We've been provided an excerpt from a new book about the 1968 Buckeyes by David Hyde which has been well received by a number of members of that team. This text has been copied and adapted from the original .pdf files, and in transition may have lost some formatting. David wanted to bring this to BuckeyePlanet in particular, and worked with his publisher to make this section available. Many thanks go to BB73, in particular, for helping edit out the artifacts created by the transfer from one character set to another.
Because of the length, we're breaking this up into 3 sections, what follows is part 1 of 3.
From Dave:
The book is called "1968: The Year That Saved Ohio State Football." It's essentially a re-creation of that season starting with the 1966 season, when Woody Hayes had a losing record, was burned in effigy, fans started chanting, "Good-Bye Woody" in Ohio Stadium ... and he re-invented himself and the program. He brought in bright, young assistants (Lou Holtz, Bill Mallory, George Chaump ...), changed the offense from the Robust T-Formation, began to recruit nationally for the first time and saw the universes align with the recruiting class that became known as the Super Sophs (Rex Kern, Jack Tatum, Jim Stillwagon ...) This is the story of that time and that team.
[ame="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1933197609?ie=UTF8&tag=mpog-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1933197609"]1968, The Year that Saved Ohio State Fooball[/ame]
by David Hyde
------------------------------
Because of the length, we're breaking this up into 3 sections, what follows is part 1 of 3.
From Dave:
The book is called "1968: The Year That Saved Ohio State Football." It's essentially a re-creation of that season starting with the 1966 season, when Woody Hayes had a losing record, was burned in effigy, fans started chanting, "Good-Bye Woody" in Ohio Stadium ... and he re-invented himself and the program. He brought in bright, young assistants (Lou Holtz, Bill Mallory, George Chaump ...), changed the offense from the Robust T-Formation, began to recruit nationally for the first time and saw the universes align with the recruiting class that became known as the Super Sophs (Rex Kern, Jack Tatum, Jim Stillwagon ...) This is the story of that time and that team.
[ame="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1933197609?ie=UTF8&tag=mpog-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1933197609"]1968, The Year that Saved Ohio State Fooball[/ame]
by David Hyde
------------------------------
III. Change In The Air
Question turned to concern, then doubt, and ultimately to panic as George Chaump sat in a meeting with the coaching staff in February of 1968. At a blackboard, Woody Hayes had written, "ROBUST," and proceeded that morning to lecture about his Robust T-formation's off-tackle play for three hours. For three more hours, that is.
Hayes already had spent the previous day sermonizing on every nuance of it. How tackles set up a precise 24 inches from guards. What foot blockers should lead with. Where helmets were placed.
"Mark this down," he'd say.
"Underline this," he'd say.
"Write this," he'd say.
All the assistants would, too. No one said anything. For going on two days! Over this most vanilla of plays! These were some of Chaump's first tactical meetings since being hired that winter out of John Harris High School in Harrisburg, Pa., where he had been undefeated the previous three years running a wide-open offense. Dennis Green, who went on to NFL coaching fame, had played for him. So did Jan White. Hayes had visited Harrisburg to recruit Chaump's latest quarterback, Jim Jones, and ended up taking the coach to lunch. It turned into a job interview. Hayes knew, like it or not, he had to upgrade the offense some as confirmed in those talks with Ellison. So the trip to Harrisburg ended up differently than anyone foresaw. Jones signed with Southern Cal after hearing about the quarterback waiting to take over Ohio State, Rex Kern. But Hayes got a recruit that trip, after all. Chaump signed a few weeks later as its quarterback and receivers coach.
For his first two months that winter, while the existing staff finished the recruiting season, Chaump studied film from the previous year. He watched every practice, every game, every frame of film there was. And he marveled at what he saw. The freshman class had more athletic talent than the varsity. It was at the impact positions, too. Quarterbacks. Running backs. Receivers. What speed. What size. What fun toys these would be for an offensive coach, he figured.
But now, hour after hour, all he heard about was this same, off-tackle play. "Robust 26" and "Robust 27," as it was called in the Ohio State playbook, depending on if it was run to the left or right. The other coaches were accustomed to this. The players, too. They would practice this play endlessly. Everything had to be precise. Hayes would show the running backs where to take their first step. He'd go over in minute detail the quarterback's handoff. He would ensure the splits between linemen were perfect.
"If you were one inch too close, he'd stomp on your foot,", tackle Dave Foley said. "Woody being 250 pounds, you learned pretty quickly you didn't want to be stomped on."
