• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

2021 ttun Shenanigans, Arguments, Surrender Cobras, Feckless Marmots, and Quitty Cowards

Jump to latest Follow Reply

Which scUM QB transfers first?

  • McNamara

    Votes: 23 45.1%

  • McCarthy

    Votes: 28 54.9%
  • Total voters
    51
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sort by date Sort by votes
Exit Zach Charbonnet
Brian January 18th, 2021 at 5:34 PM

This is a bummer man:

Michigan sophomore running back Zach Charbonnet entered the transfer portal on Monday, 247Sports has learned.

Charbonnet was largely sidelined this season with just 19 carries as Hassan Haskins took over as the top back. Haskins is back. Michigan also has Blake Corum returning and brings in Donovan Edwards and Tavierre Dunlap, so they're likely to be fine at the spot.

Charbonnet brought the biggest upside of anyone in the backfield and was a killer pass-blocker, so his loss is a loss. Michigan's streak of highly rated running back busts continues unabated. Please direct complaints to Steve Lorenz, who did not follow my directive to have Charbonnet's ranking top out at #51.
Click to expand...
I ask again...why would any RB rated in the top-150 ever consider that program?
 
Upvote 0
BuckeyeNation27 said:
:lol:

He's the one that took his first carry of the season 70 yards for a TD. So his other 18 carries for the season totaled 54 yards.
Click to expand...
So, 3 yards a carry after his first one?

Reminds one of that great 100-yard performance he had against Army in his second game of 2019, on 33 carries.
 
Upvote 0
NFBuck said:
I ask again...why would any RB rated in the top-150 ever consider that program?
Click to expand...
Since Mike Hart left after 2007, scUM has had just two running backs eclipse the 1000-yard mark for a season; Ohio State has had nine.

Trey Sermon had 868 yards rushing in just seven games in 2020 (he was injured on the first play in the eighth game, a 2-yard carry). Sermon would've been scUM's leading rusher in 10 of the past 13 seasons post-Hart.

Here's a comparison of Ohio State and scUM running backs since 2007:

YeartOSU Running BackYds RushingYds/CarryscUM Running BackYds RushingYds/CarryAdvantage
2020Trey Sermon8707.5Hassan Haskins3756.1+495
2019J.K. Dobbins20036.7Zach Charbonnet7264.9+1277
2018J.K. Dobbins10534.6Karan Higdon11785.3+125
2017J.K. Dobbins14037.2Karan Higdon9946.1+409
2016Mike Weber10966.0De'Veon Smith8464.7+250
2015Ezekiel Elliott18216.3De'Veon Smith7534.2+1068
2014Ezekiel Elliott18786.9De'Veon Smith5194.8+1359
2013Carlos Hyde15217.3Fitzgerald Toussaint6483.5+873
2012Carlos Hyde9705.2Fitzgerald Toussaint5144.0+456
2011Daniel Herron6755.0Fitzgerald Toussaint10415.6+366
2010Daniel Herron11555.3Vincent Smith6014.4+554
2009Brandon Saine7395.1Brandon Minor5025.2+237
2008Beanie Wells11975.8Brandon Minor5335.2+664

Mike Hart was a 6th round pick in the 2008 draft; none of his successors, not a single one, has been drafted.

Ohio State, on the other hand, has had two 1st rounders (Elliott, Wells) and three 2nd rounders (Hyde, Dobbins, and Curtis Samuel, who had 771 yards rushing as a a freakin' H-back in 2016); Herron (6th round) and Weber (7th round) were also drafted.

Why would any top RB go to scUM? Damned if I know. Hell, Rod Smith (549 career rushing yards at Ohio State) has had a better NFL career than any of scUM's running backs, Mike Hart included. Winged helmets and barbecues, I guess....
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
LordJeffBuck said:
Since Mike Hart left after 2007, scUM has had just two running backs eclipse the 1000-yard mark for a season; Ohio State has had nine.

Trey Sermon had 868 yards rushing in just seven games in 2020 (he was injured on the first play in the eighth game, a 2-yard carry). Sermon would've been scUM's leading rusher in 10 of the past 13 seasons post-Hart.

Here's a comparison of Ohio State and scUM running backs since 2007:

YeartOSU Running BackYds RushingYds/CarryscUM Running BackYds RushingYds/CarryAdvantage
2020Trey Sermon8707.5Hassan Haskins3756.1+495
2019J.K. Dobbins20036.7Zach Charbonnet7264.9+1277
2018J.K. Dobbins10534.6Karan Higdon11785.3+125
2017J.K. Dobbins14037.2Karan Higdon9946.1+409
2016Mike Weber10966.0De'Veon Smith8464.7+250
2015Ezekiel Elliott18216.3De'Veon Smith7534.2+1068
2014Ezekiel Elliott18786.9De'Veon Smith5194.8+1359
2013Carlos Hyde15217.3Fitzgerald Toussaint6483.5+873
2012Carlos Hyde9705.2Fitzgerald Toussaint5144.0+456
2011Daniel Herron6755.0Fitzgerald Toussaint10415.6+366
2010Daniel Herron11555.3Vincent Smith6014.4+554
2009Brandon Saine7395.1Brandon Minor5025.2+237
2008Beanie Wells11975.8Brandon Minor5335.2+664

Mike Hart was a 6th round pick in the 2008 draft; none of his successors, not a single one, has been drafted.

Ohio State, on the other hand, has had two 1st rounders (Elliott, Wells) and three 2nd rounders (Hyde, Dobbins, and Curtis Samuel, who had 771 yards rushing as a a freakin' H-back in 2016); Herron (6th round) and Weber (7th round) were also drafted.

Why would any top RB go to scUM? Damned if I know. Hell, Rod Smith (549 career rushing yards at Ohio State) has had a better NFL career than any of scUM's running backs, Mike Hart included. Winged helmets and barbecues, I guess....
Click to expand...
'Member when no RB should come to OSU because Urban never had a thousand yard rusher?
YeartOSU Running BackYds RushingYds/Carry
2018J.K. Dobbins10534.6
2017J.K. Dobbins14037.2
2016Mike Weber10966.0
2015Ezekiel Elliott18216.3
2014Ezekiel Elliott18786.9
2013Carlos Hyde15217.3
 
Upvote 0
Abenaki said:
'Member when no RB should come to OSU because Urban never had a thousand yard rusher?
YeartOSU Running BackYds RushingYds/Carry
2018J.K. Dobbins10534.6
2017J.K. Dobbins14037.2
2016Mike Weber10966.0
2015Ezekiel Elliott18216.3
2014Ezekiel Elliott18786.9
2013Carlos Hyde15217.3
Click to expand...
Then we lost out on RB's cause Day will be pass heavy. JK runs for 2k and all the suden the RB's are back
 
Upvote 0
Haskins is a good candidate for the September Heisman next year considering their September schedule is West Michigan, Washington, Northern Illinois and Rutgers, All at home

Then it comes crashing down @ Wisconsin the first weekend of October

That is if they can get by Washington and Rutgers first.
 
Upvote 0
harbaugh.gif


Re: Michigan football RB Zach Charbonnet plans to transfer

Just sayin': Well, apparently Charbonnet is convinced that somebody out there does.

:slappy:

 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top