1995 - 1998: Four Losses That Defined the Cooper Era
Nowadays it is unheard of for a head football coach at a powerhouse program to receive a seven-year grace period, but that's exactly what John Cooper got. Cooper's first seven years at Ohio State were mediocre by any standards, and dreadful by Ohio State standards, but he was able to keep his job into year eight.
And at first that seemed like a brilliant decision. Everything finally clicked for Ohio State in 1995, as the team won its first eleven games (including the Buckeyes' first ever win over Notre Dame) and shot to the top of the polls. In week twelve, #2 Ohio State played #18 Michigan and lost 31-23 when unheralded Wolverine running back Tim Biakabutuka rushed for a record 313 yards against the Buckeye defense. The loss cost Ohio State a trip to the Rose Bowl, a Big Ten title, and a shot at a national championship. With the season in ruins, Ohio State also lost another bowl game, this time to Tennessee in the Citrus Bowl.
Despite the lousy finish to the 1995 season, several players had outstanding years. Eddie George rushed for a Buckeye single-season record 1,927 yards and single-game record of 314 yards (versus Illinois) and became Ohio State's sixth Heisman Trophy winner. Offensive tackle Orlando Pace was named an All American and won the Lombardi Award. Wide receiver Terry Glenn would set team records with 1,411 receiving yards for a season (since broken), 253 receiving yards for a single game (still standing), and 17 touchdown receptions for a season (still standing), was an All American, and won the Biletnikoff Award. Defensive end Mike Vrabel would set team records with 13.0 sacks (since broken) and 26.0 tackles for loss (still standing) and be named an All American. Quarterback Bobby Hoying would set several single-season and career records (all since broken), earn first team All Big Ten honors, and win the Draddy Award as the best senior student-athlete in college football.
The 1996 season started off much the same as 1995, with ten straight wins (including Notre Dame again) and a #2 ranking heading into The Game. And once again, a low-ranked Michigan team (#21 in the AP poll) would ruin the Buckeyes' perfect season and crush their national champion hopes. In the first half of The Game, Ohio State made it into the red zone three times but had to settle for three field goals. Even though the offense was unable to punch it into the end zone, the defense pitched a shutout and Ohio State led 9-0 at halftime. On the second play of the second half, Buckeye cornerback Shawn Springs slipped in single coverage and Wolverine wide receiver Tai Streets raced 69 yards for what would be the only touchdown of the contest. Michigan would add a field goal as the third quarter expired to take a 10-9 lead into the final session. Ohio State's offense sputtered to a halt in the fourth quarter and Michigan tacked on another field goal to make the final score 13-9.
The bitter loss to Michigan dropped Ohio State to #3 in the polls, but the Buckeyes were still headed to the Rose Bowl to play a perfect Arizona State squad that was ranked #2 in the country. Ohio State scored a late touchdown to prevail 20-17 for the team's first Rose Bowl victory since the 1973 season. However, #4 Florida upset #1 Florida State in the Sugar Bowl, and the Gators leapfrogged the Buckeyes in the polls to win the consensus national championship. With a record of 11-1-0, Ohio State would finish #2 in both polls.
Offensive tackle Orlando Pace was again named an All American, he repeated as the Lombardi Award winner, also claimed the Outland Trophy, and became the first pick in the 1997 NFL draft. Defensive end Mike Vrabel also repeated as an All American. Despite his unfortunate slip in The Game, cornerback Shawn Springs was named Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year and an All American.
After losing all-time greats like Pace, Vrabel, and Springs, Ohio State took a step back in 1997, and the Buckeyes had little hope for a national championship after losing a mid-season contest against Penn State. Nevertheless, Ohio State still entered The Game with a 10-1-0 record a #4 ranking in the AP poll. Michigan was ranked #1, and even if the Buckeyes couldn't win a title for themselves, they still had the opportunity to prevent the Wolverines from doing so. Michigan jumped out to a 20-0 lead thanks to a 78-yard punt return for a touchdown from eventual Heisman winner Charles Woodson and a 43-yard pick six by Andre Weathers. Ohio State scored the next two touchdowns to close the gap to 20-14, but the Buckeye offense would gain only 20 total yards on its final three drives and the Wolverines survived with a six-point win. Michigan would go on to win the Rose Bowl and the AP national championship, while the Ohio State would get pounded in the Sugar Bowl by Florida State. Linebacker Andy Katzenmoyer won the Butkus Award and was named an All American.
