How prolific gorilla appendages are or aren't aside...
Your point stands about trusting Urban Meyer on this - and that is something I am constantly reminding myself of. I guess my problem is my eyes, and because I didn't trust them, I took a few hours and charted every offensive play late Sat night into Sun morning - and that told me that there is the same turmoil, indecision, and confusion going on within the offensive coaching staff as we have here. But then I have to remind myself that the staff has way, way more info to go on than my little play chart AND they have UFM to bring clarity, definition, and calm.
That said, it's not just Kanell. I haven't heard one pundit, on any network (and I dvr and watch almost all of them) - most of them former players and coaches that have better eyes than I do - back the decision to start CJ and sit JT. Several of them have noted the change in the offense, and have concluded that if this new "Cardale" offense is going to be what they are committed to, then Cardale has to be the guy who runs it - and I agree with that.
Right now, after game 5, you are operating on blind faith if you think this offense is OK. It is possible that there will be significant improvement beginning this Saturday - although if they destroy Maryland with 8 explosive plays, has the offense really gotten to the point where they can string first downs together and sustain a drive? All I know is that they have got to pull this offense together by late November or we will be watching the B1G CC and the playoffs with more indifference than we did last year. If they do, we will be looking at this part of the season as part of the process of a great team becoming great. If not, I will not be able to stop myself from thinking that if OSU had maintained the offensive system that had them scoring at a record rate, and started the guy who ran that system, that a great team would have proved to be great. I don't think I will be alone in that.
The nice thing is the schedule affords the players and coaches to get this thing fixed. Nothing to do but see if they can.