about that distant PM.

 

[NJ-Buckeye]

Is Eric Winston getting votes because of pre-season rep? Has anyone actually seen him play worth a shit this year? because I obviously missed those games... unless he's been dealing with a sprained spinal cord, every time I've seen him I thought he was horrible... I'm not sure he starts for Akron U?

and how does the best OL I have seen this year... Texas... not seem to get any votes???
damn.. I wanted to vote for every one of them...

 

[NJ-Buckeye]

Baugher may very well deserve a look based on those stats, but anyone that has seen Ryan punt this year knows it doesn't get much better.

and BTW... I think his name is pronounced BOOGER ..

 

[Thump]

I pm'ed LordJeffBuck mine.

 

[ScarletInMyVeins]

Oh man! Evidently I don't pay as much attention as I should

I didn't list a top 6 or even a top 5. I just sent in who I thought should win each award, and even then, I didn't have a "nominee" for every award.

I'm such a dumb ass!

 

[Saw31]

Homerism? Don't care... I didn't blatantly pick a Buckeye for every position and since criteria for the picks were left up to me, this is what you get...

The Griffin
1. Reggie Bush RB USC
2. Vince Young QB Texas
3. A.J. Hawk LB tOSU
4. Matt Leinart QB USC
5. Jerome Harrison RB WSU
6. Brady Quinn QB ND
<O:p></O:p>
The George
1. Reggie Bush USC
2. DeAngelo Williams Memphis
3. Jerome Harrison WSU
4. Lawrence Moroney Minnesota
5. Garrett Wolfe N. Illinois
6. Brian Calhoun Wisconsin
<O:p></O:p>
The Kern-Krenzel
1. Vince Young Texas
2. Matt Leinart USC
3. Brady Quinn ND
4. Brian Brohm Louisville
5. Rudy Carpenter ASU
6. Drew Olsen UCLA
<O:p></O:p>
The Boston-Carter Trophy
1. Santonio Holmes tOSU
2. Jeff Samardzija ND
3. Mike Hass Oregon State
4. Dwayne Jarrett USC
5. Greg Jennings W. Michigan
6. Ryan Grice-Mullen Hawaii
<O:p></O:p>
The Orlando Pace Award
1. Greg Eslinger C Minnesota
2. Joe Thomas OT Wisconsin
3. Eric Winston OT Miami (Fl)
4. D’Brickshaw OT Ferguson
5. Marcus McNeill OT Auburn
6. Nick Mangold C tOSU
<O:p></O:p>
The Big Daddy
1. Elvis Dumervil DE/DT Louisville
2. Haloti Ngata DT Oregon
3. Mathias Kiwanuka DE BC
4. Rod Wright DT Texas
5. Mike Kudla DE tOSU
6. Jesse Mahelona DT Tennessee
<O:p></O:p>
The Spielman Trophy
1. A.J. Hawk tOSU
2. Paul Posluszny PSU
3. DeMeco Ryans Alabama
4. Aaron Harris Texas
5. Bobby Carpenter tOSU
6. Chad Greenway Iowa
<O:p></O:p>
The Assassin Award
1. Aaron Gipson CB Oregon
2. Alan Zemaitis CB PSU
3. Nate Salley S tOSU
4. Marcus Hamilton CB Virginia
5. Tim Jennings CB Georgia
6. John Talley CB Duke
<O:p></O:p>
The Nuge
1. Brandon Coutu Georgia
2. Mason Crosby Colorado
3. Darren McCaleb S. Mississippi
4. Stephen Gostkowski Memphis
5. Sam Swank Wake Forest
6. Josh Huston tOSU
<O:p></O:p>
The Skladany
1. Ryan Plackemeier Wake Forest
2. Daniel Sepulveda Baylor
3. Sam Kock Nebraska
4. Gordan Ely-Kelso Georgia
5. Michael Hughes San Diego St.
6. Chris Miller Ball St.
<O:p></O:p>
The Woody Hayes Memorial Trophy
1. Joe Paterno PSU
2. Les Miles LSU
3. Charlie Weis ND
4. Rich Rodriguez W. Virginia
5. Mack Brown Texas
6. Pete Carroll USC