The 1998 season saw the unthinkable - a win over Michigan and a victory in a bowl game during the same year. The problem in 1998 was an upset loss to Michigan State, a game that must rank as one of the most bizarre in the history of Ohio State football. The Buckeyes had destroyed their first eight opponents by a combined score of 306 to 72 (38.3 to 9 on a per game basis) and were the clear number one team in the country. During week nine, the 4-4 Michigan State Spartans, led by head coach Nick Saban, visited the Horseshoe as 28-point underdogs. Through the first two-and-a-half quarters, the game progressed as anticipated, with the Buckeyes holding a 24-9 lead and the Spartans lining up deep in their own territory for their fourth punt of the contest. Michigan State's punter shanked the ball so badly that it hit one of the Ohio State gunners in the foot. The Spartans recovered the muff and promptly drove the short field for a touchdown to cut the lead to 24-15. Ohio State's next drive ended quickly with a fumble and Michigan State kicked a 49-yard field goal to cut the lead to 24-18. Ohio State got the ball back and punted, and Michigan State drove 92 yards for a touchdown to take a 25-24 lead at the beginning of the fourth quarter. Ohio State still had plenty of time to re-take command of the game, but their next four possessions ended with a punt, a fumble, a turnover on downs, and an interception in the red zone in the final minute of the game. Final score: Michigan State 28, Ohio State 24. Ohio State would rebound with easy wins over Iowa and Michigan to close out the regular season, but it would provide little solace for a team that was supposed to win a national title.
1998 was the first year of the BCS Championship, and Ohio State narrowly missed being selected for that game (Tennessee would defeat Florida State to earn the national championship that year). However, the Buckeyes did play in the Sugar Bowl, and they defeated #8 Texas A+M by the score of 24-14 to finish with a record of 11-1-0 and in second place in the final polls. Wide receiver David Boston was named an All American after setting the Ohio State single-season record with 1,435 receiving yards (still standing), plus career records with 2,855 receiving yards (since broken), 191 receptions (still standing), and 34 touchdown receptions (still standing). Cornerback Antoine Winfield won the Thorpe Award and became a two-time All American (also 1997).
John Cooper will forever be defined by four losses: the losses to Michigan in 1995 and 1996, and to Michigan State in 1998, that ruined perfect seasons and cost Ohio State a chance for a national championship; and the loss to Michigan in 1997 that propelled the Wolverines to a national championship of their own. If Cooper could have won a couple of those games, and a national title along the way, then his legacy at Ohio State would be much different today.
Nowadays it is unheard of for a head football coach at a powerhouse program to receive a seven-year grace period, but that's exactly what John Cooper got. Cooper's first seven years at Ohio State were mediocre by any standards, and dreadful by Ohio State standards, but he was able to keep his job into year eight.
And at first that seemed like a brilliant decision. Everything finally clicked for Ohio State in 1995, as the team won its first eleven games (including the Buckeyes' first ever win over Notre Dame) and shot to the top of the polls. In week twelve, #2 Ohio State played #18 Michigan and lost 31-23 when unheralded Wolverine running back Tim Biakabutuka rushed for a record 313 yards against the Buckeye defense. The loss cost Ohio State a trip to the Rose Bowl, a Big Ten title, and a shot at a national championship. With the season in ruins, Ohio State also lost another bowl game, this time to Tennessee in the Citrus Bowl.
Despite the lousy finish to the 1995 season, several players had outstanding years. Eddie George rushed for a Buckeye single-season record 1,927 yards and single-game record of 314 yards (versus Illinois) and became Ohio State's sixth Heisman Trophy winner. Offensive tackle Orlando Pace was named an All American and won the Lombardi Award. Wide receiver Terry Glenn would set team records with 1,411 receiving yards for a season (since broken), 253 receiving yards for a single game (still standing), and 17 touchdown receptions for a season (still standing), was an All American, and won the Biletnikoff Award. Defensive end Mike Vrabel would set team records with 13.0 sacks (since broken) and 26.0 tackles for loss (still standing) and be named an All American. Quarterback Bobby Hoying would set several single-season and career records (all since broken), earn first team All Big Ten honors, and win the Draddy Award as the best senior student-athlete in college football.
The 1996 season started off much the same as 1995, with ten straight wins (including Notre Dame again) and a #2 ranking heading into The Game. And once again, a low-ranked Michigan team (#21 in the AP poll) would ruin the Buckeyes' perfect season and crush their national champion hopes. In the first half of The Game, Ohio State made it into the red zone three times but had to settle for three field goals. Even though the offense was unable to punch it into the end zone, the defense pitched a shutout and Ohio State led 9-0 at halftime. On the second play of the second half, Buckeye cornerback Shawn Springs slipped in single coverage and Wolverine wide receiver Tai Streets raced 69 yards for what would be the only touchdown of the contest. Michigan would add a field goal as the third quarter expired to take a 10-9 lead into the final session. Ohio State's offense sputtered to a halt in the fourth quarter and Michigan tacked on another field goal to make the final score 13-9.
The bitter loss to Michigan dropped Ohio State to #3 in the polls, but the Buckeyes were still headed to the Rose Bowl to play a perfect Arizona State squad that was ranked #2 in the country. Ohio State scored a late touchdown to prevail 20-17 for the team's first Rose Bowl victory since the 1973 season. However, #4 Florida upset #1 Florida State in the Sugar Bowl, and the Gators leapfrogged the Buckeyes in the polls to win the consensus national championship. With a record of 11-1-0, Ohio State would finish #2 in both polls.
Offensive tackle Orlando Pace was again named an All American, he repeated as the Lombardi Award winner, also claimed the Outland Trophy, and became the first pick in the 1997 NFL draft. Defensive end Mike Vrabel also repeated as an All American. Despite his unfortunate slip in The Game, cornerback Shawn Springs was named Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year and an All American.
After losing all-time greats like Pace, Vrabel, and Springs, Ohio State took a step back in 1997, and the Buckeyes had little hope for a national championship after losing a mid-season contest against Penn State. Nevertheless, Ohio State still entered The Game with a 10-1-0 record a #4 ranking in the AP poll. Michigan was ranked #1, and even if the Buckeyes couldn't win a title for themselves, they still had the opportunity to prevent the Wolverines from doing so. Michigan jumped out to a 20-0 lead thanks to a 78-yard punt return for a touchdown from eventual Heisman winner Charles Woodson and a 43-yard pick six by Andre Weathers. Ohio State scored the next two touchdowns to close the gap to 20-14, but the Buckeye offense would gain only 20 total yards on its final three drives and the Wolverines survived with a six-point win. Michigan would go on to win the Rose Bowl and the AP national championship, while the Ohio State would get pounded in the Sugar Bowl by Florida State. Linebacker Andy Katzenmoyer won the Butkus Award and was named an All American.
The 1998 season saw the unthinkable - a win over Michigan and a victory in a bowl game during the same year. The problem in 1998 was an upset loss to Michigan State, a game that must rank as one of the most bizarre in the history of Ohio State football. The Buckeyes had destroyed their first eight opponents by a combined score of 306 to 72 (38.3 to 9 on a per game basis) and were the clear number one team in the country. During week nine, the 4-4 Michigan State Spartans, led by head coach Nick Saban, visited the Horseshoe as 28-point underdogs. Through the first two-and-a-half quarters, the game progressed as anticipated, with the Buckeyes holding a 24-9 lead and the Spartans lining up deep in their own territory for their fourth punt of the contest. Michigan State's punter shanked the ball so badly that it hit one of the Ohio State gunners in the foot. The Spartans recovered the muff and promptly drove the short field for a touchdown to cut the lead to 24-15. Ohio State's next drive ended quickly with a fumble and Michigan State kicked a 49-yard field goal to cut the lead to 24-18. Ohio State got the ball back and punted, and Michigan State drove 92 yards for a touchdown to take a 25-24 lead at the beginning of the fourth quarter. Ohio State still had plenty of time to re-take command of the game, but their next four possessions ended with a punt, a fumble, a turnover on downs, and an interception in the red zone in the final minute of the game. Final score: Michigan State 28, Ohio State 24. Ohio State would rebound with easy wins over Iowa and Michigan to close out the regular season, but it would provide little solace for a team that was supposed to win a national title.
1998 was the first year of the BCS Championship, and Ohio State narrowly missed being selected for that game (Tennessee would defeat Florida State to earn the national championship that year). However, the Buckeyes did play in the Sugar Bowl, and they defeated #8 Texas A+M by the score of 24-14 to finish with a record of 11-1-0 and in second place in the final polls. Wide receiver David Boston was named an All American after setting the Ohio State single-season record with 1,435 receiving yards (still standing), plus career records with 2,855 receiving yards (since broken), 191 receptions (still standing), and 34 touchdown receptions (still standing). Cornerback Antoine Winfield won the Thorpe Award and became a two-time All American (also 1997).
John Cooper will forever be defined by four losses: the losses to Michigan in 1995 and 1996, and to Michigan State in 1998, that ruined perfect seasons and cost Ohio State a chance for a national championship; and the loss to Michigan in 1997 that propelled the Wolverines to a national championship of their own. If Cooper could have won a couple of those games, and a national title along the way, then his legacy at Ohio State would be much different today.
Last edited:
Upvote
0