This play was an extension of Hayes. Direct. Aggressive. No nuance at all. "Three yards and a cloud of dust," wasn't some line arbitrarily hung on Hayes' offense. It was who he was. It is how he saw himself. Punch them in the face. See if they can take it. Keep punching them, too. That's what this play did. Before moving to the secondary in 1968, Gerry Ehrsam was a reserve quarterback and would be drilled in meetings on what plays would work in different situations. Whenever Ehrsam was stuck for a play, he would answer it looked like a good place for "26" or "27."
"You're damn right, Gerry, good job,", Hayes would say.
When the fullback ran the ball, Hayes kept control of the game. He was renowned for lines like, "The only pass I like is the one in the classroom.", and how, "Three things can happen when you throw the ball and two of them are bad." But when a fullback carried, the ball was in Hayes' hands. Fullbacks, therefore, were his babies. He treated them different through the years from other players. He recruited them by the dozen, too. Just on this team, Jim Otis, Paul Huff, James Coburn, Alan Jack, John
Brockington, Leo Hayden, Mark Debevec, Ralph Holloway and John Dombos all had been recruited as fullbacks. Hayes' philosophy was to grab as many as possible. He needed a great one in his offense, he figured, and they generally were talented enough to help elsewhere if they didn't become The One. Jack became a starting guard, Debevec an All-Big Ten defensive end and Holloway and Coburn provided depth on the offensive line.
But, as with everything important to Hayes, he had exacting ideas on how the fullback should run the ball. He wasn't hesitant to share them, either. Brockington, in his first scrimmage, saw the off-tackle hole was plugged and juked outside for a nice seven-yard gain. Next play, same thing. That time, he gained six yards. As he kneeled down to put on a shoe that had come off, he noticed two legs straddling him. It was Hayes. Glowering down at him.
"If you ever run the football like that again, you'll never play a down at Ohio State,", Hayes told him.
Anyone who carried the ball had a similar experience. Tatum, who ran fullback as a freshman, bounced an off-tackle outside and ran for a long run in a scrimmage. Hayes was livid.
"Tatum, what the hell did I tell you to do", he screamed.
He didn't want any back bouncing out of that hole, no matter how much they gained that play. Hit the hole. Punch the defense in the face. Don't be twinkle-toes. This philosophy was crucial in Hayes deciding who would be his fullback.
Chaump didn't have this background in his first weeks as an assistant. He just saw a lot of time was spent on this one simple play. He didn't understand it. Nor did he understand why Hayes stood at the front of class and lectured while no one else added anything.
"Is this how you handle meetings here", Chaump asked the other assistants at lunch that second day of meetings. "Woody just talks and you listen" There's no give-and-take? No one wondering if there's another way to do something?"
Chaump understood, as the new guy, his voice was diminished. And he didn't want to upset protocol. But that afternoon, when Hayes began lecturing again about his off-tackle play, Chaump raised his hand.
"Coach, I'd just like to ask a question, if I could,", he said. "Is this what we plan to do on offense this year?"
"Yeah,", Hayes said, "unless you think of something better."
"Well, you gave me film to look at. The only thing I really saw that I liked was the talent we have. Starting with Rex Kern at quarterback, we ..."
"You think Kern is better than Billy Long", Hayes asked.
"Coach, I think Rex Kern is far ahead of Long in talent,". Chaump said.
Hayes snickered. He was constitutionally opposed to playing young kids, and Long had been a two-year starter.
"I'm sorry, coach,", Chaump said. "I see a lot of talent. I don't think this tight formation is going to utilize this talent. We've got to open it up both running and throwing the ball."
When Hayes asked for suggestions, Chaump said to put a big, speedy receiver like White out wide. Throw a quick-out pattern. Force the defense to double-team him. That would open up the running game. Also, start employing the I-formation, he said, with a wingback in the slot, instead of the old-fashioned T-formation.
"Show me,", Hayes said, holding out a piece of chalk for Chaump. So Chaump went to the blackboard and began designing short-passing plays. Quick outs. Little flare patterns. Anything to take advantage of this team's size and speed.
"OK, enough of throwing the ball,", Hayes said. "What would you run?"
Chaump drew the I-formation's off-tackle play. The formation was more spread out. The tackles moved more. The ...
"That won't work in college,", Hayes. He cited a Notre Dame defense stopping Southern Cal's I-formation years earlier to back this up.
"A lot of people do it, and a lot of people do it successfully,", Chaump said.
Hayes, by now, was becoming madder with each give-and-take with Chaump. His volume was going up, and up, until at this point he finally shouted, "No high school coach is going to tell me what to do! You don't belong here! You can leave!"
"Coach, I didn't mean to .."
"You're gone,", Hayes said.
"What?"
Hayes took a step forward and said, "You. Are. Gone."
Getting fired, every assistant knew, was part of the Hayes process. Each of them had been fired. Some had been several times. Bo Schembechler, then coaching Miami University, counted 15 times he was fired by Hayes. But, again, Chaump didn't know any this in his opening weeks. Nor did he feel support from the other assistants. He left the room and packed up his desk. He began walking down the hall to the door, wondering what the heck had just happened, when a voice called after him.
"Get back in here,", Hayes said. "I've never fired a coach, and I'm not going to break the record on you."
Back in the room, the mood had broken a little. Something had happened. The staff had rallied, after all. Hugh Hindman, who coached the offensive tackles and tight ends, was saying how he understood Hayes better than anyone. He had played for Hayes at Miami University. He had been an assistant under him for years.
"But, quite frankly, this way hasn't worked the last couple of seasons,", Hindman said. "I think this would be a perfect time to see if we can do something and change."
Earle Bruce, the offensive-line coach, agreed. Hayes began to budge. Just a little. But it was like the Walls of Babylon had cracked, so crucial was this moment for what it meant and how the offense would shift this upcoming season.
"OK," Hayes finally said, "if we're going to do this, we'd better do this right."
He wanted film of Arkansas under Frank Broyles, Oklahoma under Chuck Fairbanks and Southern Cal under John McKay. They ran I-formations and open offenses. They'd copy from the best, Hayes said, not some high-school coach.
"But inside the 20,", Woody told his staff that day, "we're going to run it my way. We?re going to go the Robust formation."
Thus began the daily battle between the assistants to open the spigot of this offense and tap its talent and Hayes' constitutional desire to control everything in a way he understood. The players saw what was happening. They preferred to open up the offense, too. Kern became known for changing plays in the huddle. Bruce Jankowski would run full speed in pre-game warm-ups with the thought of catching Hayes' eye and selling him on throwing the ball that day. Quiet, bordering on bashful, Jankowski then would position himself close to Hayes on the sideline and say of some defensive back, "I can beat him, coach. Throw me the ball."
"We've got to be careful,", Hayes would say. "We'll watch for it."
Many weeks, Hayes would tell the offense in practice they would throw more that week. Then they?d focus on the passing game more, often very successfully. But in the game Hayes would revert to his comfort zone of great running backs and a power running game. The challenge wasn't to change that. The idea was to shift it by degrees through education. Mike Polaski, a junior defensive back in 1968, once walked past Hayes' office at Room 142 to see Lou Holtz, the secondary coach. Hayes was looking at film and yelling for Chaump to come in there. Some opponent was running a 4-4 defensive alignment, meaning eight men were set up close to the line to stop the run.
"How the hell we gonna block that in this offense", Hayes said.
"We're not,", Chaump said.
"What the hell are you talking about", Hayes said.
"I've seen this tape,", Chaump said. "Run it three plays ahead."
The offense put a man in motion. The defense immediately switched to a more-balanced 5-2 alignment.
"Coach,", Chaump said, "we're not going to block it, because we're going to make sure they're not going to be in that formation."
As the years turned, and their careers rolled, Chaump would leave Ohio State after 11 seasons to join McKay at the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He never met two coaches more different. Woody was brash; McKay smooth. Woody drove an old truck; McKay drove the newest-model luxury car. Woody had said during Chaump's interview no assistant could play golf because it took too much time and was too expensive. On Chaump's second day at Tampa Bay, McKay asked for his golf handicap. When Chaump said he didn't have one, McKay said he better get one because everyone on his staff played golf. Most pertinently, Woody plotted everything about his team carefully and deliberately. McKay would draw up plays on the sideline at games and try them out.
Success was their only common denominator. It showed Chaump there were many ways up the mountain. It also told him that the most important job of the head coach was to get the most from his assistants and players in the mode of his personality. Chaump felt Woody could push people hard, because, deep down, they knew he cared for them. They felt his passion. It reminded Chaump of a saying: "No one cares how much you know until they know how much you care."
That first season at Ohio State, Chaump's fight for opening the offense didn't end with his firing and re-hiring in that off-season meeting room. It would go on for all his years with Hayes. At the end of spring practice, each assistant wrote a critique of his area of responsibility. In a report dated May 7, 1968, Chaump wrote about Hayes' favorite Robust-formation, off-tackle play:
"It is my opinion that this is a real good, sound, football play. However, it is vastly overemphasized in our system even to the point of monotony. Statistics bear out that other plays have as good a consistency and average, and I venture to say if they were given as much emphasis and practice time in game-like scrimmages or games they would be equal or superior in basis."
In pen, Hayes wrote one word in response, which he underlined for emphasis:
"BULLSHIT!"
Last edited: